The Pantheon of Boston announcers: Who you got?

MyDaughterLovesTomGordon

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 26, 2006
15,024
With Mike Gorman's retirement today, I thought it would be interesting to place him in the all-time rankings. Who are your top-5 all-time Boston sports announcers, in ranked order?

I'd go:
1. Joe Costiglione
2. Mike Gorman
3. Gino Cappelletti
4. Dennis Eckersley
5. Tommy Heinson

i think Joe is just the best - dry sense of humor, dense knowledge, a voice you're recognize anywhere, total respect for the game, never misses.

I guess I'd give honorable mentions to Sean McDonough, Jerry Remy, and Zolak, who I find really entertaining calling bad games.

Fake edit: I never heard Ned Martin actually call a game, but I get that he's probably up there.
 
Last edited:

Granite Sox

Member
SoSH Member
Feb 6, 2003
5,228
The Granite State
I’m not a Joe Castig guy, but he belongs on the list. Bob Wilson is (imo) consistently criminally underrated. Ahead of Gino here for sure and maybe even Eck. Whither Gil Santos?! Fun discussion.
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
80,642
PBP
1. Sean Grande
2. Don Orsillo
3 Sean Mcdonough
4. Joe Castiglione
5. Fred Cusick
6. Mike Gorman

Color
1. Dennis Eckersley
2. Cedric Maxwell
3. Tommy Heinsohn
4. Andy Brickley
5. Gino Cappeletti
6. Jerry Remy
 
Last edited:

The Mort Report

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 5, 2007
8,245
Concord
Remy and Orsillo were usually gold when it was downtime or something weird happened. I think Brick is great, though he's getting pulled down so much by Jack who can't coherently call a game anymore. Eck for being Eck. Mike is the gold standard though and to me it's not even close
 

bankshot1

Member
SoSH Member
Feb 12, 2003
25,891
where I was last at
Ned Martin and Jim Woods might have been the best radio listen for baseball. I'm not saying it was poetry every night but those guys could spin a sentence and make baseball seem more than just a game.

Remy and Eck were the gold standard in TV .

Johnny Most was as unique a pbp and color guy who ever called a game on radio. He painted vivid pictures for listeners from high above courtside, and always in different shades of green. And was a big factor in creating the Celtic persona of Celtic Pride which is still prevalent today.

And Gorman is great in his own way. And I'm sorry to see him go.
 

Tudor Fever

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 16, 2004
3,719
Maine
It wouldn’t shock me a bit if Drew Carter enters the discussion sooner rather than later, assuming that he sticks around.
 

bernardsamuel

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 4, 2006
197
Denver, only physically
1. Curt Gowdy (he was my first announcer - not just Red Sox, but overall - when I was a little boy)
2. Johnny Most (I associate him with many happy events)
3. Fred Cusick (to this day, I remember his call of a Bruins' goal at the very end of a game to give them a tie with the RedWings on January 15, 1958, which was my father's birthday: "McKenney back to Toppazzini, shoots, save by Sawchuk, rebound to Labine, shoots and SCORES").
4. Gil Santos (like Johnny Most, lots of memories involved here)
5. Mike Gorman (he is a high school classmate of mine, though we never interacted during our years at Boston Latin - since I moved out to Denver in 1980 and to Baltimore in 2013, I really never had the privilege of seeing/hearing him to any substantial extent at all, but what I did see was quite magnificent)
 

Bob Montgomerys Helmet Hat

has big, douchey shoulders
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Gorman is fantastic. Orsillo, Joe C, Remy, Eckersley all terrific.
But Brick gets extra love from me. I'm a long time Bruins fan, but hockey is the one of the major sports that I never played. Not only do I really enjoy Brick's style, but I've learned tons about the ins and outs of hockey just from listening to him over the years.
 

pokey_reese

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 25, 2008
16,423
Boston, MA
I don't think that I can rank order them well across sports, but:
  • Jerry Remy
  • Mike Gorman
  • Joe Castiglione
  • Tommy Heinsohn
  • Eck/Gino tie
 

The Mort Report

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 5, 2007
8,245
Concord
It wouldn’t shock me a bit if Drew Carter enters the discussion sooner rather than later, assuming that he sticks around.
You know I was going to say this too in my post but chickened out. I think he went from generic to start the season to really great by the end with a ton of room to grow. With Mike now gone and Jack making listening to Bruins games tough bringing down Brick Drew is my favorite current voice I hear
 

chrisfont9

Member
SoSH Member
Ugh, so many apples to oranges to sort out here. For the ancient memories, Bob Wilson had the best radio voice I've ever heard. I loved Johnny Most but if I listened to old recordings I'd probably cringe a bunch. He spiced things up though. Fond memories of Dick Stockton.

