Dismiss Notice
Guest, I have a big favor to ask you. We've been working very hard to establish ourselves on social media. If you like/follow our pages it would be a HUGE help to us. SoSH on Facebook and Inside the Pylon Thanks! Nip

2019 Coaching Carousel

Discussion in 'Blinded by the Lombardis: Patriots Forum' started by Boston Brawler, Dec 30, 2018.

  1. EvilEmpire

    EvilEmpire Dope Staff Member Dope

    Messages:
    8,927
    I think this is exactly right. Hopefully Darnold can reach his potential.

    With regard to Gase, he may not be an exciting hire, but I think he's solid. I like him better than a college coach or NFL assistant with no HC experience. I like him better than McCarthy.
     
  2. Ralphwiggum

    Ralphwiggum Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,984
    I thought this was funny:

     
  3. Doug Beerabelli

    Doug Beerabelli Killer Threads Lifetime Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    9,371
    I saw some scuttlebutt on TV (ESPN) about the fact 5 minority head coaches fired, and none hired to replace these openings. Two openings left. Many of these former minority HCs have been hired to coordinator positions, or are under consideration for the same.

    Anyone think there's legit racial bias here? I agree the teams kind of make a mockery of the Rooney Rule when they have their chosen guy, but then go through the motions of interviewing minority candidates to comply. I'd be inclined not give NFL owners the benefit of any doubt, but there are only 32 of these jobs out there. And this certainly is an easy and obvious clickbait topic for the media to choose to cover.
     
  4. Super Nomario

    Super Nomario Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    11,791
    I don't think there's overt racial bias, but there are subtle things happening. The trend towards offensive hires favors white candidates; there are few black offensive coordinators and quarterbacks coaches (probably for the same reasons there have not historically been many black quarterbacks relative to other positions), but relatively more black defensive coordinators. Five of six hires so far are offensive guys. All 7 of the 2016 hires were offensive guys, 4 of 6 in 2017 (and 1 of the D guys got fired after just 2 seasons), 4 of 7 in 2018 (and the one fired after one year was a D guy).
     
  5. cheech13

    cheech13 Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    1,014
    It's a bias, but it's more systemic than overt. To fill head coaching positions with minorities you need a strong pool of candidates and there is a relative dearth of black and minority individuals filling top coordinator positions. That's because top offensive positions such as quarterback are still disproportionately held by white individuals at the pro, collegiate and high school level and those players more often than not end up as QB coaches and then Offensive Coordinators.

    NFL owners are mostly white and they hire GMs from a pool that is mostly white. Those GMS give head coaching jobs to guys they know, again mostly white. They fill their staffs with other white guys and the cycle continues. I think the Rooney Rule is necessary and helps with illuminating potential hires, but it's not going to overturn decades worth of bias toward a certain "type" of candidate. There are a lot of teams looking for the next Sean McVay, but not any looking for the next Anthony Lynn, so...
     
    #305 cheech13, Jan 10, 2019
    Last edited: Jan 10, 2019
  6. Cellar-Door

    Cellar-Door Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    13,673
    Mina Kimes had a story a while ago that I can't find now, but basically the problem goes all the way down, the coach and coordinator positions that most often become head coaches are overwhelmingly white, and the positions that feed into those are mostly white, all the way down
     
  7. Deathofthebambino

    Deathofthebambino Drive Carefully SoSH Member

    Messages:
    30,070
    I think the one stat that I keep hearing from the talking heads that makes me crazy is the one about 70% of the players in the league are African-American, and (now), only 2 head coaches are African-American. Thus, racism. I want to climb through my computer/radio and strangle someone every time I hear it. It's as if there is no difference between the qualifications of a player and a head coach. The real statistic, if there even should be one, would be "How many NFL head coaches are former players and what percentage of them are white vs. black?" I haven't gone and counted them all, but from what I can tell, there are very, very few head coaches in the NFL that are former NFL players. Kliff Kingsbury is one of the actual exceptions to the rule (for those that forget, he was drafted by the Patriots in 2003, with the 201st pick in the draft, trying to catch lightning in a bottle twice, hmm?) and then roamed around and went to Canada before turning to coaching 2008. Anthony Lynn and Todd Bowles are also exceptions.

    The reality is the guys that choose to become head coaches, for the most part, chose that path very early on in life. The one thing most of these guys have in common is that one of their first resume entries reads the words "graduate assistant." We all know Belichick's story, McCarthy basically started a path towards coaching when he was 25, Pete Carroll started as a collegiate assistant when he was 22, Gruden was 22, Dirk Koetter coached a high school team for 2 years after college, Adam Gase got a job as an undergraduate assistant while in college, Hue Jackson stayed at his alma mater and started coaching at 22, Marvin Lewis was a grad assistant at Idaho State at 23, Andy Reid was a grad assistant at 23, McVay became an Asst WR coach under Gruden when he graduated from Miami at age 22, and on and on and on it goes.

