The Worst Free Agents In Red Sox History

reggiecleveland

sublime
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 5, 2004
28,018
Saskatoon Canada
Price. JFK fellas. I posted about him possibly being in this thread some day in a game thread. A game thread.

Sure were frustrated with the latest high priced guy, but wait until half way through the contract.
 

Sampo Gida

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 7, 2010
5,044
Price. JFK fellas. I posted about him possibly being in this thread some day in a game thread. A game thread.

Sure were frustrated with the latest high priced guy, but wait until half way through the contract.
Panda is not halfway through his contract, and I think the jury is already out on him. I do agree 6 starts is way too early to judge Prices contract, but you have to be worried, even if just a little bit.

There are some areas of concern, mainly his velocity down 2 mph from the same time as last year. Then in hindsight, we must look to his poor last start of the previous season which was followed by a curious decision not to pitch in a game for 10 days (skipping a tuneup start) and his poor post season. Tfis is a historic poor start for him in a year the Red Sox hope to get top production early in his FA deal.

We have to consider non-injury reasons of course. Maybe he slacked off on his off season conditioning regime. Maybe he stopped PED's, now having too much to lose and nothing to gain Maybe Boston has a hex on ex-Tampa players. Maybe an adjustment year like Josh Beckett in 2006 and Lackey in 2010, both guys redeeming themselves later on, although in Lackeys case his poor start was likely attributed to injury that required TJS and a brutal 2011 and missed 2012 season.
 

Clears Cleaver

Lil' Bill
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2001
11,370
Price's stuff is just not very good. Read he's gotten two swings and misses on non-change ups in his last 101 pitches. He's unlucky based on bapip but it's not like his line drive rate is low. Basically, he is a 4-5 starter right now even with "average luck"

Now, one thing to note is that he has pitched in cold, rainy games almost every time out. I'm too lazy to do this but I'm guessing there could be some correlation to his performance and the cold this year and historically. Might also explain his crap postseason record?

But, there is little in what we see from Price so far that would suggest this might be amongst the worst contracts the Red Sox have signed
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
24,842
Price has not merely been a good pitcher during his career. He's been an elite pitcher. Whether we liked him or not (see: his comments about Papi), we pretty much all (the vast majority anyway) felt like he was the guy to get. DD got him. It would be miraculous (in a bad kind of way) for him to suddenly be awful.

He may not be in the CYA running this year but he should end up just fine. Granted, he's being paid to be a CYA contender, but still. I think it's still crazy to think he won't end up with pretty good numbers by season's end.
 

Rasputin

Will outlive SeanBerry
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Oct 4, 2001
29,524
Not here
Price has not merely been a good pitcher during his career. He's been an elite pitcher. Whether we liked him or not (see: his comments about Papi), we pretty much all (the vast majority anyway) felt like he was the guy to get. DD got him. It would be miraculous (in a bad kind of way) for him to suddenly be awful.

He may not be in the CYA running this year but he should end up just fine. Granted, he's being paid to be a CYA contender, but still. I think it's still crazy to think he won't end up with pretty good numbers by season's end.
Remember when he signed and some of us were ranting about accepting seven years of downside while only getting three years of upside? This is what seven years of downside looks like after six starts.
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
24,842
Seven starts. Three really good ones. Four really bad ones.

Let's hope he has a lot more
Good ones than bad ones the rest of the way.
 

Stitch01

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
18,155
Boston
Velocity is getting concerning. Getting knocked around for a few starts wouldn't bother me given his track record but velocity suggests injury.
 

HomeRunBaker

bet squelcher
SoSH Member
Jan 15, 2004
30,470
Price's stuff is just not very good. Read he's gotten two swings and misses on non-change ups in his last 101 pitches. He's unlucky based on bapip but it's not like his line drive rate is low. Basically, he is a 4-5 starter right now even with "average luck"

Now, one thing to note is that he has pitched in cold, rainy games almost every time out. I'm too lazy to do this but I'm guessing there could be some correlation to his performance and the cold this year and historically. Might also explain his crap postseason record?

But, there is little in what we see from Price so far that would suggest this might be amongst the worst contracts the Red Sox have signed
Fwiw, a caller into Felger/Mazz last week cited Price's career ERA in certain temperature ranges. It was something like 4.90 when 59 degrees and below, 2.95 between 60 and 85 degrees, and 6.00 when over 85 degrees.
 

MtPleasant Paul

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 28, 2015
169
In Ben Affleck's bank robbery movie of 2010, the Town, there's the line to the effect that 'No one's robbed the Sox like that since Jack Clark."

On a more positive note we could look at free agents signed away from the Sox who bombed, although it's probably a shorter list. Jacoby Ellsbury looks like he will belong on it when his career is over. Nick Esasky had a really good year in his single Red Sox season of 1989 with 30 homers and 108 RBI's, and was signed away by Atlanta for three years and $5,600,000. He came down with vertigo, played nine games in April, 1990 and his career was over.
 

BuellMiller

New Member
Mar 25, 2015
453
Mo Vaughn didn't exactly bomb, but his OPS+ took a nosedive from the 150 range to the 115 range in the three seasons he played in 4 years (and then 2003 happened).
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,667
Miami (oh, Miami!)
In Ben Affleck's bank robbery movie of 2010, the Town, there's the line to the effect that 'No one's robbed the Sox like that since Jack Clark."

On a more positive note we could look at free agents signed away from the Sox who bombed, although it's probably a shorter list. Jacoby Ellsbury looks like he will belong on it when his career is over. Nick Esasky had a really good year in his single Red Sox season of 1989 with 30 homers and 108 RBI's, and was signed away by Atlanta for three years and $5,600,000. He came down with vertigo, played nine games in April, 1990 and his career was over.
Jason Bay signed a four year $66M contract with the Mets starting in 2010, had a sort of decent year but then fell off the table.
Salty took 3 years and $21M from the Marlins - he played in 120ish games with a .680 OPS before being released.