This isn't what this thread is usually for, but Posnanski's recent blog post about the greatest players has this part about Yaz, and I love it, especially the baseball cards, and the part about how absolutely insane his 1967 season was.
Joe Posnanski:
By the time I was old enough to see Yaz play, he was already a legend… and he seemed to me like a very old man. By 1978, his baseball card made him look like he had to be in his late 50s.
By 1981, he looked like a retired legend who returned to spring training to teach the kids a little somethin’ about baseball.
By 1983, he was clearly just a coach.
So, while I sort of knew that Yaz was great—he kept showing up at All-Star Games—I didn’t really know. Yaz was pretty meh the last half-dozen years of his career, and those were the only years I saw him. I didn’t appreciate then that Yaz’s 1967 season might be the best season any position player has ever had.
Start with bWAR:
- Babe Ruth, 1923, 14.1
- Babe Ruth, 1921, 12.8
- Babe Ruth, 1927, 12.6
- Carl Yastrzemski, 1967, 12.5
- Rogers Hornsby, 1924, 12.1
So that would make it the fourth-greatest season ever for a position player. FanGraphs WAR does not have it quite that high—it ranks Yaz’s 1967 as the 20th-best, behind six Ruth years, three Barry Bonds seasons, a couple of Ted Williams and Mickey Mantle seasons, a Hornsby season, a Ty Cobb season, a Honus Wagner season, a Lou Gehrig season, a Jimmie Foxx season and even Aaron Judge’s 2022 season.
Still, statistically, we know Yaz’s season is up there with the very best.
Then, you add in his impossible dream September performance, when the Red Sox were trying to win their first pennant in more than 20 years. Yaz hit .417/.504/.760 that month. On Sept. 17, the Red Sox were tied with Minnesota for third place, a game behind Detroit and a half-game behind the White Sox.
In the final 12 games, Yaz hit .523/.604/.955 with four doubles, five homers, 14 runs and 16 RBIs.
When you put the greatest clutch performance in baseball history at the end of one of the greatest individual seasons in baseball history, yeah, you have an argument for the best season of all time.