    The media make it sound like any old NFL player can become a head coach, and they completely ignore the fact that if these guys were busy playing football, they were falling behind the curve of all of these guys who started coaching immediate after, or in some cases during, college. They can't necessarily compete with the experience the other coaching candidates have. When I hire someone to work for me, experience is always the #1 factor, and I feel it should be that way in most professions.

    So while I don't doubt for a second that some of these owners are racist, I think every single one of them would hire a black coach tomorrow if they were guaranteed a couple more wins and a whole lot more money. They may be racist, but they ain't stupid, and they are certainly greedy. I think we need to look into what's happening to the black coaches that start right out of college, and try to move up the ranks. Where are they getting stopped in the process? What's holding them back? How many of them are there? By the time most of these guys get a shot at an NFL head coaching gig, they've been coaching in some capacity for 20+ years. Whereas guys who play NFL football aren't building that resume as a coach. If they have a successful NFL career, they can be starting their coaching career 10+ years behind these other guys who didn't/couldn't play at the NFL level.

    Anyway, just something to throw out there because I keep hearing this stat about NFL players and I just don't think it actually proves what the speakers think it proves.
     
  8. Cellar-Door

    Cellar-Door Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    13,673
    Yeah as mentioned above the biggest problem is that the feeder system for coaches is overwhelmingly white. On the other hand, since 2014 there have been I think 17? Former NFL players who were a head coach in the NFL? Todd Bowles was the only one who was black, so it's not totally outrageous to wonder why 70% of NFL players are Black, but only 5% of NFL players turned coaches are Black.
     
  9. Super Nomario

    Super Nomario Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    11,791
    Doug Pederson, Frank Reich, Jason Garrett, Mike Vrabel, Doug Marrone, and Ron Rivera were also former players. You are right to note the pool of potential coaches is different than the pool of players, but there are a lot of ex-player-turned-coaches, and they are still overwhelmingly white.

    I think this is the right focus. I think it's harder for black coaches to get in the door because (like many professions) so much of getting your foot in the door is nepotism and references. The Patriots' hiring practice (as documented in the Michael Holley books) is to get a young guy out of college and give him a tedious film grinding job. He does well in that for a year? Great, we'll give you something else - except now we need someone to do that tape grinding job, so recommend us a buddy to fill your shoes before we can move you up. So Brian Daboll brings on Josh McDaniels (who both GA'd at Michigan State) and McDaniels brings on his college teammate Nick Caserio, etc. You start with a bunch of white guys and you hire based on reference (and nepotism - both of Belichick's sons work for the team now) and you're going to still have a bunch of white guys. Without anyone trying to be racist. Nepotism works for young black coaches, too - Leslie Frazier's kid got an entry-level gig in Baltimore's FO - but there are just so many fewer antecedents to nepotize from. This isn't that different from the business world at large.

    (There is also privilege involved in being a grad assistant - I imagine they get paid, but it cannot be a lot. I'm guessing the bulk of folks who take gigs like that are getting some financial help from their parents)

    The Rooney Rule gets the attention, but I think the entry-level stuff is more important. There are programs like the Bill Walsh Diversity Coaching Fellowship that get talented minority coaches in training camps with teams, which helps them network and get a foot in the door. The Patriots have a coaching assistant now, Atif Austin, who came through that program (and also like a decade of college coaching).
     
  10. Ralphwiggum

    Ralphwiggum Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,984
    I think this is spot on. I would add to this the fact that inherent bias is a real thing that leads to minorities being underrepresented in certain jobs. Companies that are serious about promoting and providing a diverse and inclusive workplace spend a lot of time with employees on identifying inherent bias and trying to remove it (or at least be aware of it) when it comes time to make hiring and promotion decisions. It takes self awareness and a real desire to understand some of the ugliness that resides in all of us around this topic, and it's not easy. In an industry where people like Jerry Richardson and Bob McNair held positions of prominence until very recently, I'd be surprised if there is a lot of work being done to help NFL decision makers identify and understand inherent bias and how it impacts the decisions they make about front office and coaching hires.
     
