Sounds like a game between two teams that most predicted would be in the relegation fight.7 minutes in on the Alaves v Valencia match and I'm not exactly sure what I am watching
2 missed penalties
1 own goal
I really didn't understand what happened on the pen review and subsequent roja directa. The ESPN English announcers didn't either. Hopefully getting Cancelo at RB helps settle the D, especially in Araujo's absence. One of brightest performances came from Kounde, who got to play RCB next to Christensen. Although I also saw Inigo Martinez get his first minutes over the weekend. Gavi is an animal and had his ear stapled together on the field. He's got Puyol's heart and fire in half the size! Love that MADLAD. The team really misses Pedri (any team would TBF). Lewa looks like he's lacking confidence so hopefully the pen gets him on course. FDJ also had a terrific game and I refuse to believe he won't shine in Catalunya before it's all over.Barca with another not-so-convincing win at Osasuna. I thought the result was unfair to the hosts. Osasuna had a legit penalty shout only to have a very iffy pen given to Barcelona. The ref did go to VAR, and everyone including the announcers thought he would reverse the call. Instead he doubled down and gave a red card to the Osasuna defender. But we did get a Chimy Avila banger. He’s still one of a kind. There was also a brief moment where Avila and Gavi, two of the grittiest players in the game, were 1v1 but nothing wild happened.
Sounds like a game between two teams that most predicted would be in the relegation fight.
Thanks for the vote of confidence . . . I think.Speaking of ESPN La Liga announcers, one of the announcers doing the Betis game was both effusive in his praise of the additions made to the club and emphatic in his belief that they had no chance at 4th place. Isco has looked great and they’ve been able to hold on to important pieces. Fekir is on his way back, Abde is in town, Luis Henrique will be back soon enough. They go two deep at every position on the field. Villarreal are a great team but always seem on the verge of sacking Setien. Sociedad traditionally fade as the season goes on and got off to an ok-but-not great start. Sevilla remain pointless, though their game this weekend was postponed. In other words, Real Betis have a chance at top four.
Barca have a really nice lineup now, and obviously Madrid have maximum points along with the hottest commodity in Spain in Jude, but I’m taking Atleti to win La Liga. I just like the team they’ve built.
Edit: apparently Setien was sacked earlier today!
It’s more of a curse. Sorry my man.Thanks for the vote of confidence . . . I think.
Back to the cow pastures!Speaking of ESPN La Liga announcers, one of the announcers doing the Betis game was both effusive in his praise of the additions made to the club and emphatic in his belief that they had no chance at 4th place. Isco has looked great and they’ve been able to hold on to important pieces. Fekir is on his way back, Abde is in town, Luis Henrique will be back soon enough. They go two deep at every position on the field. Villarreal are a great team but always seem on the verge of sacking Setien. Sociedad traditionally fade as the season goes on and got off to an ok-but-not great start. Sevilla remain pointless, though their game this weekend was postponed. In other words, Real Betis have a chance at top four.
Barca have a really nice lineup now, and obviously Madrid have maximum points along with the hottest commodity in Spain in Jude, but I’m taking Atleti to win La Liga. I just like the team they’ve built.
Edit: apparently Setien was sacked earlier today!
I haven’t heard yet from Sid Lowe on the Spanish Football Podcast regarding Carzola. Im a couple of episodes behind but he usually gives an update on his beloved Oviedo who are still winless but thankfully climbed out of the Segunda basement. They have a new league sponsor but it’s officially something like La Liga Hypermotion now.1 Question and 1 Observation regarding Real Oviedo:
Question - As best as I can tell, Santi Cazorla.has yet to appear on the squad sheet for Oviedo. Is there any reason for this?
Observation - I was super excited that ESPN+ has started to show Liga 2 matches but am dumbfounded and dispaointed that they neither streamed live or on on demand El Derbi Asturiano between Gijon and Oviedo.
Regardless it has not been a great start of the season for Los Azules as they only have 2 points from their first 5 matches.
Barca did look like a different team with the addition of the Joaos. Cancelo is the answer to the Dani Alves question that hasn't been answered for years. He's equally adept at setting up on the touchline, but usually setup further inside to allow Ferran space to receive without pressure on the wing. He's incredible on the ball and will help Barca's shape immensely. His goal at the end of the match was easily predictable 5-10 seconds before the hit, and the confidence with which he took that poor defender on was palpable.There are a lot of dynamics at play. The only similar instance I can think of was a Real Betis-Sevilla game. I can’t remember what the punishment was for Betis when their fans chanted “Die Ramos” at Juan de Ramos, but that was a home game and Ramos had just been knocked out by a projectile thrown from the stands (and I think they blocked the ambulance too) so it’s not totally apples to apples.
