This week's wasn't completely horrible. He at least interviewed a couple of guys on the record. But I'm just so tired of hearing about Adrian Gonzalez and his potential trade to the Red Sox, especially when the context is complete and utter crap. Cafardo has been beating that drum every week for a year or more and there's never - NEVER - any new information. It's just idle mention after idle mention about the Sox being interested and San Diego not being able to afford to keep him.
This week, there's a mention that they've had "a zillion" talks at this point, and that both sides know what it would take, but then we don't actually get any information on what it would take. Do some reporting, Nick. WHAT WOULD IT TAKE? That's what anonymous sources are for - information that no one else has.
Is there anyone on the planet that doesn't know the Red Sox would like to have Adrian Gonzalez? Then why keep repeating it when there's no new information?
But that's not the real problem. The real problem here is: Why in fuck is Justin Upton even in the same discussion? The guy isn't close to Gonzalez' caliber as a hitter.
Yet this is the way Cafardo leads his column:
A National League scout was asked a simple question: If you had only so many trade chips to use in the pursuit of a hitter, would you use them for Justin Upton or Adrian Gonzalez?
Without hesitation, the scout said, “Gonzo. He’s a much better hitter.’’
Can you imagine being that scout?
Nick: Hey, I've got a question for you, and don't worry, I won't use your name, so you can be completely honest.
Scout: Uh, well, okay, as long as I'm completely anonymous so that I could be one of, oh, say, 300 scouts, I'll do it. Lay it on me.
Nick: Okay, if you had only so many trade chips to use in the pursuit of a hitter, would you use them for Justin Upton or Adrian Gonzalez?
Scout: Hahahahahaha. Gonzo. He's a much better hitter. But what's the big question you want me to anonymously comment on?
Nick: Well, that was it.
Scout: That was it? Okay, well, Nick, if you had only so much money, would you spend it on some nice KC BBQ, or would get a McRibb?
Nick: Hmmm. I really like that McRibb.
Scout: Click.
Adrian Gonzalez is a completely elite hitter: from 2006-2010, five complete seasons, he's averaged 160 games, 32 HR, 100 RBI, and slash stats of 288/374/514 for an ops+ of 141.
Justin frigging Upton? Yeah, he's had three complete seasons in the majors, and averaged 126 games, 19 HR, 66 RBI, slash stats of 277/359/482 for an ops+ of 117. Oh, and he struck out 152 times in 130 games last year. Oh, yeah, and he led the league in RF errors in both 2008 and 2009, despite only playing in 100 games in RF in 2008. 11 errors in 100 outfield games!
I really don't understand why Justin Upton is even being discussed. Where does it come from?