A lot of the more measured media voices in American soccer are calling for Gregg to be fired, including
Jon Arnold. Elsewhere, he wrote about his
five reasons the USMNT failed. I thought reason five was particularly salient.
Forgetting That Fight
U.S. fans of a certain age can remember the team going into contests with an underdog mentality and playing freely, facing teams like Spain without fear in the 2009 Confederations Cup, knocking Mexico out of the World Cup with a young Landon Donovan (along with center back Gregg Berhalter) in 2002 or even getting to the 1990 World Cup thanks to Paul Caligiuri's goal in Port of Spain to beat Trinidad and Tobago in 1989.
For many years, that was the hallmark of the national team. They might not be the most talented team, but they would fight and scrap for a result. They'd be David with a slingshot trying to take down Goliath.
Now, the team has the talent and prestige to match. Players are getting consistent minutes with UEFA Champions League clubs like AC Milan, Juventus and PSV Eindhoven, while others start in the Premier League or La Liga. But somewhere in that transition, it looks to have lost the fire.
In the end, that's what U.S. fans should want to see most: A team that represents them with heart, with a bit of daring and one that always feels like it can find a way to the next round.
U.S. Soccer's review may find differently, but in the hours after the early elimination from the Copa América, it's difficult to imagine Berhalter leading the way for the team.
Matt Besler also made comments before the loss about what he perceives to be a lack of leads among US players.
View: https://twitter.com/meninblazers/status/1807606020878868768
I think he makes a lot of great points. There's a reason why Besler's teams were no less successful the current "golden generation," despite a huge upgrade in club prestige. No one is arguing for a return to a more domestically-based team (though I'll note that the winning side had more MLS players on the pitch last night) but as our talent heads to Europe at a younger age, they rarely put into a position to lead until they wear the USA badge.
The current leadership vacuum combined with a player-friendly manager is a bad combination. Furthermore, Gregg does not posses an amazing tactical acumen to overcome these issue. His players-first style is probably the exact opposite of what this side needs right now.
CONMEBOL is CONCACAF with better players.