For the Saints, it’s never been one back that gets featured. Payton has used multiple backs for as long as I can remember.
Cook has missed 5 games this year so Zimmer’s thinking is to not go overboard with his usage. He’s also coming off an ACL last year. Next year, it should be more of a feature back role which I think it started out to be this year before the injuries.
Gore and Drake have the exact same YPC
this year at 4.6. Not much drop off in the running game with either one.
Payton's never had a running back as good and as explosive as Kamara, since maybe Reggie Bush (but Bush was never a great runner, like Kamara). Just because this is what Payton does doesn't make it right. Two years ago, he was stealing carries from Mark Ingram and giving them to Tim Hightower, and to use your stat (which I don't think is the right way to look at these things) Ingram averaged 5.1ypc and Hightower was 4.1.
Zimmer isn't the reason Cook wasn't used. It was the offensive coordinator, old Flip, that got fired two weeks ago. Unsurprising to anyone, the next game was Cook's best of the year and his most usage. They just didn't run the ball, but when they did, for every 2 carries Cook got, Murray got one, and that's just terrible.
The reason I say, you can't look at ypc to glean anything is because NFL plays aren't made the same. It's why I despise LeGarrette Blount in his final year in New England and called him "Mr. Minimum." It's my opinion that virtually every time he touched the ball, he got the minimum amount of yards (if not less) that any average NFL running back would have gotten. Just because Gore is getting 4.6ypc and Drake is doing the same doesn't mean Drake would average 4.6ypc on the same plays Gore was getting. If Gore gets good blocking from his line, and gets 10 yards on a play, maybe Drake hits that hole a little faster and instead of 10, he gets 20. When you are playing guys that aren't as talented, you're taking the ball out of the hands of a guy who could do more with it.
Every team needs a change of pace guy and someone to come in and give a guy a breather, but when you have a stud running back, giving a dozen touches to a guy that is way inferior is, IMO, costing the team in the end. It's why I don't understand giving Rex Burkhead so many touches over James White or Sony Michel. I just don't think he does as much with it when he gets it as they would.