seriously. Although early next month is next week.Are the “affected parties” on an Antarctica excursion or something? How does that take more than a day or two? What am I missing?
seriously. Although early next month is next week.Are the “affected parties” on an Antarctica excursion or something? How does that take more than a day or two? What am I missing?
FTFYI’ll say again, I think the longer it drags on, the better it bodes for the Red Sox. If there was something worthy of punishment in the same stratosphere as Houston, it would have leaked by nowthe league should have been highly motivated to get it out and begin to move on.
The writer may be seeing the world through Yankee-tinted glasses, but I think he’s more right than wrong.Mike Axisa used to run River Ave Blues and writes for CBS now. He has a twice a week, $3/month Patreon newsletter about the Yankees and anything related and in today's, he predicted Boston's punishment and if it is even close to what he is predicting, people here are going to go nuts. Honestly I don't even want to post it. He is often wildly wrong, but don't click on that spoiler without being prepared to be pissed off.
Keeping in mind, he knows nothing more than us and might be wildly wildly wrong...
5. Red Sox punishment. Have you enjoyed all the Astros sniping? Because we're going to go through it all again with the Red Sox soon. Last week commissioner Rob Manfred said he expects a resolution on the Red Sox investigation by the end of this week. "There have been a couple developments in the Boston thing that slowed us down," he said. From what I understand, Boston's cheating scheme was not as intricate as Houston's. They were decoding sign sequences in real time using the video room, but there was no garbage can banging or buzzer to relay those signs to the hitter. I guess the runner at second base would look in at the catcher, pick up the sign, then relay the incoming pitch to the hitter with a hand signal. Something like that. Rob Arthur (subs. req'd) found the Astros chased fewer pitches in the dirt when they were stealing signs in 2017, and the Red Sox showed the same tendency in 2018, but only when there were runners on base, lending some credence to the theory. Either way, what the Red Sox were doing was illegal. Can't use the video room to steal signs in real time. On one hand, their punishment may not be as severe as Houston's because the scheme wasn't as elaborate. On the other hand, the Red Sox are a repeat offender. They got caught using Apple Watches to steal signs in Sept. 2017 and were fined, and when Manfred announced the fine, he said this in his statement: "I have received absolute assurances from the Red Sox that there will be no future violations of this type." Seems like a pretty big deal. The team got caught cheating, assured the commissioner they wouldn't do it again, and then did it again the very next season (and won the World Series along the way). Even if Boston's scheme wasn't as elaborate as Houston's, doesn't the fact they are a repeat offender mean their punishment should be even more severe? They were given a warning and ignored it. Pretty brazen, I'd say. This is my official punishment prediction:
The fine, lost draft picks, and Dombrowski's suspension follow the Astros' template. Dombrowski, 64 in July, was fired last September and I don't know whether he is planning to pursue another front office job. The suspension would mean he'd have to wait a year to do so, if he wants. As for Cora, MLB identified him as a key figure in Houston's scheme. He helped the Astros put a sign-stealing system in place as their bench coach in 2017 and then did the same thing with the Red Sox as their manager in 2018. Cora is going to get hammered (as he should), and because he's already parted ways with the Red Sox, it gives MLB a chance to put this all on someone who is already out of the picture. It's far too convenient to pass up (MLB wants nothing more than this all to go away already). Pleasing ownership is Manfred's top priority and putting the blame on Cora would accomplish that. I am pro-chaos and it would be hilarious if Manfred came out and said he's vacating the 2018 World Series title because he learned his lesson after so many opposing players were upset about the Astros' punishment. I'm not gonna hold my breath though. Boston's sign-stealing scheme may not have been as elaborate as Houston's, but they still stole signs illegally, and they're a repeat offender. That last part seems mighty important. They should get hit hard. Even harder than the Astros. Ultimately, I think Cora is going to shoulder most of the blame, and the Red Sox organization will escape with the same relative slap on the wrist as Houston.
- $5M fine (maximum allowed by the MLB Constitution)
- Former manager Alex Cora suspended three years.