La Liga didn’t punish Atleti for their verbal abuse against Vini last season but punished Valencia for essentially the same thing after the player fought back against the abuse. There was widespread criticism of the Valencia ultras- well deserved- which I imagine is why they were punished and Atleti were not. Basically, La Liga and the Spanish Federation will only act when there is a lot of criticism. I don’t see too many people expressing outrage in defense of Greenwood outside of southern Madrid, so my best guess is La Liga shrugs and says “Hey that Jude guy looks good, and aren’t we excited by Lamine??”
On the pitch, what Zoso’s Barca did to my Betis was just cruel. It wasn’t just the “manito”, it was the way they did it. Like the back-to-back-to-back nutmegs? My lord. I haven’t watched the Sociedad-Madrid game yet but am hopeful my second team can take something out of Madrid.
The real Scylla and Charybdis part for La Liga on this is when those two things get combined and some crowd decides that they need to racially abuse the domestic abuser.Athletic Club Bilbao are facing sanctions by La Liga after their fans were chanting “die” to Mason Greenwood. This is the second time the chants were heard following Osasuna away fans doing so earlier. The league probably needs to do something about this sooner rather than later before it spirals out of control. Obviously I’m not condoning what Greenwood is accused doing but these types of things build and build in Spain. Given how poorly the league handled the Vinicius chants, I fully expect them to screw up what is a much more delicate issue in “protecting” an accused sexual assaulter in this political climate from over-the-top chants.
Don’t give them any ideas. Most teams have at least some far right ultras…The real Scylla and Charybdis part for La Liga on this is when those two things get combined and some crowd decides that they need to racially abuse the domestic abuser.
Hopefully they would be wearing a Dani Alves jersey as they do it.The real Scylla and Charybdis part for La Liga on this is when those two things get combined and some crowd decides that they need to racially abuse the domestic abuser.
I’ll answer this as best I can. The secessionist movement is absolutely a major point of conflict in Catalunya. I’ve had family members’ marriages fall apart over it, close relatives refuse to speak to one another over it, and I’ve seen people reduced to tears talking about it. It’s about as close to a 50/50 issue as you can get in the region (I know how the “votes” have gone but only one side shows up to those). That being said, I don’t see much anti-Andalucían sentiment any more among the pro-Independence crowd, at least where my family lives. The Andalucians who live there were mostly born in Catalunya, their families migrating in the 50s. The bulk of these families were gypsies or other marginalized parts of Spanish society, and generally indifferent to Franco. With so many immigrants and migrant laborers in the area, the families assimilated pretty quickly into Catalan society. Many are pro-Catalan independence, many are not. I’ll also note that the absolute vast majority of Andalucians who migrated to Catalunya were Béticos. There is a segment of bourgeois Barcelona society the looks down on those of Andalucian descent, but it’s kind of like the Brahmin families here, looking down their noses at pretty much everyone else. To your point, I do think the board at FC Barcelona does have an ample number of these blue bloods of Catalan society though. The bulk of the secessionist crowd that I know will say that it’s all a push just to gain more autonomy in Spain, not to actually secede as they would be entirely cut off from Europe and European markets if they actually became an independent country. All of this is based on discussions with family in a very small farming town southwest of Barcelona and a few who live in the city itself, so don’t take it as gospel.In the leadup to the Sevilla v Barcelona match, the Sevilla Board of Directors chose not to attend they typical pre-match luncheon and announced that they were not going to watch the match in the directors box with their Barcelona counterparts. This was of course in protest of the Negreira scandal and possibly a convenient way to distract from their disappointing start of the season.
Futbol Club Barcelona then did what they truly do best and released a press statement claiming to be the victim's of a unfair smear campaign. However what stuck out to me was the language that seemed to be not so subtle dog whistles to provencial grievances; referring to Sevilla's actions as an attack on a Catalan institution and making a point to remind everyone that Sevilla is in Andalucia (No shit sherlock).
Obviously, there are a ton of Andaluces and descendant of who live in Catalonia. For those of you more in the know -Is that still a major tension point in Catalan society? Possibly stirred up by the 2017 Referendum and seccesion push?
