I feel like Mazz, despite his "sidekick" status, has increasingly come to dominate the tone of this show, and it results in this overwhelming sense of intellectual dishonesty. The epitome of this for me is Mazz's notion (all too convenient for his purposes) that the 2013 Sox season was just a complete fluke, a blind stroke of luck, ex nihilo. It doesn't fit his narrative, therefore we are to believe that this season, alone among Red Sox seasons, simply has no explanation. It is beyond human agency, beyond causality itself. In a reversal of roles, Felger seems glad to play along and let such declarations stand.
I'm always pleasantly surprised at how pleasant Felger is when paired up with people other than Mazz - be it Hiolley, Tanguay, Troy Brown, Amonte, etc. He still has that ability to bring that "breath of fresh air" perspective, but (perhaps also because one can see his facial expression on TV) you get the sense he's doing it in a playful spirit, and that he expects to be made fun of by his at times skeptical colleagues.
That enjoyable, even graceful equilibrium is entirely absent from F&M. The show has become a self-defeating contradiction: a pair (or now trio) of self-proclaimed contrarians who are zealous conformists when it comes to each other's views. The air in that room has long ago gone stale.