gammoseditor said:
In terms of overall value? Defense counts. Heyward plays RF and is by all account gold glover caliber there. He's also 4 years younger than Gonzalez when he was traded.
1. He plays corner OF very well, sure, but Gonzalez was a gold glove 1B. Positional value between the two isn't that big.
2. The love for defensive metrics on this site is trending into full blown absurdity if we're suggesting that it bridges ~40 points of OPS+. That is a gap oceans wide.
3. He's so damn good the Braves gave extensions to every other good young player but him, and are now looking to trade him while still being a competitor. Gonzalez got traded by a team who knew they couldn't afford to extend him, Heyward is being shopped by a team that simply doesn't want to.
4. Gonzalez also brought back the #31 prospect (Kelly) and the #47 prospect (Rizzo) in baseball per Baseball America. If Betts was still eligible he'd now likely land firmly in the top 10. Bogaerts has only just exited that tier. Swihart will either join it or land just outside it, well above Kelly and Rizzo when traded.
This is just my personal opinion, but after seeing all the continued fapping over Bradley's D despite his pitiful offensive display this year, discourse on how to supplant Bogaerts with Marrero at SS, arguments that Headley is the real value at 3B this off-season when he's a top Yankees target and conversely WILL get a healthy contract, and now Jason Heyward being some sort of all-world player it seems to me like SoSH has full blown jumped the damn shark when it comes to defensive metrics. This isn't OBP, it's a tool you only get to use when two other players (the pitcher and hitter) put you in position to do so, and then it relies heavily on random variables and surrounding teammates. The metrics require massive samples and still show inconsistencies.
Hell, I'd argue the #1 problem of the 2014 Red Sox was the front office getting high on their own supply when it comes to defensive metrics and thinking a team with guaranteed good defenders who may or may not hit would result in a winning team. Instead we saw a top tier offensive team plummet to the bottom of the league. Good defenders are nice but it isn't nearly as important as good pitching or hitting.