  11. bosockboy

    bosockboy Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    10,003
  12. tims4wins

    tims4wins PN23's replacement SoSH Member

    Messages:
    20,294


    This is stunning to me. Shades of the Jets hiring Mangini. Did they even watch the game last month? Pats D was a tire fire. I think Flores has potential but this seems like a horrible idea. I hope Miami does it though, high likelihood they will be looking for someone else in 2-3 years.
     
  13. Ralphwiggum

    Ralphwiggum Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,984
    I guess if you are Miami and you really believe he's the guy you can't wait for him to get another year or two of experience as a coordinator under his belt. But I'm not sure I understand the case for Flores right now. The D was decent at home, maybe even good, but pathetic for long stretches against mediocre offenses, particularly on the road. It isn't like he stepped in for Patricia and fixed everything.
     
  14. tims4wins

    tims4wins PN23's replacement SoSH Member

    Messages:
    20,294
    To your point, Flores won’t be hired by anyone else this offseason. But I guess if they think he is the man might as well get him in place now. But man does this seem like a reach - one of the biggest I can ever remember.
     
  15. pappymojo

    pappymojo Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,655
    Being cynical, this would take the heat off the league (potentially buying them a favor from the commish). Plus, if the team does not do well, it accelerates the process of rebuilding by being a bad team.
     
  16. rymflaherty

    rymflaherty Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    2,374
    ^
    Well the other main rumored candidate, Richard, is African-American as well, so they don’t have to hire Flores for that reason.

    Richard was actually my favorite, as a Dolphins fan, amongst the rumored lot of underwhelming options. The fact that Richard was reported to have the job yesterday, and a day later it’s flip-flopped to what many would consider a worse choice, seems like the most Dolphins thing possible. It reeks of the poor communication, indecision and everything else that has made this organization a complete clown show. Tomorrow it will probably leak that their ST coach Rizzi is the front runner.
     
  17. Mystic Merlin

    Mystic Merlin Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    29,493
    The optimistic way of looking at this is that some or all of these reports were unreliable, rather than accurately documenting what the Dolphins were thinking at some point in time.

    Alternatively, the Dolphins may have preferred Richard but Richard might’ve signaled he ultimately wasn’t going to take the job if offered.
     
  18. PC Drunken Friar

    PC Drunken Friar Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    9,113
    I like it. I am sick of the same 42 guys coaching the league the last 15 years. Someone has to take a chance to find the "next guy". If the Dolphins suck the next 3 years while Flores learns the ropes (and they see the potential that he can be a great HC), is that worse than hiring a Marvin Lewis or Greg Williams and winning 40% of your games?
     
  19. Cellar-Door

    Cellar-Door Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    13,673
    The Pats D as performed decently this year with not particularly great personnel in the front 7.
    Miami is rebuilding, Flores might be an interesting pick to develop a culture and identity, which in some ways is more important than scheme, especially for a defensive coach.
     
  20. tims4wins

    tims4wins PN23's replacement SoSH Member

    Messages:
    20,294
  21. Mystic Merlin

    Mystic Merlin Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    29,493
    ‘I don’t want Case Keenum’ is a difference in ‘offensive philosophies’ I suppose.
     
  22. RedOctober3829

    RedOctober3829 Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    36,564
    Rapsheet says the focus of the Dolphins coaching search is Brian Flores.
     
  23. Morning Woodhead

    Morning Woodhead Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    964
    If Flores is going to Miami, I wonder if Schiano comes in.
     
  24. Red Averages

    Red Averages owes you $50 SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,479
    rapsheet is on NFL network saying Dolphins plan to hire Flores.
     
  25. RedOctober3829

    RedOctober3829 Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    36,564
    Not a coincidence that Schiano left his post to "pursue other NFL opportunities".
     
  26. CCR

    CCR lurker

    Messages:
    33
  27. SMU_Sox

    SMU_Sox loves his fluffykins SoSH Member

    Messages:
    6,123
    I really liked what I saw from Flores this year in his first year at this level. I know he is going to the Dolphins but I can't help but wish him the best of luck going forward. Thought Flores had a lot of potential going forward. As a defensive first-time coach though I worry for him.
     
  28. BigSoxFan

    BigSoxFan Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    30,273
    That and the fact that he doesn’t have a good QB. Will be interesting to see what Miami does there. But as a BC grad, I’m pumped and jacked for him!
     
  29. Red Averages

    Red Averages owes you $50 SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,479
    Sounds like the Patriots also vouched for his potential, which in this case is even more intriguing given it was within the division. Yet, you won’t see stories about BB for it nationally....
     
  30. Saints Rest

    Saints Rest Well-Known Member Lifetime Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    6,946
    I’d like to see the return of Pepper Johnson to the Pats, this time as DC.
     
