I suspect he played it right at 9am. I've played it at exactly 9 and gotten crazy % that adjust during the day.I’m not sure how he got 0% for Gibson because I chose him for the Royals and Tigers and got a 9%.
View attachment 75187
Weird.
I'm not sure how his answers displayed that way. I've never seen 0%. A correct answer has to have a percentage since you've given that answer yourself. If it's less than 1%, it will give it to the tenth or hundredth of a percent (at least one of the games will display to the thousandth). If he had a 22, there's something else going on though, because if those were all less than 1% his score couldn't be higher than 9. For starters, I also had David Howard, so that wasn't 0% even aside from his own answer.Joe Posnanski plays the Grid:
https://joeblogs.joeposnanski.com/p/free-friday-immaculate-grid-live
Not bad, he got a rarity score of 22. Though it looks like it should have been 2?
I missed it, too. There were over 500 players who played their whole career with the A's and TWO had over 10 career WAR. The team has regularly moved on from their good players for their entire existence.Wow, that One Team middle square was particularly impossible (at least if you don’t know any current players). Did that give any trouble to the experts here?
Wow, that One Team middle square was particularly impossible (at least if you don’t know any current players). Did that give any trouble to the experts here?
It's funny, I was coming here to post the same thing. Usually with old franchises there are plenty of well known players who meet the One Team criteria. But the Athletics have always been a transient franchise with transient players; pretty much all of their old stars from the first half of the 20th century were traded or sold, and that just continued from the Charlie Finley era to the current day. I finally came up with track star and pinch running specialist Herb Washington.The funny thing is, even going back to Philadelphia, Mack always got rid of them when he considered them too expensive.
The only candidate from the A's heyday of the 70s was a mainstay, and should have won the '74 WS MVP for his incredible defense. Only problem was,Wow, that One Team middle square was particularly impossible (at least if you don’t know any current players). Did that give any trouble to the experts here?
I got it right. Are you sure you put him in the correct box? I know I've made that mistake in the past, especially with players associated with the Sox when the Sox logo is on the board.Another mistake in today's grid. I was marked wrong about someone who indeed did play one game at third base for Montreal.....Terry Francona.
Right box, right playerI got it right. Are you sure you put him in the correct box? I know I've made that mistake in the past, especially with players associated with the Sox when the Sox logo is on the board.
A little disappointed with my Boston/Cincy and Boston/St. Louis results but overall pleased with today's grid
I had a Boston/Cincy and a Boston/Wash (Expo) duo of infamy (if you're a Red Sox fan): Bob Bailey and Stan Papi. Both are correct answers for other grids on here (Papi also was a Cardinal and Bailey was an Expo).
I 'm feeling like Stan Papi might not be obscure enough, if only for Bill Lee's famous quote, "Who the hell is Stan Papi?" when the Sox dealt him to Montreal. But maybe that's for those of us of a certain age (I was 8 at the time).
I had the same guy in that box. My best was
I think it’s because by the time he played for them, the Negro League was considered a “minor” league. It looks like after 1948 they went to minor league status.I used Hank Aaron for shortstop because that's the position he played for the Indianapolis Clowns but I wasn't given credit for that. I'm not exactly sure why.
Gotcha. That makes complete sense, thanks. I was thinking that I had a very clever answer.I think it’s because by the time he played for them, the Negro League was considered a “minor” league. It looks like after 1948 they went to minor league status.
Edit- look at “member timeline” in this Wiki article.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negro_American_League?wprov=sfti1#Negro_American_League_franchises