That second one is particularly ugly. I'd be hoping some of the hero stuff would dissipate or be coached out at the higher level of competition, but what I worry about with any of the QB prospects is that our line and WRs will not put them in a position to succeed, they'll get rushed, they'll make dumb plays. If they draft one of these guys, there will be lumps.
Well yeah, there will be lumps. Lots of them.
I'll just point out the rookie seasons for these guys:
Peyton Manning: 326-575 (56.7%), 3,739 yds, 26 td, 28 int, 71.2 rating
Brett Favre: 318-522 (60.9%), 3,303 yds, 19 td, 24 int, 72.2 rating (this was actually his 2nd year as a starter)
John Elway: 123-259 (47.5%), 1,663 yds, 7 td, 14 int, 54.9 rating
Drew Brees: 320-526 (60.8%), 3,284 yds, 17 td, 16 int, 76.9 rating (even worse his second season)
Trevor Lawrence: 359-602 (59.6%), 3,641 yds, 12 td, 17 int, 71.9 rating
Josh Allen: 169-320 (52.8%), 2,074 yds, 10 td, 12 int, 67.9 rating
And on and on. Rookie QBs have a ton of lumps. Even some of the greatest to ever play the position. And for many of them, those lumps last a few years.
I think Maye, Daniels, and Williams all have really good NFL talent. But it's almost a certainty that it'll be a rough ride the first year or two (or three) before it all starts to click for them. And there's also a reasonable chance that for one or two of them (maybe even all three) it will never click.
So we need to buckle up as fans if they draft one of these guys. It's going to be a wild ride with lots of "WTF was that?" moments.