Celtics vs Heat ECF Redux Discussion Thread

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,941
People arguing that it's the coach's fault for not benching his starters because they shit themselves are ridiculous, that's not how the NBA works first of all, but second of all.......
BLAME THE PLAYERS WHO CONSISTENTLY SHIT ALL OVER THEMSELVES.
 

shoelace

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 24, 2019
269
They need a coach
They are losing to a team that is playing a gray haired Kevin Love. This is on the players. They actually have to execute and win the game. They may need a new coach, but maybe they need to trade the antisemite for someone who can score consistently in the playoffs.

I think SoSH is full of middle manager dipshits who think you can just make things happen when I read this kind of post. Lol.
 

NomarsFool

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2001
8,270
Was Jaylen’s hand bleeding during game 7 or was it game 1 of this series. He just seems like a shell of himself these first two games. His stat line was fine in game 1, but he looked bad tonight, I thought.

Marcus also seemed pretty lousy tonight. A non factor most of the game but out to commit a key turnover when the game got close.

BTW, do the players know they are allowed to get defensive rebounds?

I did think Brogdon had a better game defensively, and White was hitting his threes.
 

timelysarcasm

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 23, 2010
1,428
Los Angeles by way of Roxbury
They are losing to a team that is playing a gray haired Kevin Love. This is on the players. They actually have to execute and win the game. They may need a new coach, but maybe they need to trade the antisemite for someone who can score consistently in the playoffs.

I think SoSH is full of middle manager dipshits who think you can just make things happen when I read this kind of post. Lol.
And Zeller, who is an absolute stiff. Letting Caleb Martin cook them should embarrass the fuck out of them.
 

Pilgrim

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 24, 2006
2,407
Jamaica Plain
I think firing the coach is a good place to start, but it might be time to make some changes to this core as well. They are consistently horrifically careless with the ball In crunch time and have been for years. I don’t think they can win a championship like this.

Miami is obviously better than their seed suggests, but losing to this team when the title Is wide open is a joke. They played like shit the first two rounds and are lucky to be here.
 

Euclis20

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 3, 2004
8,251
Imaginationland
Was Jaylen’s hand bleeding during game 7 or was it game 1 of this series. He just seems like a shell of himself these first two games. His stat line was fine in game 1, but he looked bad tonight, I thought.

Marcus also seemed pretty lousy tonight. A non factor most of the game but out to commit a key turnover when the game got close.

BTW, do the players know they are allowed to get defensive rebounds?

I did think Brogdon had a better game defensively, and White was hitting his threes.
Game 1, pretty profusely. If that's why he played poorly today it's a major major problem for the rest of the series.

Almost as bad for Marcus was him missing the wide wide open 3 on the following possession (I think).
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,941
Lol, Celtics were +18 in the 10 minutes Jaylen Brown sat... should Joe take the gamethread kneejerk advice and sit him down for Grant next game?
 

Brand Name

make hers mark
Moderator
SoSH Member
Oct 6, 2010
4,423
Moving the Line
Not many Joe complaints today but I have to wonder why Grant without help so much on Butler in the 4th? I like the idea in theory, worth a shot. But it clearly wasn't working without any kind of changes in personnel or approach in this respect.
 

CaptainLaddie

dj paul pfieffer
SoSH Member
Sep 6, 2004
36,930
where the darn libs live
And the Celtics don't?

Edit: will be interesting to see if the C's figured something out over the last two games.. interested to see how the Heat react to Horford and Timelord playing together. Do think the Celts should use their depth to their advantage more this series.
So you're saying you're terrified?

It's always weird when people ascribe things to opposing teams but not our own. The Celtics have a ton of confidence in themselves, as evidenced by their ability to win an elimination game on the road, bounce back from a shaky 1st quarter in G7 and blow the other team out to finish them off. They've done that two postseasons in a row. As for skill, well - it was on full display today. I'll remind people we beat this Heat team last year. And before anyone brings up the Butler missed 3, it should have never gone to game 7 and I think most people know that. It was a serious growing pains series for the Cs against a tough team that won't beat itself.

So I have to ask, in this rematch: which team has gotten better, and which team is currently worse?
Yeah, I was right to be terrified.
 

