Status of Boston's Farm System

Cesar Crespo

79
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2002
20,955
I tend to mix up Kutter Crawford with Kason Gabbard a lot too. Hopefully Kutter has a better career.
 

billy ashley

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
1,091
Washington DC
That list is close to mine. I probably wouldn't have Bleis in the top 10 (and you make note that you're high on him), yet, my ranking might almost exactly match the other 9. Bleis is also the type of guy that could be top 3 by season end, so betting on him makes some sense. I'd just maybe swap him out for Groome instead of Downs.

It's a good system for sure. They probably are a little thin on 5-10 but their top 5 is excellent, and they have 40 or so guys who are at a minimum interesting. It wasn't long ago that someone like Hamilton or Spears would be on every top 20 list for this team.
 

Cesar Crespo

79
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2002
20,955
Speaking of Bleis, it's his 18th birthday today. I tend to favor upside and he has loads of it (as you noted with top 3, though that will be hard with Casas/Yorke/Mayer). Still has a long way to go.

I've said it before (maybe in this thread), but after the top 5 or 6 prospects on a team, it makes more sense to lump players into tiers rather than to individually rank them. Even if one did that, I am still high on Bleis and Law is high on Lugo, but not crazily so. I'm probably a bit down on Downs too. Though, the fun thing about individual rankings is you get the occasional Lugo or Bleis at 8.
 

Jimbodandy

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 31, 2006
7,670
around the way
I think that everyone is pretty clear on who the top 3 are, and most have the same order (Casas, Mayer, Yorke).

There are other guys who probably have decent to better careers, but we just don't know who they are yet. Hell even Meyer and Yorke could flame, and Casas could be a 200K guy for all we know.

System at least has some high ceiling guys now. It has markedly improved in the last couple of years.
 
Last edited:

Cesar Crespo

79
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2002
20,955
Yeah, while this may be a make or break year in terms of Downs' ultimate upside, I just don't know how heavily last season should be weighted. He played 12 games in AA Tulsa to finish his age 20 2019 season, and the next time he played minor league baseball was spring 2021 in AAA Worcester. I'd be curious to see if highly rated prospects across the league were treated similarly, i.e. being advanced as if they'd played in 2020 at the expected level. A+ to AAA is a massive jump under any circumstances, and certainly if you include a year off in between.
Just saw this. I don't know about other teams, but Triston Casas only had 7 PA in A+ (2 games) in 2019 and started 2021 in Portland.
 

billy ashley

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
1,091
Washington DC
Re Downs and giving him a break for last season due to it being a strange year.

I think this approach is totally fair when discussing Down's ceiling as a player. He had a brutal year (though he looked better at SS then previously thought and maybe just maybe could still there). But the underlining reasons to like him going into 2021 remain and I think we can all agree the circumstances were really strange for him. As Cesar Crespo points out, others were able to manage or even thrive, despite this, but I think it's okay to give him a some rope, especially in terms of his upside.

Where I think there has to be a lot of re-evaluation though is his floor. He went into last year, looking almost certain to be 2nd division starter. The multiple reports of how Downs looked dejected and defeated when he came to the plate, how he just wasn't even having competitive at-bats at all (nevermind the results), etc. should absolutely make us rethink what Down's downside si.

His downside is a guy who never makes the majors. That wasn't really in the conversation last Spring. It's pretty significant and that's why it is fair that he's slipping in the rankings. I just would keep him in the top ten, given the upside and recent success.

It's strange. You could tell me that he's a major league contributor in 2023, or not even in the top 40 in 2023, and I wouldn't be surprised either way.
 

jon abbey

Shanghai Warrior
Dope
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
62,132
Amazing job by Chaim building back depth so quickly, wow. NY still has 15 guys 45 or above in FG to Boston's 10, but BOS has 51 guys ranked 35+ or over (the whole list) and NY only 39.
 

Heating up in the bullpen

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 24, 2007
697
Pittsboro NC
Sox Prospects updated their list. Pretty minor tweaks. 1-3 stayed the same (Casas, Mayer, Yorke). Flipped Bello (new 4) and Duran (5). Walter jumped from 9 to 6, while Groome fell from 6 to 10. Mata and Bleis stayed at 7 and 8, respectively. Wikelman Gonzalez moved to 9 from 11.
Biggest jump came at the bottom of the list with two Portland players: pitcher AJ Politi from not ranked to 54 and catcher Cole Kottam from 59 to 52. Salem pitcher Tyler Uberstein jumped six spots, from 51 to 45. Portland pitcher Frank German jumped five spots from 35 to 30, and Greenville SS Matthew Lugo went 29 to 24.
Complete list at https://soxprospects.com/.
 

grimshaw

Member
SoSH Member
May 16, 2007
3,887
Portland
They have 3 hitters with an FV at 55 or better. No other team has more than 2.

I hope they go pitching heavy this draft.
 

jmcc5400

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 29, 2000
3,816
Incredible rebuild by Bloom while remaining competitive in the majors.
I get what you mean, but part of the reason the system has rebounded is that the team was historically noncompetitive in 2020 and it just happened to be a year that was forgettable for myriad reasons. That led directly to Mayer, Downs and Wong. But, yes, Chaim certainly gets credit for restoring the team to competitiveness in 2021 and 2022 while still developing the farm.
 

Apisith

Member
SoSH Member
Oct 19, 2007
2,923
Bangkok
I get what you mean, but part of the reason the system has rebounded is that the team was historically noncompetitive in 2020 and it just happened to be a year that was forgettable for myriad reasons. That led directly to Mayer, Downs and Wong. But, yes, Chaim certainly gets credit for restoring the team to competitiveness in 2021 and 2022 while still developing the farm.
The system's also ranked highly because it has guys like Winckowski, Binelas, German and Seabold. They're here because of Bloom trading away major league players (Benintendi, Renfroe, relief pitchers to Phillies). That's what I meant about staying competitive while rebuilding the farm system. Three of the top 10 prospects (based on fangraphs' rankings) are here through trades, not the draft. I consider that a significant (and positive) contribution by Bloom. It's his 'alpha', basically.
 

Farty Barrett

lurker
Nov 4, 2012
26
They have 3 hitters with an FV at 55 or better. No other team has more than 2.

I hope they go pitching heavy this draft.
Fangraphs seems reluctant to tag 60 FVs on pitchers. Looking at their Board of top prospects, only 4 of the 18 60+ prospects are pitchers.

Four of the top 10 Red Sox prospects on FG are pitchers. Six of the top 13.
25 if the 51 on the list pitch
To me that Fangraphs seems to think we have a nice crop
The list was created early in the season and Bello was projected to be a relief pitcher. His stock has risen since March.

I’m not sure Bloom needs to go heavy on pitching this draft, but if he likes an arm, I trust him. There’s a lot to be excited about with this farm system and the man in charge
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
17,735
Incredible rebuild by Bloom while remaining competitive in the majors.
Yeah, he's done a phenomenal job. Last year got to game 6 of the ALCS. This year in playoff contention. All while rebuilding the system into a monster.