I only saw a few pics, but I thought she was pretty damned cute. So she's not a totally super model babe...but I'm not sure Olivia is either. I'm no Marciano, but I've done ok for myself over time, and I don't think eithe rof those girls are other-wordly hot enough to say "oh this one's SO much cuter than that one".
When he went home with her, I'm pretty sure it was "no trouble at all". It's not like he had to court her and she's really high maintenance or something. So, then she took a pic of him...a little bit of trouble, yeah. But, yknow, if she was "really good", maybe it's worth the trouble. She's probably pretty (generically) fun.