Newer guys, I do really like Castig and Flemming now. Rem and Eck were incredible too. And I loved Gil Santos, to me he's just the only voice of the Pats (although no discredit to the new team, I haven't listened to them very much).

So, in no order,
- Castig
- Flemming
- Santos
- Wilson
- Eck
- Remdawg
- Stockton
 

luckiestman

Son of the Harpy
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
34,922
Because of how you phrased this “who ya got”, I’ve got Tommy. Dude gave me so much joy in my life listening to him. Gorman is next and even though I am not a RS fan I enjoyed McDonough doing Sox games when I was a kid; a hell of a lot more than I like Mike Kay now. Rizzuto on PIX was my guy, though.
 

chrisfont9

Member
SoSH Member
Because of how you phrased this “who ya got”, I’ve got Tommy. Dude gave me so much joy in my life listening to him. Gorman is next and even though I am not a RS fan I enjoyed McDonough doing Sox games when I was a kid; a hell of a lot more than I like Mike Kay now. Rizzuto on PIX was my guy, though.
Can you remind me, what has Celtics radio been like post Most? I know that Grande and Max are there, but I rarely get radio calls since I'm out of state now. Also who came before Grande?
 

Bob Montgomerys Helmet Hat

has big, douchey shoulders
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Can you remind me, what has Celtics radio been like post Most? I know that Grande and Max are there, but I rarely get radio calls since I'm out of state now. Also who came before Grande?
Sirius/XM is your friend. I'm out of state and listen to local radio broadcasts in all sports. It's great.
 

riboflav

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 20, 2006
11,223
NOVA
Disclaimer - I don't consume hockey.

PBP

1. Sean McDonough
2. Ken Coleman
3. Ned Martin
4. Johnny Most
5. Gil Santos

Color

1. Eck
2. Gino
3. Remy
4. Maxwell
5. Cousy

The order for the PBP guys was really hard. It's amazing looking at that particular list how lucky we've had it considering Mike and Joe didn't make it yet deserve to be on any list of the great NE announcers. So, I'll do an Honorable Mention.

HM

1. Joe
2. Sean Grande
3. Mike
4. Tommy
5. Don
6. Curt Gowdy, who was before my time but I've heard enough to know he was all-time

The Opposite List

1. Monty
2. Zo
3. Marshall
4. Merloni (though he's better than I thought but still)
5. Flemming - let the game breathe, man. It's baseball.

Random thoughts on the future inductees: Agree with the poster above that if he sticks around and doesn't become schtick-y, Drew Carter will be first-ballot in. Scal may get HM if he's doing color here for another 15-20 years and they win multiple titles during his tenure. He's not great but he's OK enough and the team is very good which will help his case. As for Youkilis, I have no idea. I love the guy and root for him and if I squint I can see all the potential and him growing into it like Remy did.
 

luckiestman

Son of the Harpy
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
34,922
Can you remind me, what has Celtics radio been like post Most? I know that Grande and Max are there, but I rarely get radio calls since I'm out of state now. Also who came before Grande?
Don’t know. I have been a mostly TV C’s guy for ages but had to listen to Grande and Max because of one of my kids practice’s. I think they’re a great duo.
 

riboflav

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 20, 2006
11,223
NOVA
Play By Play:

1. Ned Martin
2. Gil Santos
3. Johnny Most
4. Fred Cusick
5. Don Orsillo

Color

1. Eck
2. Gino
3. Remy
4. Cous
5. Johnny Pierson
Hey Jack, I love hearing your perspective because I believe you're around the same age as my Dad. I had Ken Coleman on my list but only caught the last couple years of his tenure as Red Sox radio PBP and I know he was one of my Dad's favorites. So, I'm curious why he's not on your list. What am I missing about him, if anything?
 

jacklamabe65

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Hey Jack, I love hearing your perspective because I believe you're around the same age as my Dad. I had Ken Coleman on my list but only caught the last couple years of his tenure as Red Sox radio PBP and I know he was one of my Dad's favorites. So, I'm curious why he's not on your list. What am I missing about him, if anything?
In short, Ned Martin was Boston's version of Vin Scully. Ken Coleman was Boston's version of Dick Enberg.
 

jbupstate

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2022
695
New York, USA
I know Jack Edwards has lost a lot on his fastball but he’s an all time great in my book. I regularly go to the Dafoomie YouTube channel to watch and listen to the 2011 Cup run. Absolutely passionate about the Bruins. Bonus if you’ve ever bumped in to Jack post game at the hotel bar.