Eddie Jurak

canderson-lite
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2002
44,820
Melrose, MA
People arguing that it's the coach's fault for not benching his starters because they shit themselves are ridiculous, that's not how the NBA works first of all, but second of all.......
BLAME THE PLAYERS WHO CONSISTENTLY SHIT ALL OVER THEMSELVES.
The coach did not think Grant was good enough to be in the rotation for much of these payoffs including Miami game 1. Then in game 2 he decides to go a long stretch of the 4th with Grant as Butler’s primary defender. He’s grasping at straws and hoping something works. And whatever he does, Spo figures it out and counters it after a few minutes.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,941
Not many Joe complaints today but I have to wonder why Grant without help so much on Butler in the 4th? I like the idea in theory, worth a shot. But it clearly wasn't working without any kind of changes in personnel or approach in this respect.
Tatum was tired and nobody else could guard him so they put Grant and Smart on him and tried to make him take tough shots because when they doubled guys got and made wide open 3s
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
18,244
What happens when a more talented team goes up against a much better coached, more disciplined, more mentally tough team? This. Mazzulla is like an up and coming chess master who suddenly finds himself up against Magnus Carlsen.

I doubt this even goes to 6. The Heat are without question the better team. They aren't more talented, but everything else is in their favor and it's enough.
Miami's roster is better built for playoff basketball. Proof has been there in front of us all playoffs.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,941
The coach did not think Grant was good enough to be in the rotation for much of these payoffs including Miami game 1. Then in game 2 he decides to go a long stretch of the 4th with Grant as Butler’s primary defender. He’s grasping at straws and hoping something works. And whatever he does, Spo figures it out and counters it after a few minutes.
Does he? Spo didn't counter anything in the 3rd when we went on a huge run on both sides of his timeout (he did bench Love I guess, but it didn't matter) most of our problem as always was execution and key guys getting tired of playing in the system, the number of Smart and Jaylen bad offensive possessions after the Tatum PnR was humming was awful.
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
18,244
They have played White, but at 6’4” 180 he’s terribly huntable by Miami’s bigger guys. They need more 6’6”-6’9” guys that can play D and shoot treys.
Doubt they have the assets to get those kind of players. This really is the roster we have for the long term.
 

benhogan

Granite Truther
SoSH Member
Nov 2, 2007
20,394
Santa Monica
Does he? Spo didn't counter anything in the 3rd when we went on a huge run on both sides of his timeout (he did bench Love I guess, but it didn't matter) most of our problem as always was execution and key guys getting tired of playing in the system, the number of Smart and Jaylen bad offensive possessions after the Tatum PnR was humming was awful.
Yea but it was Jaylen's turn to play scorer
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
11,875
Does anything matter when Tatum, Brown and Smart keep having bad possessions every close & late game?
So.. it makes sense if you're CJM to not do anything different game after game? Why not try anything different or make some subs? I know it's sort of crazy to sit Brown or Tatum, but desperate times at this point.. everyone has said for weeks/months that White should be playing a lot more already.

Don't know enough about plays and such to know what could be done differently there... but are they playing any different types of plays against Miami's zone game after game?
 

Eddie Jurak

canderson-lite
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2002
44,820
Melrose, MA
Does he? Spo didn't counter anything in the 3rd when we went on a huge run on both sides of his timeout (he did bench Love I guess, but it didn't matter) most of our problem as always was execution and key guys getting tired of playing in the system, the number of Smart and Jaylen bad offensive possessions after the Tatum PnR was humming was awful.
Boston’s halfcourt offense is lousy. Their transition offense is great. If their D can get stops and they can run, they are going to do well. Most of the time, their D can’t get stops against this Miami team and their halfcourt offense can’t trade basket for basket.
 

shoelace

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 24, 2019
269
So.. it makes sense if you're CJM to not do anything different game after game? Why not try anything different or make some subs? I know it's sort of crazy to sit Brown or Tatum, but desperate times at this point.. everyone has said for weeks/months that White should be playing a lot more already.

Don't know enough about plays and such to know what could be done differently there... but are they playing any different types of plays against Miami's zone game after game?
The Celtics have two All-NBA players, 6th man of the year, a former DPOY and multiple All-Defense guys and they are losing to a team putting undrafted dudes, the Weekend at Bernies version of Kevin Love, and Cody Zeller on the floor. This is on the players. And I think Brogdon isn't the player I thought he was. Maybe all of the dipshits who thought Brad is a better GM than Danny were wrong, lol.
 

Kenny F'ing Powers

posts way less than 18% useful shit
SoSH Member
Nov 17, 2010
14,486
I have no idea who to blame. That said, I've spent a decade trying to not jump to conclusions after a SSS. But something is wrong with this team.