- Former president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski suspended one year.
- Forfeit first and second round draft picks in 2020 and 2021.
If this happens, my interest in the sport takes an unbelievable hit.I just unfortunately get the feeling that Manfred has seen which way the wind is blowing and will punish the Red Sox significantly. Besides Cora and Dombrowski being punished for two years; I could see him vacating the 2018 Series. His justification would be the Red Sox are repeat offenders as a result of the Fitbit scheme. In total the punishment would be:
Cora 2 year suspension
Dombrowski 2 year suspension
Red Sox organization 5 million dollar fine
Lose of first 3 rounds of draft picks for 2020 and 2021
No international signings allowed for next 3 years
2018 championship vacated
As a Red Sox fan I really hope I'm wrong but after Roger Godell I've learned to expect the worst. Manfred seems like a mini Godell.
I agree for the most part with your first 3. Manfred can go as hard as he wants on Cora and DD since neither is currently employed.I just unfortunately get the feeling that Manfred has seen which way the wind is blowing and will punish the Red Sox significantly. Besides Cora and Dombrowski being punished for two years; I could see him vacating the 2018 Series. His justification would be the Red Sox are repeat offenders as a result of the Fitbit scheme. In total the punishment would be:
Cora 2 year suspension
Dombrowski 2 year suspension
Red Sox organization 5 million dollar fine
Lose of first 3 rounds of draft picks for 2020 and 2021
No international signings allowed for next 3 years
2018 championship vacated
As a Red Sox fan I really hope I'm wrong but after Roger Godell I've learned to expect the worst. Manfred seems like a mini Godell.
This isn’t college. Professional sports owners will NEVER tolerate leagues ordering them to vacate championships. It significantly devalues the goal of all owners, which is to make as much money as possible on the basis of fan interest in championship runs. If there is a possibility that every time that a losing team whines that a winning team cheated that the championship is vacated, fans lose interest in future championship runs and interest/revenues go down. At the end of the day this is business. If this weren’t the case, don’t you think Goodell would have had The Patriots vacate championships to appease the mouth breathers out there? He doesn’t do that because that’s the third rail for owners.I just unfortunately get the feeling that Manfred has seen which way the wind is blowing and will punish the Red Sox significantly. Besides Cora and Dombrowski being punished for two years; I could see him vacating the 2018 Series. His justification would be the Red Sox are repeat offenders as a result of the Fitbit scheme. In total the punishment would be:
Cora 2 year suspension
Dombrowski 2 year suspension
Red Sox organization 5 million dollar fine
Lose of first 3 rounds of draft picks for 2020 and 2021
No international signings allowed for next 3 years
2018 championship vacated
As a Red Sox fan I really hope I'm wrong but after Roger Godell I've learned to expect the worst. Manfred seems like a mini Godell.
No one is vacating a world series.I just unfortunately get the feeling that Manfred has seen which way the wind is blowing and will punish the Red Sox significantly. Besides Cora and Dombrowski being punished for two years; I could see him vacating the 2018 Series. His justification would be the Red Sox are repeat offenders as a result of the Fitbit scheme. In total the punishment would be:
Cora 2 year suspension
Dombrowski 2 year suspension
Red Sox organization 5 million dollar fine
Lose of first 3 rounds of draft picks for 2020 and 2021
No international signings allowed for next 3 years
2018 championship vacated
As a Red Sox fan I really hope I'm wrong but after Roger Godell I've learned to expect the worst. Manfred seems like a mini Godell.
Anxiety about the Sox losing enough valuable draft picks to severely handicap their future is a reaction to a fairly unlikely hypothetical. Planning to exit the game of baseball because the Sox could have their 2018 World Series title vacated is the equivalent of stocking up on wine and roses for an upcoming long weekend with Margot Robbie.If what we've learned so far via rumor is even remotely accurate - that the Red Sox primarily relayed signals via base runners - and the Red Sox title is vacated but Houston keeps theirs, I am done with baseball until Manfred is gone. That would be such an absurd turn of events that it would destroy the credibility of the people running the league. I am sure I am not alone in that feeling even though I am reacting to a fairly unlikely hypothetical.