Someone mentioned memories upthread.

Ned Martin
Most
Cusick
Pinpoint Peirson (especially in between period replay reviews)
Eck
Orsilli and Remy
 

grimshaw

Member
SoSH Member
May 16, 2007
4,417
Portland
#1 Fred and Derek were my favorite duo. I knew nothing about hockey at the time, but they made me want to watch it. Derek talking about fights and roughing in such a low key way always made me laugh.
#2 Sean and Remy were better than #3 Don and Remy and I loved version 2.0 even if it felt forced at times. Don is kind of AI generated play by play though.

#4 Gorman is/was always listenable. Never interfered with the game and let his partner talk.
#5 Castig to me is a familiar voice of times gone by, but never really must listen. I'd put Ned Martin in this category too.

I loved Dave Gaucher too but not enough accumulated WAR unfortunately.
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
20,176
My favorites (ordered by team, but otherwise unranked):

PBP:
Ned Martin
Ken Coleman
Joe Castig
Sean McDonough
Don Orsillo

Fred Cusick
Bob Wilson (hadn't seen him mentioned, but he was a must listen radio voice of the team for many years, teamed with Johnny Bucyk)
Peak Jack Edwards (he was good in his prime, and much better than most hockey PBP announcers for many teams)

Mike Gorman
Sean Grande

Gil Santos (HM for his Celtics PBP days as well)
Bob Socci (especially given that he has to work with the useless Zolak)

Color:
Jerry Remy
Eck

Johnny Pierson
Derek Sanderson
Andy Brickley

Tommy Heinsohn
Bob Cousy
Max (I'm probably a minority here, but I like him)

Gino Cap

It's really hard to limit the list. Let me tell you, most sports media markets would be thrilled to have 1 or 2 of talents as good as those listed above. If you ever get to hear out-of-market broadcasters, you will know what I mean. I will say, however, that Ron Darling would be on the list above if he did Red Sox games.

No one mentioned Jon Miller? With his impressions and great voice?

I’ll second McDonough And Johnny Most and Cusick and Peirson. I like Santos, but he and Gino both hung on far too long.
Could care less if they hung around too long. The peak of Santos/Gino was very long and very good.
 

BringBackMo

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
1,455
PBP
1. Sean Grande
2. Don Orsillo
3 Sean Mcdonough
4. Joe Castiglione
5. Fred Cusick
6. Mike Gorman

Color
1. Dennis Eckersley
2. Cedric Maxwell
3. Tommy Heinsohn
4. Andy Brickley
5. Gino Cappeletti
6. Jerry Remy
I think this post is lock-the-thread good. I don’t think there can be any question that McDonough is the best play by play guy to ever call a game in Boston, and, oh mercy, does Ned Martin belong on here. But overall this list nails it. That no one else even mentioned Cornbread Maxwell is really surprising, so extra points for that inclusion!
 

BringBackMo

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
1,455
No one mentioned Jon Miller? With his impressions and great voice?

I’ll second McDonough And Johnny Most and Cusick and Peirson. I like Santos, but he and Gino both hung on far too long.
I’d totally forgotten Jon Miller had a Boston era! He actually challenges McDonough as top dog. Awesome catch!
 

MyDaughterLovesTomGordon

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 26, 2006
15,024
Ugh, so many apples to oranges to sort out here. For the ancient memories, Bob Wilson had the best radio voice I've ever heard. I loved Johnny Most but if I listened to old recordings I'd probably cringe a bunch. He spiced things up though. Fond memories of Dick Stockton.

Newer guys, I do really like Castig and Flemming now. Rem and Eck were incredible too. And I loved Gil Santos, to me he's just the only voice of the Pats (although no discredit to the new team, I haven't listened to them very much).