I don't know what it is, but it's rotten. In short bursts they can forget the moment. Hit a 3 or a game winner. But when things start to crumble over a few minutes, they collapse and choke. I've never seen a team fall apart EVERY time they're beating a good team.

They aren't fun to follow, they deserve to lose, and I have NO idea why I find them so despicable.
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
18,244
The Celtics have two All-NBA players, 6th man of the year, a former DPOY and multiple All-Defense guys and they are losing to a team putting undrafted dudes, the Weekend at Bernies version of Kevin Love, and Cody Zeller on the floor. This is on the players. And I think Brogdon isn't the player I thought he was. Maybe all of the dipshits who thought Brad is a better GM than Danny were wrong, lol.
Stevens will be under pressure from Wyc to make a major move if this series continues to go pear shaped, as the roster is simply not built for playoff basketball.
 

shoelace

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 24, 2019
269
Stevens will be under pressure from Wyc to make a major move if this series continues to go pear shaped, as the roster is simply not built for playoff basketball.
Consolidate Brogdon and Timelord into one good player and find an athletic big.
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
18,244
Consolidate Brogdon and Timelord into one good player and find an athletic big.
The bolded is going to be a huge problem for them given that they have almost zero assets to net such a player. That Brogdon trade is looking pretty bad right now.
 

DennyDoyle'sBoil

Found no thrill on Blueberry Hill
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2008
43,045
AZ
I know it is hard to envision the Heat going 1-4 but it does seem a little premature for off-season talk.
 

shoelace

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 24, 2019
269
I know it is hard to envision the Heat going 1-4 but it does seem a little premature for off-season talk.
I've been negative in this thread, but I agree. The Celtics are ludicrously more talented. If they play to their potential, they can still win this series.
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,272
The bolded is going to be a huge problem for them given that they have almost zero assets to net such a player. That Brogdon trade is looking pretty bad right now.
How is the #29 pick in the 2023 draft solving that problem?
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,941
How is the #29 pick in the 2023 draft solving that problem?
yeah given the lack of roster spaces like next year they essentially moved down 4-7 picks (they have HOU 2nd). Starting draft night they have no encumbered 1sts (well 2028 kind of).
 

Light-Tower-Power

ask me about My Pillow
SoSH Member
Jun 14, 2013
16,084
Nashua, NH
I know it is hard to envision the Heat going 1-4 but it does seem a little premature for off-season talk.
I agree with you 100%. I can totally see this team just winning 4 in a row against all odds here.
I've been negative in this thread, but I agree. The Celtics are ludicrously more talented. If they play to their potential, they can still win this series.
I admire the optimism but I think at this point it’s clear there is something rotten here and they’re just never going to play to their true potential. They’re done.
 

CaptainLaddie

dj paul pfieffer
SoSH Member
Sep 6, 2004
36,930
where the darn libs live
I admire the optimism but I think at this point it’s clear there is something rotten here and they’re just never going to play to their true potential. They’re done.
I also agree with this and I've been clear from the beginning here that I think the Heat are terrifying and they should be underrated by no one! The Celtics are clearly a fucked up team who should lose this series but right now they're +290 to make the finals and the Heat are +450. Tatum is still 2nd for Finals MVP at +360.

They still do have the talent to win this, it's just going to be like playing NES Ice Climber or Battletoads at this point for them.
 

timelysarcasm

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 23, 2010
1,428
Los Angeles by way of Roxbury
Yeah, I was right to be terrified.
I don't understand victory laps like this, there's no glory in being a doomer and then celebrating that you were right. When you're right, you gloat, when you're wrong, you're happy that your team did well/won. So, great, you were right?

That being said, I still think "terrified" was a huge stretch. Maybe just for me, but whatever. The Celtics problem is themselves, period.
 

DennyDoyle'sBoil

Found no thrill on Blueberry Hill
SoSH Member
Sep 9, 2008
43,045
AZ
I also agree with this and I've been clear from the beginning here that I think the Heat are terrifying and they should be underrated by no one! The Celtics are clearly a fucked up team who should lose this series but right now they're +290 to make the finals and the Heat are +450. Tatum is still 2nd for Finals MVP at +360.

They still do have the talent to win this, it's just going to be like playing NES Ice Climber or Battletoads at this point for them.
Small correction. Heat are -180 to make the finals. Celtics are +150.

