Garrett Whitlock

Wither Whitlock?

  • In the rotation

  • In the bullpen

Results are only viewable after voting.


SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
Good move. Still need another good (to really good) RHP in the bullpen. Taylor will help, and a RHP mix of Houck, Whitlock, and Schreiber is really good. But another RHP would be awesome.

Van Everyman

SoSH Member
Apr 30, 2009
Eventually everyone listens to me.

This is the only sensible move. The pen needs help with Houck being a shithead and Whitlock was far more effective out of the pen than in the rotation. Took much longer than it should have to make this move but at least they’re doing it.
I, too, was arguing this back in early May. Looking back at that thread it’s actually kind of funny that the last time we were debating Whitlock’s role it was … when Houck was unavailable in Toronto:
Here's the first thing I'd do:

Move Whitlock back to the bullpen.

This isn't exactly scientific, but my theory is that while they started slow, their real slide started when Whitlock had to be moved to the rotation because Houk couldn't play in Toronto because he wouldn't get vaccinated. That denied the team their bullpen weapon and while the other guys were decent enough role players, pitchers like Robles got exposed in repeated high leverage situations. I can't really explain it but bullpen struggles have a way of infecting the rest of a team.

So fix that. It doesn’t solve the putrid offense problem and leaves something of a hole in the rotation. But using Whitlock's skillset more than once every five days will help slam the door situationally, put the other bullpen arms in better positions to succeed, and potentially have a larger effect on the team.
Obviously the offense is a lot stronger now. And their rotation is as well. But I pretty much stand by all of this today. Having Whitlock back there to soak up the high leverage innings will put all of the the bullpen arms in a better position to succeed.