So, in no order,
- Castig
- Flemming
- Santos
- Wilson
- Eck
- Remdawg
- Stockton
Taste is taste, but Will Flemming drives me up the wall. Just can’t handle his hyperbole. Every player is “gifted” or “spectacular.” It’s too much.
 

JOBU

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 22, 2021
9,823
This is probably a generational thing but no Ken Coleman or Curt Gowdy? I am also not a part of that generation but I seem to recall my my elders speaking fondly of them. I’d like to hear the older generations chime in on this.

For me;

Sox only

Radio team (Joe C and Trupe)
TV Rem/orsillo. Honorable mention ECK and McDonaugh

I never listened to the pats/b’s/c’s on the radio. Growing up in central CT in the 90’s it was WTIC 1080.
 

bankshot1

Member
SoSH Member
Feb 12, 2003
25,891
where I was last at
This is probably a generational thing but no Ken Coleman or Curt Gowdy? I am also not a part of that generation but I seem to recall my my elders speaking fondly of them. I’d like to hear the older generations chime in on this.

For me;

Sox only

Radio team (Joe C and Trupe)
TV Rem/orsillo. Honorable mention ECK and McDonaugh

I never listened to the pats/b’s/c’s on the radio. Growing up in central CT in the 90’s it was WTIC 1080.
I was thinking of Gowdy and Cusick & Pierson but limited my choices to 5 (as per instructions) and paired two of my picks to guys (4) who worked together who I thought delivered for the listener/viewer.

I also thought Gil and Gino were great, but I hardly ever listened to them as I usually watched Pats games.

I'm a little surprised Ned Martin is not more acclaimed. That too might be generational
 

Bob Montgomerys Helmet Hat

has big, douchey shoulders
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
I'm a little surprised Ned Martin is not more acclaimed. That too might be generational
I grew up listening to Ned Martin, but I really don't have many strong memories of him. I guess I think of him as being solid but unremarkable, which, upon reflection, is probably what we generally want from our pbp guy. Even more noticeable now, given how obtrusive I find O'Brien to be.
 

ifmanis5

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 29, 2007
66,352
Rotten Apple
1. Curt Gowdy (he was my first announcer - not just Red Sox, but overall - when I was a little boy)
2. Johnny Most (I associate him with many happy events)
3. Fred Cusick (to this day, I remember his call of a Bruins' goal at the very end of a game to give them a tie with the RedWings on January 15, 1958, which was my father's birthday: "McKenney back to Toppazzini, shoots, save by Sawchuk, rebound to Labine, shoots and SCORES").
4. Gil Santos (like Johnny Most, lots of memories involved here)
5. Mike Gorman (he is a high school classmate of mine, though we never interacted during our years at Boston Latin - since I moved out to Denver in 1980 and to Baltimore in 2013, I really never had the privilege of seeing/hearing him to any substantial extent at all, but what I did see was quite magnificent)
This is the correct big picture answer I think. I would just add Sean McDonough as my #6.
 

mikeford

woolwich!
SoSH Member
Aug 6, 2006
30,767
St John's, NL
There's Johnny Most and then everyone else.
I can't believe there are posts without him on the list.

And most of the people on this board are older than me so that's not an excuse!

Joe Castig is kinda the last guy left going from any semblance of my youth. McDonaugh is still doing games but he's not really doing them in a place I hear him.
 

cshea

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 15, 2006
37,948
306, row 14
He's not doing games around here anymore but Dave Goucher was the radio PBP guy for 17 years and IMO the best in the biz for hockey.
 

jose melendez

Earl of Acie
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Oct 23, 2003
32,725
Geneva, Switzerland
With Johnny announcing every game was a) great and b) a struggle between good and evil. Might not have been what was happening on the court, but no one cared.
 

jacklamabe65

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
With Johnny announcing every game was a) great and b) a struggle between good and evil. Might not have been what was happening on the court, but no one cared.
As fragile buds of crocuses began to peer through the rock-strewn soil of Massachusetts each spring, a fan could easily switch from Ned Martin's evocative eloquence to the rat-a-tat-tat of Johnny Most's unyielding, theatrical narrative - an ongoing saga in which the good guys were forever attired in the green and white. For nearly forty seasons, Johnny Most was able to describe in excruciating detail the heroic plight of a "warranted championship team" that even malevolent referees and hooligan thugs couldn't conquer. As one Boston sportswriter once commented, "John didn't broadcast a basketball game; he thought he was narrating the 'Passion Play.'"