Celtics are better odds to win the championship, but that is based on how they are perceived to match up against Denver, not because they are favored to beat the Heat.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
11,875
I don't understand victory laps like this, there's no glory in being a doomer and then celebrating that you were right. When you're right, you gloat, when you're wrong, you're happy that your team did well/won. So, great, you were right?

That being said, I still think "terrified" was a huge stretch. Maybe just for me, but whatever. The Celtics problem is themselves, period.
If there's one thing SOSHers love to do (not necessarily CL) it's predict that things are over as early as possible.. every game thread for every team has posters posting 'game over' as early as possible.

We have one poster saying a sweep was easily possible after game one and congratulating himself after they lost game two... it's what SOSH does.
 

Light-Tower-Power

ask me about My Pillow
SoSH Member
Jun 14, 2013
16,084
Nashua, NH
I don't understand victory laps like this, there's no glory in being a doomer and then celebrating that you were right. When you're right, you gloat, when you're wrong, you're happy that your team did well/won. So, great, you were right?

That being said, I still think "terrified" was a huge stretch. Maybe just for me, but whatever. The Celtics problem is themselves, period.
This. They’re a better team than Miami and frankly I don’t think it’s particularly close. The difference is Miami executes at a high level for 48 minutes. Boston does not. I don’t know why, but it is what it is. If Boston played as fundamentally sound as Miami they’d win in 4 or 5. But they don’t. They shit all over themselves when things get tight. Something’s rotten.
 

Jed Zeppelin

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 23, 2008
51,554
I admire the optimism but I think at this point it’s clear there is something rotten here and they’re just never going to play to their true potential. They’re done.
Love Jaylen in general but it’s fucking tough to have such a high usage player be a wing who can’t dribble pass or defend off the ball. I don’t buy the “JT/JB can’t play together” stuff but I think the teams chances would clearly be better with a guy who could defend with like 60% of Jaylen’s offense and minus the boneheadedness.

Could say similar about Smart as well. Good players, but limited in ways that are killing them at the most important times.
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
24,783
This. They’re a better team than Miami and frankly I don’t think it’s particularly close. The difference is Miami executes at a high level for 48 minutes. Boston does not. I don’t know why, but it is what it is. If Boston played as fundamentally sound as Miami they’d win in 4 or 5. But they don’t. They shit all over themselves when things get tight. Something’s rotten.
Well I mean…. Are they a better TEAM than Miami? For Miami the while seems to be much greater than the sum of their parts while it seems the opposite for Boston. And the whole is really all that matters when talking about a team. Miami sure seems to actually be better at this point.
 

Humphrey

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 3, 2010
3,212
How is the #29 pick in the 2023 draft solving that problem?
No shit. #29 picks lost can be recovered rather easily. And I haven't seen any posts implying the Celts would be better off with Nesmith out there instead of Malcolm.
 

TripleOT

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 4, 2007
7,783
Not many Joe complaints today but I have to wonder why Grant without help so much on Butler in the 4th? I like the idea in theory, worth a shot. But it clearly wasn't working without any kind of changes in personnel or approach in this respect.
So Spo has a plan to slow Tatum in crunch time, but Mazzulla’s plan is to play Butler the way Miami wants him played, by an overmatched defender switched up on him so he can get to his spots for a baseline jumper or a shot at the rim?
 

Light-Tower-Power

ask me about My Pillow
SoSH Member
Jun 14, 2013
16,084
Nashua, NH
Well I mean…. Are they a better TEAM than Miami? For Miami the while seems to be much greater than the sum of their parts while it seems the opposite for Boston. And the whole is really all that matters when talking about a team. Miami sure seems to actually be better at this point.
Well that’s the thing. They’re clearly a more talented team than Miami, especially with Miami’s injuries. Talent usually wins out in the NBA. In this case it isn’t. Something is obviously rotten and maybe we find out after the season what it is.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,941
So Keith Smith watched back the 4th, he says we doubled Butler 3 times, and all 3 led to open 3s so we stopped... we have a real problem with Jimmy, especially once they get in the bonus, best defense on him was probably in the 2nd, rotated Tatum/Grant/Brogdon, played him physical, didn't double much. We struggle to defend him 1v1 with anybody but when we double he's too good a passer and they are too good a shooting team right now. Maybe we leave Martin open next game in the 4th?
 

timelysarcasm

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 23, 2010
1,428
Los Angeles by way of Roxbury
This. They’re a better team than Miami and frankly I don’t think it’s particularly close. The difference is Miami executes at a high level for 48 minutes. Boston does not. I don’t know why, but it is what it is. If Boston played as fundamentally sound as Miami they’d win in 4 or 5. But they don’t. They shit all over themselves when things get tight. Something’s rotten.
And some of us expected them to stop fucking around in the ECF. For that, sure, I'll put on my clown mask. It's not over, but they dug themselves a massive hole yet again.

