Baseball Ethics

The Gray Eagle

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2001
16,897
Tango Tiger's site has a long list of unethical acts throughout baseball history. It's part of a project to try to crowd-source how unethical certain actions are considered to be by the fans.
 
Beyond that though, it's a pretty interesting list, and shows just how much time, thought, effort and creativity have gone into cheating and gamesmanship throughout baseball history. 
 
Some of my favorite entries:
Potato: "It wasn't a major league game, to be sure, but the bizarre potato story is worth recounting. The Double A Williamsport club was mired 27 games out of first place in an Aug. 31, 1987, game against the Reading Phillies. Rick Lundblade was the runner at third for the Phillies when the enterprising Williamsport backstop, Dave Bresnahan, called time out. He ambled over to the dugout, supposedly to replace his ripped catcher's glove, an act that raised no eyebrows. Then he walked back to his position with a new glove, and, it turned out, a nicely peeled potato hidden on his person.
After catching his pitcher's next offering, Bresnahan chucked the potato far over the third baseman's head out into left field, in what appeared to be a wild pickoff attempt. Lundblade scampered home, only to be tagged out with the game ball by Bresnahan. When the umpiring crew finally figured out what had happened, they ruled that Lundblade had, in fact, scored. They tossed Bresnahan out of the game and fined him $50. Bresnahan was then let go by the Williamsport club, which nonetheless held a special promotion on the last day of the season, admitting any fan with a potato for $1. It seemed all had been forgotten; Bresnahan was brought back to the park by the Williamsport team for the special day and assigned the task of autographing the potatoes."
 
Cut the corner: "In 1880s and 1890s, many runners would cut the corner from first to third, without touching second, if they thought the lone umpire wasn't looking. They tried to do the same between second and home. This prompted a new rule in 1897, namely that a runner had to touch every base in order.
Note this wonderful anecdote from the classic baseball book, The Glory of Their Times: In the days before the rule was enacted, Cincinnati first baseman Jake Beckley scored from second on a hit to the outfield, although it was unclear if he had stopped at third en route. Umpire Timothy Hurst, a rough-and-tumble brawler himself, ruled that Beckley was out. This was a surprising call, since there had been no play at the plate. Basically, Hurst made the call on general principles. "What do you mean, I'm out?" queried the surprised Beckley. "You big S.O.B. You got here too quick," responded Hurst."
 
There's quite a variety of others, ranging from horrifying to silly. I found it to be an interesting and thought-provoking list on its own, apart from the ethics project.
 
 

twothousandone

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jan 18, 2001
3,976
Always good to see Vic Wertz noted for something other than a fly ball to CF.
 
I'm not sure of the overall effort, but acting within the rules, IMO, is never "unethical," especially when league authorities are able to overrule of force adjustments. Seeminglt, Selig even had the authority to declare Jimenez' game a perfect one. If they can change a rule quickly, thus eliminating tricks like Eddie Gaedel, then i think a team that finds a loop-hole ought to be able to exploit it. I never knew this one:
 
Legendary Dodger Jackie Robinson was not just a trailblazer but a quick-thinking base runner as well. He was well aware of the old baseball rule that stated that if a batted ball hits a base runner, then that base runner shall be immediately called out. When Robinson was on first and a sure double-play grounder was hit towards the second baseman, Robinson would intentionally run into the ball. Yes, he would be called out, but the batter would be safe at first. In 1956, the rules of baseball were changed to avoid this (legal) subterfuge. Heretofore, the umpires could call both batters out in obvious double-play situations. 
 

The Gray Eagle

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2001
16,897
One thing I found shocking was how short Marichal's suspension was for trying to brain Roseboro with a bat.
 
He got 9 games and missed 2 starts-- if this happened now, he would be done for the season at least. The video would be everywhere and the internet and sports media would go crazy about it, he would have to be suspended for a lot longer than 2 starts.
 
M

MentalDisabldLst

Guest
The Gray Eagle said:
One thing I found shocking was how short Marichal's suspension was for trying to brain Roseboro with a bat.
 
The temptation to misuse those things is just awful.