  31. Super Nomario

    Super Nomario Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    11,791
    Schiano seems like the obvious replacement DC given the rumors last year, but on Twitter some have suggested Bret Bielema and that would make sense, too. He was a college DC before becoming head coach at Wisconsin. Brendan Daly called plays in the fourth preseason game this year per Doug Kyed, so he would be the "next man up" presumably. Steve Belichick is the the other internal option.

    I'm also curious as to whether Flores poaches some guys from the staff. Daly and Josh Boyer have been position coaches forever and might see more opportunity for advancement moving. Flores has never coached anywhere else so I'm not sure what his network looks like, or how much management might influence his choices. He worked with Pepper Johnson a long time and he's not anywhere right now. Larry Izzo could be hired away from Seattle to be ST coordinator (a position he held with the Texans). He's worked on the offense and special teams as well so he knows guys in those areas.
     
  32. Don Buddin's GS

    Don Buddin's GS Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    1,492
    If Flores is indeed the Phins choice for HC, Pats fans will always have “Malcolm go!” To remember him by.
     
  33. Mystic Merlin

    Mystic Merlin Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    29,493
    If Steve B. got the job, the years long media frenzy that would ensue might alone make it worth it.
     
  34. Red Averages

    Red Averages owes you $50 SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,479
    Greg Schiano was also Steve Belichick's coach at Rutgers when he was a long snapper.
     
  35. McBride11

    McBride11 Well-Known Member Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    11,342
    edit - wrong thread
     
  36. tims4wins

    tims4wins PN23's replacement SoSH Member

    Messages:
    20,294
    One good reason to keep on winning is to delay the Flores hiring by Miami. Nice little side benefit that he wouldn't be able to get going until February. So keep winning.
     
  37. pappymojo

    pappymojo Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,655
    I apologize for being flip earlier. Great post season so far. Deserving of the job if he gets it.
     
  38. pappymojo

    pappymojo Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,655
  39. nattysez

    nattysez Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    3,366
  40. Al Zarilla

    Al Zarilla Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    48,039
  41. Pxer

    Pxer Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    1,373
    Hurts a little to lose a guy who's been here for a lot of success, but there's more talent in the pipeline. Schuplinski is due for a promotion, Caley seems promising, Dante and Fears are still around, Brian Belichick might be waiting in the wings on the offensive side of the ball, etc.
     
  42. McBride11

    McBride11 Well-Known Member Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    11,342
    Even the coaches hate their coach!

    Long as these guys focus until Feb 4th, good on them. Lots of coaching talent coming thru and BB is always at the top.
     
  43. Super Nomario

    Super Nomario Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    11,791
    Brian is a defense guy apparently. I'm guessing the promotion path is Caley to WR coach and one of the offensive assistants - Cole Polovich or Atif Austin - to TE coach. It could also be a spot for a veteran coach they want to bring in (in anticipation of losing McDaniels to a HC gig, potentially), like Daboll a couple years back. But they don't always name a TE coach.

    This makes sense for O'Shea. McDaniels is here for who knows how long, and he had Schuplinski earmarked as his OC if he went to Indy last year (McDaniels and Schuplinski were teammates at John Carroll, along with Caserio). O'Shea's been here a decade, it's his time for an opportunity, and he couldn't get it with the Pats right now and there's no guarantee when or if he'd get his chance.
     
  44. pappymojo

    pappymojo Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,655
    Again. Good on the Dolphins for identifying their guy and being right. This defense looks great.
     
  45. soxhop411

    soxhop411 Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    33,590
  46. Pxer

    Pxer Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    1,373
  47. SeoulSoxFan

    SeoulSoxFan Dope Dope

    Messages:
    18,669
    Ummmm, isn't taking multiple assistants away an unforgivable sin in BB's eyes?

    In other news, didn't know that the Colts fired DeGuglielmo. I thought he did a fantastic job stabilizing their OL and protecting Luck.

    Apparently Reich wanted his own guy. Googs was the sole remaining hire by McDaniels.
     
  48. soxhop411

    soxhop411 Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    33,590

    I think so. But I don’t think BB can block it since it’s a “promotion”.
     
  49. InstaFace

    InstaFace MDLzera

    Messages:
    6,733
    Did a lot better than he did here, that's for sure. GoogeFest was comparable to FyreFest.
     
  50. pappymojo

    pappymojo Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,655
    From what I have heard from Colts fans, the revitalized o-line is attributed to the players they drafted and brought in. Plus, he supposedly threw Denzelle Good under the bus.

    https://www.heraldbanner.com/colts-...cle_6f544bdf-77b1-5483-8f54-fa9ac7b034dd.html


     

Share This Page