So Keith Smith watched back the 4th, he says we doubled Butler 3 times, and all 3 led to open 3s so we stopped... we have a real problem with Jimmy, especially once they get in the bonus, best defense on him was probably in the 2nd, rotated Tatum/Grant/Brogdon, played him physical, didn't double much.
The problem is they keep letting him get to his spots. He shoots from like 3 spots over and over and over again. Feels like that is an adjustment that has to be made, shepherd him out of those spots and make him more uncomfortable. The other issue is (and I haven't watched the game again yet and really don't want to) it seemed our pace slowed a bit and that always seems to bite us in the ass.

Zone defense shouldn't be this baffling.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,941
The problem is they keep letting him get to his spots. He shoots from like 3 spots over and over and over again. Feels like that is an adjustment that has to be made, shepherd him out of those spots and make him more uncomfortable. The other issue is (and I haven't watched the game again yet and really don't want to) it seemed our pace slowed a bit and that always seems to bite us in the ass.

Zone defense shouldn't be this baffling.
Yeah, getting him off his spots would be great... tough to do though as many teams have discovered, there's a reason he's on the All-NBA shortlist every year.
As to the zone, our problem is we found something that worked, spammed it for a long while, then Tatum got a little tired, TL got a little tired, and the execution dropped, and nobody else could seem to execute the same looks to take pressure off Tatum... then they started selling out to stop Tatum and we started taking quick 3s and turning it over. We probably needed to play more through Horford at the nail late, have Smart enter to him, have Tatum run baseline, but Marcus was having a terrible night as was Al so..... yeah.
 

JakeRae

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 21, 2005
8,170
New York, NY
So Keith Smith watched back the 4th, he says we doubled Butler 3 times, and all 3 led to open 3s so we stopped... we have a real problem with Jimmy, especially once they get in the bonus, best defense on him was probably in the 2nd, rotated Tatum/Grant/Brogdon, played him physical, didn't double much. We struggle to defend him 1v1 with anybody but when we double he's too good a passer and they are too good a shooting team right now. Maybe we leave Martin open next game in the 4th?
Butler scored 27 points on 25 shots. As in Game 1, doubling him is a problem and playing him straight up works if we stay disciplined and don’t foul. He will score and make shots. We need to stay disciplined and not alter our game plan as a result. We also need to do a better job of fighting through screens. We are conceding the switches Butler is hunting. That’s not the end of the world because those are guys like Grant and Brogdon who actually are doing a decent job, but Butler isn’t someone we should need to concede switches against because he’s not a threat to pull up from three if we go under. We need guys like Smart and Tatum to do the work on the defensive end to stick with Butler, particularly late in games, so Miami isn’t dictating the offense they want.

On the other end I’m less sure what the answer is. I think we go through too many stretches where we go away from Tatum on offense. He doesn’t need to be doing everything every possession, but it seems like he struggles most after stretches where we go a couple minutes without getting him the ball. Even if it’s just getting the ball and dumping it off to other guys to run different plays, the offense needs to run through Tatum more often than not. That’s not an attack on other guys but a recognition of their skills. Brogdon and to a lesser degree Smart can run the offense at times, but Jaylen and White are best off ball and Smart is erratic on offense. Jaylen’s offense is attacking defenses that are in rotation. He’s excellent at that but he’s not good in a primary scorer/initiation role and he needs to stop trying to be that guy. Tatum is that guy. If we’re going to lose, and we very well may lose at this point, we should still do it playing through our superstar.

In short, the offense needs to run through Tatum. Brown needs to accept he’s a secondary scorer (who will still score a ton in that role). Smart needs to ride Butler hard on defense. Horford needs to find his shot or needs to start rolling instead of popping because he can score at the rim against this Heat team. Brogdon and White I don’t have real complaints with and Timelord was a lot better this game. Grant needs to not antagonize Butler. These aren’t huge adjustments, but we need to simplify roles so that guys can focus on performing in them instead of cycling through different distributions of responsibilities like we are channel surfing. Because the thing about channel surfing is you sift through a lot of garbage before you find something good and even once you do you might have lulled yourself to a state of apathy where you don’t even realize it and just click through to more garbage.