What's the name of this pod? The Barca podcast I listened to has really struggled since the straight man (Craig) retired a few years ago, and the other guy (Gabriel) had to take over main man duties.Don’t give them any ideas. Most teams have at least some far right ultras…
The Spanish Football Podcast guys seemed to think the chants would be from supporters of Osasuna, Athletic Club Bilbao, Rayo Vallecano, Cadiz and maybe a few others. Rayo and Cádiz supporters are generally extreme far left politically. Osasuna and Bilbao are both more or less Basque nationalists though I’m not 100% sure why that fact would lead them to be more likely to verbally abuse a player accused of sexual assault. Maybe a rejection of Spanish machoism? Anyone who knows Basque politics would know more than me. I love traveling there, but they’re just a different people entirely.
It’s just simply The Spanish Football Podcast. Three British expats living in Madrid. They all work in the Spanish media covering soccer. Sid Lowe is probably the most recognizable as he’s on the pitch for the main ESPN game weekly and writes for the Guardian. The other two occasionally do the play-by-play for less high profile La Liga games (say, Getafe-Cádiz). Weekly pod on Mondays doing a weekend review and another free pod during the week. It’s on the Apple podcast app, Spotify etc. I’m on their Patreon which has 2 additional podcasts a week, including a long Q&A.What's the name of this pod? The Barca podcast I listened to has really struggled since the straight man (Craig) retired a few years ago, and the other guy (Gabriel) had to take over main man duties.
Just watched the Barca-Granada replay last night, and wow is that kid special. Just a no nonsense direct goal threat and does his damage in a hurry.Every year La Liga has a lot of young talent that gets folks excited. These are my top five players that aren’t that well known… yet, so I’ve excluded the Barcelona guys (yes, even Yamal) and Bellingham (best player in La Liga) and those who have gotten a lot of press in the past (Riquelme, Lino, Pino, Baena, Abde, Nico Williams and so on). I’m also not including players on loan from other leagues, like Savinho at Girona on loan from Troyes.
- Javi Guerra (Valencia)- he’s the best of the club’s youth movement that also includes Diego Lopez, Jesus Vazquez, and Cristhian Mosquera. He had season-saving goals for the club last year and he’s off to a flying start this season.
- Arnau Martinez (Girona)- not a secret anymore. He had a great campaign last season and is the best young right back in La Liga. Idk what City Group have planned for him but I hope he stays in Spain.
- Mohammad Ali Cho (Sociedad)- La Real have loads of young talent- Kubo, Zubimendi, Barrene etc- but Cho offers something different. He definitely reminds me of Ousmane Dembele, right down to the infuriating lack of quality with the final touch. But he’s only 19.
- Assane Diao (Real Betis)- this kid came out of nowhere. I love the attacking players for the club, but he is really standing out. He scored in his first three games for Betis. Not bad for an 18 year old. With another personal binkie Henrique injured and facing another suspension, Diao will have time to shine.
- Bryan Zaragoza (Granada)- another off the radar player, he had his coming out party this weekend against Barcelona. Jules Kounde does not normally get carved up like this. Five goals this campaign, two against Barcelona, is a great start.
I was going to ask you a question after seeing this game- is La Masia back? Gavi, Balde, Yamal, Araujo, Fermin López, and now Marc Guiu (no credit for Pedri). It’s getting to how Real Sociedad have been the last few season where you see a kid making his debut and think “Jesus, another one?”Barca sneak by Athletic with young substitute Marc Guiu scoring on his first couple of touches after coming on around the 80th minute. I didn't watch this whole match, but I was very impressed with Martinez's passing out of the back, Gundogan perhaps slightly starting to play better, Felix really putting pressure on defenses, Balde playing farther upfield and beating his man consistently, and Yamal beating his man off the dribble constantly as well.
I don't think Barca get credit for Araujo either--he came over from Boston River (Uruguay) at 17 or 18 years old. I'd say the player has to be in the academy by age 15 or so for it to count as a credit to development. Araujo is a gem and Barca's scouting dept. deserves huge credit, but I'd say the player was mostly developed by the time he arrived.I was going to ask you a question after seeing this game- is La Masia back? Gavi, Balde, Yamal, Araujo, Fermin López, and now Marc Guiu (no credit for Pedri). It’s getting to how Real Sociedad have been the last few season where you see a kid making his debut and think “Jesus, another one?”
Girona have moved back level with Real Madrid on points at the top of the table and moved past Atleti in goals scored. I doubt they hang for a top four finish, but they are fun to watch, this time coming back from 2-0 to beat Almería 5-2.