I agree. It's why he is waiting for the NFL to drop the hammer on the Pats for Spygate 2. He's been in cahoots with Goodell and will drop the Sox punishment 30-60 minutes after the Pats punishment is dropped.Manfred just got roasted over the handling of the Astro's situation. I can't fathom that he would want to pick at that just forming scab unless the Red Sox did something on par or worse than the Astro's. Every indication so far is that they haven't. I expect he'll do whatever he can to keep story/punishment as low-key as possible.
You're wrong.As a Red Sox fan I really hope I'm wrong but after Roger Godell I've learned to expect the worst. Manfred seems like a mini Godell.
I think it's the opposite-- he is getting roasted for not punishing the Astros players, so if he is perceived as going "light" on the Red Sox, he will get roasted even more. There's so much fan outrage over the Astros, that will only get worse if the Red Sox are perceived as getting off "light."Manfred just got roasted over the handling of the Astro's situation. I can't fathom that he would want to pick at that just forming scab unless the Red Sox did something on par or worse than the Astro's. Every indication so far is that they haven't. I expect he'll do whatever he can to keep story/punishment as low-key as possible.
People really, really, really hate the fucking Astros and Manfred. Even with the second time offender label getting attached to any Sox penalty, the absolute worst look for Manfred will be putting another notch in the Astros got away with it belt. It's going to come down to how much he can pin on Cora, since people now loathe Cora. The general sentiment I've read from neutrals or even rival fans is that what has been reported about the Sox isn't nearly as bad as the Astros.the only ones to complain anywhere will be Red Sox fans.
Unless the Sox are shown to have done something equally bad or worse than the Astros, I don’t see how it’s possible he could possibly justify a punishment in line or more severe than what the Astros received. Maybe some fans would cheer it, but I can’t see other owners being happy about it. Sure, it weakens the Sox in the short run, but would other owners want the risk of getting over-punished as a “make-up call” like that if he is perceived to have under-punished a different franchise in future scandals?I think it's the opposite-- he is getting roasted for not punishing the Astros players, so if he is perceived as going "light" on the Red Sox, he will get roasted even more. There's so much fan outrage over the Astros, that will only get worse if the Red Sox are perceived as getting off "light."
If he goes hard on the Red Sox, the only ones to complain anywhere will be Red Sox fans. Fans of other teams and the media will congratulate him for getting this one "right" and Manfred himself will be better off, facing less public bashing from fans and the media. I don't think he has a clue about what to do, and I think this punishment will be about making himself look as good as possible to everyone who has been attacking him.
Which means going hard on the Red Sox. He'll hit them as hard as he can without getting baseball sued.
I sincerely hope I am wrong, but Manfred seems clueless and overmatched and has bungled pretty much everything he's touched IMO.
Made me laugh and made me feel better. However, I have a hard time not buying into The Gray Eagle's line of logic here. I think it will be in the best interest of Manfred and MLB's PR department to hit the Sox as hard as they can. I still doubt it's a vacated title, but I mean, the wine and roses are being stocked as we speak.Anxiety about the Sox losing enough valuable draft picks to severely handicap their future is a reaction to a fairly unlikely hypothetical. Planning to exit the game of baseball because the Sox could have their 2018 World Series title vacated is the equivalent of stocking up on wine and roses for an upcoming long weekend with Margot Robbie.
It would have been difficult taking any action against the players as it would have been a bunch of people pointing accusing fingers at eachother. MLB was more interested in going after management, so giving the players immunity resulted in evidence they could run with.I think it's the opposite-- he is getting roasted for not punishing the Astros players, so if he is perceived as going "light" on the Red Sox, he will get roasted even more. There's so much fan outrage over the Astros, that will only get worse if the Red Sox are perceived as getting off "light."
