soxfan121 said:
What is more American than coming to America being such a success that both you and America want to make things official?
I get this consternation about guys like Julian Green or John Brooks. I don't get it AT ALL about Darlington Nagbe or Manneh - those guys are as American as it gets - they live in America, they get paid in America, they pay taxes to America and if they're good enough to represent America, I can't think of a better way to "get talent" for the USMNT.
Agree. Nagbe has been here since age 11. He's an Ohio kid who grew up in the Cleveland suburbs, played some old-fashioned NCAA ball down the road at Akron, and then married his (American) college sweetheart. Manneh hasn't been here for as long (age 15 and he originally came over for soccer-related reasons), but he's been freaking legally adopted by his host family in Texas.
Nagbe made it clear that he didn't want to be taken by Vancouver #1 overall in the 2011 draft for citizenship related reasons. Funnily enough, Manneh is playing in....Vancouver, but he's made it work via the Point Roberts solution. Which doesn't sound like a really fun place to live, unless you enjoy long commutes and hanging out with ex-mafiosos in the witness protection program.
These are much stronger connections to the US than many of the German-Americans. The presence of all those foreign-born players only bothers me to the extent that it's a condemnation of the US player development system at large. Individually, I welcome them with open arms. I just wish we were better at producing players at home. The number of foreign-born players in the USMNT player pool indicates that we aren't where we need to be.
As an aside, while a lot of the Germericans (and other foreign-born players) are the offspring of hit-it-and-quit-it American servicemen, some of our USMNT guys have pretty strong family connections.
IIRC: Williams (dad), Diskerud (mom), Carter-Vickers (dad), Morales (dad) all grew up with an American parent in the household. Green's and Brooks' dads are in the US but they have a relationship. Can't remember where FJ falls. Jones, Boyd, Chandler were estranged from their American dads. Boyd couldn't play with our U20s because he had trouble tracking down the American side of his family for paperwork. But ironically he's the most rah-rah US guy of the entire lot.
It's never as simple as it looks.