With the uncertainty surrounding Rask's new AAV level, as well as the re-emergence of Playoff Horton, I took a look at what this summer will hold for PC and company. Eaves's (negligible) buyout is finally up, and I've decided to omit Savard as his LTIR condition was a pre-existing hockey injury, meaning he doesn't have his cap hit added to the opening night roster and can go on LTIR straight away.
Here's where the roster would stand on opening night as currently constructed:
RFA:
Daugavins
Rask
UFA:
Jagr
Horton
Pandolfo
Ference
Redden
Johnson
Khudobin
Lineup:
Lucic - Krejci - Seguin
Marchand - Bergeron - Spooner
Söderberg - Kelly - Peverley
Paille - Campbell - Thornton
XX
Chara - Hamilton
Seidenberg - Boychuk
Krug - McQuaid
Bartkowski
XX
Svedberg
With that existing $5,648,333.33 in cap space, the Bruins would be right on the cusp of being able to retain Rask, with no wiggle room or extra forwards.
Step 1: Trade/compliance buyout of Peverley to retain Rask
The prevailing notion is that, if he can't be moved in a salary dump, Peverley would be a compliance buyout - this definitely appears to be the way to go with Peverley's form dipping so severely, but I believe he could still hold some trade value at $3.25m AAV. On top of that, his 8-team trade list submitted by 10/1/12 expands to 15 teams come 10/1/13, so the need to move him to create space for Rask/potentially bringing Horton back is further heightened.
Of course, with the dropping cap, teams that would normally be able to take a chance on the 31 year old Peverley returning even to his '11-'12 form (57 GP - 11 G - 31 A - 42 P) are going to be looking at other buyouts like Briere as alternatives, potentially at a discount. Excluding obvious rebuilding squads, here are teamswho have more than $2.5m in Capgeek's handy $/opening in terms of NHL roster spots (on a 23 man roster) - my possibilities are bolded:
Nashville - Legwand/Fisher/Wilson/Forsberg/Smith/Gaustad as options down the middle - their roster is pretty much set already, and they've previously waived Peverley. Not happening IMO
Winnipeg - RFAs include Wheeler, Little, Burmistrov, and Bogosian - with Jokinen/Slater on the roster and Scheifele likely getting his shot this year, I doubt they re-acquire Peverley.
New Jersey - $22m in cap space to retain Lokhtionov, Henrique, Josefson, and perhaps D'Agostini - not to mention Elias, Zubrus, and the seemingly departing Clarkson. I don't think they're a fit.
Columbus - Depends how much they have left after taking care of Bobrovsky/Anisimov and whether Prospal will return. Johansen hasn't matured into that #1 role yet and Umberger/Letestu are not viable top-6 centers. My bet is they go after someone bigger like Ribeiro.
Dallas - Even though Nieuwendyk's gone, I'm not sure a team that signed Ray Whitney to a 2 year deal and proceeded to sell off Ryder, Morrow, and Jagr while in 9th place knows what they want to do. However, they're weak down the middle behind Benn, and even if Eakin can step into a full-time role they'll need more depth than Vernon Fiddler. All their important RFAs are signed to boot. If there's a partner to be had, my money's on the Stars.
St. Louis - Berglund/Stewart/Pietrangelo/Shattenkirk/Russell as RFAs - they won't have cap space for long.
Detroit - With Datsyuk re-upping and Howard's mega-deal, they're clearly still in win-it-now mode. However, moving in-division would complicate any potential trade.
New York Islanders - Tavares/Bailey (RFA)/Nielsen down the middle, could take a flier I guess but they don't strike me as the kind of team that would take a gamble for more than one year on a vet like Peverley.
Ottawa - in-division, Spezza/Turris/Zibanejad/Smith/O'Brien down the middle, Noesen/Puempel/Robinson coming up soon - longshot.
In the best case, they get back a low-round pick for Peverley from one of these teams. If not, a compliance buyout gives them the room to pay Rask the ~5 year/$6m AAV deal he's earned. After that move, I imagine they re-sign Daugavins and/or Caron (~$700,000 1-way - loser in camp is waived to Providence if he isn't claimed) and call up Bourque as the 13th forward. Then comes the tough decision regarding Kelly.
Scenario 1: Keep Kelly, Horton goes as a UFA
Daugavins - Kelly - Söderberg becomes the third line, without a clear way to keep Horton still. With Kelly's $3.25m looming as another attractive potential buyout option (giving them the $4.5m+ it would likely require to keep Horton), I believe they'll keep the second compliance buyout in their back pocket. Bergeron is unrestricted after 2013-14 - while I'm sure he isn't going to try and break the bank in the interest of preserving the current squad as much as possible, he'll still be seeking a bump up from $5m AAV. Also, Seidenberg is up that year, and barring something very much unforeseen they'll have to clear space in addition to his current $3.25m to retain him.
On the flip side, the cap will be increasing, and they could compliance Kelly and even attempt to bring him back on a lesser cap figure. There is a precedent for this, as the Senators did this coming out of the '04-'05 lockout with Alfredsson. Regardless, amnestying Kelly would allow them to...
Scenario 2: Compliance Kelly, re-sign Horton
Lineup:
Lucic - Krejci - Horton
Marchand - Bergeron - Seguin
Daugavins - Spooner - Söderberg
Paille - Campbell - Thornton
Without a doubt, this is the strongest roster on paper - however, with what happened to the Rangers this year and the Blackhawks after their Cup run after they sacrificed multiple character guys to acquire/retain scorers, I'm sure the front office would tread lightly. Kelly's contributions in the locker room seem to be very tangible.
Another factor to consider is the timeline for Campbell's return - though with a clean bone break, I doubt he'll be out of commission for 4+ months. Even if he is, it was a pre-existing hockey-related injury, so he would only need to have space cleared for him upon his return from LTIR.
There's no scenario in which see Jagr coming back - especially if he goes out on top. There were rumors of him negotiating with Lev Praha before the Cup began, and in the end I think another trip to the KHL is in order in part due to what'll be a lean 2013-14 for UFAs. For my purposes, I'm not envisioning a scenario in which he returns, much as I'd like him to.