Does Grady Sizemore fill the bill here? 2005-2008 were great seasons for him getting MVP votes all four years, 2GGs, 1 SS and 3 All Star nods with 107 HRs and 115 SBs. Injury derailed what looked to be a great career.
https://www.mlb.com/news/grady-sizemore-hall-of-fame-path-before-injuries
https://www.mlb.com/news/grady-sizemore-hall-of-fame-path-before-injuries