Agree that is a much more reasonable offer. And I would do him and Callahan for those two because of the years of control. If you have to spend a premium for a top end bullpen arm, at least get one you can use for longer than a stretch run.Chavis for Kahnle isn't really that crazy; Kahnle is 27 and under control for three more years, and though this is the first year he's harnessed his stuff to become dominant, the stuff is legit. And I don't think anybody thinks Chavis is going to be a superstar; his glove is suspect and his swing-happy approach seems likely to limit his offensive ceiling. He could be a solid player, but he could also be mediocre or bust completely, and he's very unlikely to be great. So this would not be Bagwell-for-Anderson, not on either side.
Groome for two months of Frazier, though, is just nuts. And I'm as pro-Frazier as anybody around here.
I think they can get by without one but given recent history, Dombroski may double down until he hits on one of these flamethrowers. His vision has been having a wipe out back end pen and injuries keep foiling his evil plans.