These are all fair qualifying questions. I suppose I meant it in a way that you, as a Barca fan, are happy with the production at La Masia. More of a gut feeling in terms of confidence in the program at this point after several tough years. Any standard that includes producing a Messi-Xavi-Iniesta-Busquets crop of talent while redefining how the game is played and supplying the core of a World Cup winning team is too high, but for some, that is the standard. For me, a La Masia that is consistently developing top five talent is “back”, and I know we can quibble over “consistently” and “developing”. I would say that more players need to emerge over the next few years to reach that standard. For my uncle, a Culer, he wants at least 75% of the team to come from La Masia with nearly all of them being Catalan. So his standard is a little different and probably impossible to reach in this day and age.I don't think Barca get credit for Araujo either--he came over from Boston River (Uruguay) at 17 or 18 years old. I'd say the player has to be in the academy by age 15 or so for it to count as a credit to development. Araujo is a gem and Barca's scouting dept. deserves huge credit, but I'd say the player was mostly developed by the time he arrived.
Hard to say whether "La Masia" is back, because what does that really mean? When most people think of La Masia, I imagine they think of the golden generation--Xavi, Iniesta, Messi, Busi, Pique, etc. And while La Masia certainly fueled the incredible run from approx. 2005-2015, what I also remember about that time is how many academy players they had to ship out because...how do you displace Xavi-Iniesta-Messi-Busi?!?? Some players that came through La Masia during that time and succeeded in whole or in part elsewhere include: Bojan Krkic, Thiago (probably a mistake not to figure out a way to keep him), Cesc, Bellerin, Pedro, Adama Traore, Alena, Rafinha, Deulofeu, Bartra, etc. That's a pretty good academy output that mostly didn't play for the club!
So what's the standard? Filling in half the XI for a club that wins La Liga or UCL? Is the amount of starters lower/higher? If the number is 5-6, does La Masia need to crank out a certain amount of starters in the Big 5 leagues over a certain period to reach our imaginary 'back-ness'? I'm not being snarky, but rather pointing out that while Gavi, Balde, and Yamal are LEGIT, it's possible that the club just got "lucky" with them. I certainly hope Fermin and Guiu stick and continue to develop, but it also wouldn't surprise me if they end up elsewhere in a couple of seasons.
We do need to do a Gazza 'deep dive' on European academies at some point. As SOSH denizens, we could probably develop some really interesting numbers regarding academy product output (e.g., number of players in EPL/La Liga, minutes played, goals, etc.) and financial performance.
On a related note, one of my pub league teammate's brother had a trial for Gladbach and Bayern recently, but ended up signing a youth contract with Cadiz. Previously he was with Inter Miami's academy.
I'm not expert on La Masia. I hadn't heard of Guiu until he scored the winner on Sunday. But I do find the world of academies and player development fascinating.These are all fair qualifying questions. I suppose I meant it in a way that you, as a Barca fan, are happy with the production at La Masia. More of a gut feeling in terms of confidence in the program at this point after several tough years. Any standard that includes producing a Messi-Xavi-Iniesta-Busquets crop of talent while redefining how the game is played and supplying the core of a World Cup winning team is too high, but for some, that is the standard. For me, a La Masia that is consistently developing top five talent is “back”, and I know we can quibble over “consistently” and “developing”. I would say that more players need to emerge over the next few years to reach that standard. For my uncle, a Culer, he wants at least 75% of the team to come from La Masia with nearly all of them being Catalan. So his standard is a little different and probably impossible to reach in this day and age.
You have more insight into Barcelona youngsters than I do. I understand that Guiu wasn’t some unknown who emerged out of nowhere, though that’s how he seemed to me. People in Spain rated him highly beforehand. Perhaps a better question is what is your confidence in La Masia going forward based on recent results? Do you feel like there has been a fundamental change that has led to this success and will continue to provide for the club either with first team players or players that will be bought by other top five clubs, or is this just a hot streak? My guess based on what you wrote, you’re like me and want to see more evidence.
Tangentially, I remember Chelsea buying Oriol Romeu as a youngster with a buyback clause for Barcelona back in 2011 or 2012 for more money than Barcelona payed Girona to get him back. Such was the reputation of La Masia at that time that a club like Chelsea was willing to play a developmental role for Barcelona with a deal like Rayo had with Real Madrid for Fran Garcia. Romeu had never suited up for Barca A at that time if memory serves, at least not in an official match.
I’m down for doing a deep dive into several La Liga clubs and their academies, specifically the Basque clubs like Athletic Bilbao, Real Sociedad, and Osasuna. None are my favorite club but they all fascinate me. Sporting Gijón’s Mareo Academy has interested me since I learned what David Villa’s nickname El Guaje means.