Morgan's Magic Snowplow said:These posts are great stuff, blueguitar. I'll try to give a more thoughtful response when I have time, but overall I agree mainly with your conclusions. I think it also shows why players like Ozil, who is almost like a support striker that likes to float around when played at his best offensively, are very hard to fit into contemporary tactics. Mourinho had this issue as well with Mata and decided to get rid. I would love for Ozil to work out at Arsenal but there is part of me that wonders whether the team would not be better off selling him this summer and putting those funds toward a massive purchase of a World Class striker and/or center back.
Silva is a similar sort of player for City and he's fine there. Their standard formation is something like 4-2-3-1 with Fernandinho holding, Toure as the B2B, Nasri left, Navas right, Aguero up top, and Silva playing between the lines.
The issue, I think is this. If you play Ozil centrally as a #10, you can only include two other central midfielders, and one of those two has to be explicitly defensive. If Flamini/Coquelln is the defensive mid, that means that only one of Ramsey, Wilshire, Cazorla, and Arteta is going to play.
OTOH, if you start Ozil wide and he drifts in, you lack width, as Sach points out. You can compensate by pushing the fullbacks up, but that means you need quick centerbacks willing to spread wide to cover for them and positionally sound central midfielders who will drop deep to cover the middle when the FBs push up and the CBs spread wide -- the whole system of players has to react to shift the shape to cover where the space is. Arsenal's central midfielders are generally not very good at that sort of fluid defensive positioning game. Indeed, if the whole point of pushing Ozil wide is to get two or three of Ramsey/Wilshire/Cazorla/Arteta on the pitch, and then you ask them to play deep to cover for attacking fullbacks, you are neutering part of their whole value, which is their ability to support the attack. Arteta can sort of play that game, but he's old and getting slower by the day.
So the issue is not Ozil per se, it's that Ozil's strengths and weaknesses don't mesh very well with the strengths and weaknesses of the other players in the squad. What I think is strange about all this is that the general attitude seems to be that this is Ozil's problem, that he needs to adapt his game or be shipped out. I see it the other way -- Ozil is the best (or 2nd best, now that Sanchez is there) player in the squad, and it's really a Ramsey/Wilshire/Cazorla problem, those guys need to learn more tactical discipline and figure out how to play within a system that allows a player of Ozil's caliber to flourish. Because Ozil when healthy and in form is absolutely one of the world's best players.