If he goes hard on the Red Sox, the only ones to complain anywhere will be Red Sox fans. Fans of other teams and the media will congratulate him for getting this one "right" and Manfred himself will be better off, facing less public bashing from fans and the media. I don't think he has a clue about what to do, and I think this punishment will be about making himself look as good as possible to everyone who has been attacking him.
Which means going hard on the Red Sox. He'll hit them as hard as he can without getting baseball sued.
I sincerely hope I am wrong, but Manfred seems clueless and overmatched and has bungled pretty much everything he's touched IMO.
Agree with this, plus the Sox being a repeat offender (almost immediately after 1st infraction) opens the door wide for the commish to drop the hammer.I think it's the opposite-- he is getting roasted for not punishing the Astros players, so if he is perceived as going "light" on the Red Sox, he will get roasted even more. There's so much fan outrage over the Astros, that will only get worse if the Red Sox are perceived as getting off "light."
If he goes hard on the Red Sox, the only ones to complain anywhere will be Red Sox fans. Fans of other teams and the media will congratulate him for getting this one "right" and Manfred himself will be better off, facing less public bashing from fans and the media. I don't think he has a clue about what to do, and I think this punishment will be about making himself look as good as possible to everyone who has been attacking him.
Which means going hard on the Red Sox. He'll hit them as hard as he can without getting baseball sued.
I sincerely hope I am wrong, but Manfred seems clueless and overmatched and has bungled pretty much everything he's touched IMO.
You said it yourself, Manfred's getting roasted because the Astros players didn't get punished. They didn't get punished because MLB gave them "immunity" to talk. Not a chance that current and former Red Sox players weren't given the same deal. So no matter what happened in the Red Sox clubhouse, no player will face punishment.I think it's the opposite-- he is getting roasted for not punishing the Astros players, so if he is perceived as going "light" on the Red Sox, he will get roasted even more. There's so much fan outrage over the Astros, that will only get worse if the Red Sox are perceived as getting off "light."
If he goes hard on the Red Sox, the only ones to complain anywhere will be Red Sox fans. Fans of other teams and the media will congratulate him for getting this one "right" and Manfred himself will be better off, facing less public bashing from fans and the media. I don't think he has a clue about what to do, and I think this punishment will be about making himself look as good as possible to everyone who has been attacking him.
Which means going hard on the Red Sox. He'll hit them as hard as he can without getting baseball sued.
I sincerely hope I am wrong, but Manfred seems clueless and overmatched and has bungled pretty much everything he's touched IMO.
If only there was a thread in the Patriots subforum about this ...Speaking of alleged misdeeds, whatever happened to that complaint against the Pats that occurred in Cleveland in December?
Hahahaha...we all forgot about that, didn't we? Don't worry, Goodell is saving that decision for a moment of maximum impact. Since the playoffs just happened, I guess it has to be right before the Pat's first game or when everyone returns to camp.Speaking of alleged misdeeds, whatever happened to that complaint against the Pats that occurred in Cleveland in December?
Agreed. I'm not much for throwing a big hissy fit about this stuff, but vacating that title would probably end my relationship with Major League Baseball.If this happens, my interest in the sport takes an unbelievable hit.
i don’t think it will be anything close to this.
You’re not going to have to worry about that. Zero chance it happens.Agreed. I'm not much for throwing a big hissy fit about this stuff, but vacating that title would probably end my relationship with Major League Baseball.
Yeah, cycling awarded the 2006 Tour de France to the runner up (Oscar Pereiro) after Floyd Landis was bounced. Within 6 months we were all talking about how Pereiro got dinged in a test himself. Nice work. Armstrong's titles were canceled several years later and just left vacant, for probably that reason. Here even if you vacate, which seems like a stretch even for 2017, actually handing the title to the next team is even crazier IMO.What amuses me about all the vacating titles nonsense is that no one benefits from doing that. So you "vacate" the title, it's not like the Miss America pageant where the crown then goes to the runner-up. If MLB vacated the Astros and/or Red Sox titles, it's not like they will ship the trophies and rings to Chavez Ravine. There simply is no World Series champ for that year. What's the point?