Unlike Ned Martin's sedan-like veneer, Johnny Most's voice sounded like a car crash. He would sit, emperor-like, in his haughty perch just below the rickety third balcony at the old Boston Garden, inhaling non-filter after non-filter, creating a minefield of smoke that shrouded him in a perpetually dimming stupor. For over two hours, Johnny would inexorably describe the proceedings on the historic court below, whining over the inequalities of life even as his team won a gaudy sixteen championships in thirty years.

Amidst Buick-sized rats, plastic beer cups, and drunken louts, his grating voice and discriminating commentary became the adhesive to which legions of Celtic fans embraced in what might have been the most flourishing Off-Broadway production in history. There were few critics; nearly every Bostonian seemed to warm to his antics like a tepid southerly breeze. An absolute original, Johnny Most made even the most irrelevant game in November seem important.

It is also certain that Johnny's exaggerated storylines knew no bounds if he was into it that night. His habit for glorious overstatement would invariably be replicated the very next day in countless schoolyards across the Boston area: "Big Red snags the rebound, and gets absolutely cuffed in the stomach by Kareem! Oh my goodness! But, of course, Jake O'Donnell isn't calling anything because there's no blood on the court! Do you believe that?"

Even the immortals wore black hats in Johnny's unambiguous world: "Oscar gets the rebound...... and puts his left elbow right in the face of Satch Sanders! Right in the face! And Manny Sobel has the nerve to call a foul on 'The Lord!' The audacity! Well, ladies and gentlemen, those of us who have been blessed to see him in the flesh know that Oscar Robertson would never, ever commit a foul!"

One night, I actually heard him bawl: "Gene Shue just gave his Bullets' players an armful of tire irons so that they may attack anything out there in green and white....knowing that Mendy Rudolph will call it 'justifiable homicide!'"

Some of the more unique Mostian broadcasts occurred away from Boston when opposing fans learned to bait such a polarizing figure unmercifully. Inevitably, after being peppered by coffee cups and cigarette butts throughout much of the game, Johnny would growl, "I just got hit by a bagel! They're throwing things at me, ladies and gentlemen, because the fans here at the Civic Center are frustrated that their shabby, mediocre team always loses to the Celtics!"

It's not to say that John didn't have a sense of humor. His recurrent cackle sounded like an old Dodge Dart attempting to start on an arctic January morning. When veteran NBA guard Dave Bing was traded to the C's, Johnny couldn't wait to sing, "The ball goes out to Dave Bing. He backs up to the right of the key as Dynamite Don clears the way. It's Bing from the corner - Bing........bang!"

In the end, though, Johnny Most's calls were both original and extraordinary. His signature phrases became compulsory axioms for an entire region of basketball fans:

"This is Johnny Most high above courtside." "Cousy fiddles and diddles - now he daddles." "Outside to Sudden Sam - swish!" "Russ gets the rebound - what a play by Bill Russell!" "Jarring John tricky-dribbles with the ball..." "The Celts are fast-breaking to victory as Tiny dishes it off to Larry!" And, of course, his nightly signoff, "This is Johnny Most - bye for now."

From someone who loved them both, Johnny Most was the Puck to Ned Martin's Hamlet.
 

Mugsy's Jock

Eli apologist
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 28, 2000
15,697
UWS, NYC
No one mentioned Jon Miller? With his impressions and great voice?

I’ll second McDonough And Johnny Most and Cusick and Peirson. I like Santos, but he and Gino both hung on far too long.
I was planning to do the whole "How about Jon Miller?" thing until I saw @WinRemmerswaal beat me to it. He was a great combination of knowledgeable and funny with just a whisper of irony, long before that became common.
 

Lose Remerswaal

Experiencing Furry Panic
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
I was planning to do the whole "How about Jon Miller?" thing until I saw @WinRemmerswaal beat me to it. He was a great combination of knowledgeable and funny with just a whisper of irony, long before that became common.
My brother? Dead to me, @Mugsy's Jock .

and @jacklamabe65 , the rats were only Oldsmobile sized up there.

signed,

a guy who had standing room “seats” behind the balcony enough times to know the rats by name.