It is always good to ask these questions. My view is we should challenge ourselves on this stuff. Trying to be as honest with myself as I can and taking your question to heart, the answer I come up with for myself is that Ohtani being in a land where he does not speak the language well and is is dedicated to baseball makes me much more willing to believe he is guileless than if he were an American/English speaking player. If he were, I would be more inclined to believe he had knowledge. Ohtani being an outsider culturally is in his favor. It is the only thing that makes this possibly of his absolute cluelessness believable, actually. But I don’t think it has to do with being from any particular country or region. It could just as easily be Venezuela.There is one thing I want to get off my chest as I sat here wondering why I even give two shits about this.
And I want to make sure I'm as clear as I can be with this and I'm not outwardly accusing anyone of consciously doing this out of any sort of malice.
Here it is. Some of you may know that I'm an Asian American. I, luckily, have not appeared to suffer from too much psychological damage growing up in New England in the 80s and being subject to all the stereotypes we have...especially since I met most of them.
But I want to pose a question. If this happened to an American American or Latin American or any race, would people be conjuring up dramatic cases of criminal mastery?
Which brings me to this. Does anyone know if Ohtani is more like Greg Maddix or Jonathan Papelbon? Like...are people putting on this idea that Ohtani, because he's seemingly been built in a factory and bred for baseball, is apparently a genius with hiding his multimillion gambling habit?
I'm saying the above not as me accusing anyone at all, but more an explanation to others on why this random guy who almost never posts in the MLB forums seems to incredulous at many of the posts.
I have a feeling someone will take what I said the wrong way, and my next words may just be me trying to cover my ass. But I truly mean this...I have never once stood up for myself for race related things, so I'm certainly not too sensitive about it...but for some random reason, this did and maybe someone can explained exactly why be sure I'm not sure I do.
Editorial addition: I'm not sure I will post about this anymore because I don't want to defend myself nor attack anyone about this. I just want people to think a little bit harder about why they think that Ohtani did something criminal...and this coming from someone who still thinks something else has to drop, but not necessarily on Ohtani himself.
$16 million of his dollars ended up in an illegal bookie’s account, and the press coverage when opinions were formed was bizarre and reflected some strange early choices by his team. That, and the desire of people to incline toward stories where people on pedestals fall, is the basis for most of the skepticism I have seen.
I can’t know what is in the hearts and minds of others, but it doesn’t feel like a race issue. Also, Ohtani is beloved. Like, people adore the guy. But people also gravitate toward the salacious story. Maybe there are race reasons why. This doesn’t feel like that, but I might not have the best handle on it. My immediate family is multi racial (my daughter is Asian) so I see how some stereotypes play out, but I may have some blind spots. This doesn’t feel like that to me though. If anything, I believe him more than I would, say, Max Scherzer.