Race and the Red Sox

Kenny F'ing Powers

posts way less than 18% useful shit
SoSH Member
Nov 17, 2010
14,468
Sam Kennedy already came out and said other players heard it...

So unless they have supersonic hearing other people in the bleachers heard it too. It happened. That's all the proof that you need.
I'm on mobile, and the link is twitter so it doesn't work. If it says in there that the people responsible didn't get kicked and people didn't do anything, I take back my post.
 

RetractableRoof

tolerates intolerance
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2003
3,836
Quincy, MA
Yes, it's a well-known cautionary tale about media sensationalism. Genovese was attacked by serial killer Winston Mosely. There were 5 known witnesses. Two of them called the police (albeit one only after calling friends for advice and crossing to a neighbor's apartment). A third, Robert Mozer, intervened directly and yelled at Mosely, causing him to run off. A fourth witness, Sophia Ferrar, came out and attempted to help the bleeding Genovese, cradling her until help arrived. The fifth witness, the aptly named Joseph Fink, closed his door, did nothing, and took a nap.

Because of the swift response by witnesses, an ambulance arrived soon after the attacks; unfortunately, Genovese died en route to the hospital.

But there was a widely-reprinted early report in the New York Times that made all sorts of incorrect claims (that there were something like 38 witnesses all of whom ignored the situation, that Mosely attacked Genovese 3 times, that nobody called the cops, and that Genovese died on the sidewalk with nobody trying to help her), so until the late 1990s people--especially in rural america--would often use it as a moral pearl-clutching story about urban decay and how people don't care enough to help each other in the big city.

Since then it's been used as a case study in journalism and the persistence of legends.

Apparently the original misconception still lingers in some corners. A good myth is hard to displace.
Sometimes it really is hard to let the air out of those stories...
 

fineyoungarm

tweets about his subwoofer!
SoSH Member
Oct 20, 2011
9,187
New Orleans, LA
There is the Yawkey Center at MGH, which is named that way for a very good reason. The legacy of the Yawkey family is certainly mixed, but that doesn't make them any different than a lot of other folks at that time.
But the street is named after Tom Yawkey and Tom Yawkey's legacy on the race issue is simply terrible. It is a hard sell to maintain that racism has no place at Fenway and Fenway is at 4 Yawkey Way.
 

DJnVa

Dorito Dawg
SoSH Member
Dec 16, 2010
54,016
The city of Boston does deserve it. It was more than one person. You had hundreds of people in the bleachers that heard it and all made a decision to not do anything about it. They're just as bad. We deserve to get protests from any groups out there that want to.

However, I would also like to remind you that it's not only here. It happens everywhere and that's the problem. It shouldn't even exist in 2017.

A lot of white people have been racially empowered shall we say since T***P was elected in November.
Price and Sabathia heard it long before the election, in fact it's so well known that the black players all discuss it.
 

Sir Lancelotti

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2006
284
Boston
Was there a college ticket give away of some sort last night at Fenway? I find it strange they would have 3X the number of arrests on a Monday night game, and early weekday games are typically when the Sox would offer discounted bleacher seats to colleges to help fill their community outreach quota.

I don't know how much it will change the national narrative if it turns out the idiots involved were drunk frat kids from Northeastern who come from areas scattered throughout the country rather than the stereotypical "Sully from Old Colony projects" Boston racist caricature.
 

thestardawg

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 30, 2005
913
Section 38, Row 13
Interesting way to characterize what happened. You're right though, there's always some reason we can scrounge up for not speaking up--but don't anyone dare call Boston "racist." Then you'll hear from us.

Can we really even believe these big money elites making these claims?
No actually he's right. Do you sit in the bleachers? I have gone to minimum 15-20 games a year in those seats yearly. I've said something to "that guy" before and for my troubles ive had beer thrown on me, swung at, and one time ejected from my own seats.

So look Captain America while you may think there's never a good reason to remain quiet maybe you need to actually be in that situation a few times yourself
 

PC Drunken Friar

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 12, 2003
14,591
South Boston
I grew up in an era where people thought racism was no big deal. I grew up with race riots at the high school in my home town (players on the same football team on opposing sides of the fighting). In the face of that I learned from neighbors who were black that quality people are quality people regardless of their pigmentation and more generally their appearance. I went to college in Boston through the disgusting Charles Stuart claims. Over my lifetime I've watched the sports teams in Boston change or take a stand on racist policy. I saw a black hockey player wear the home teams jersey. I've seen the city I call home change and evolve in a lot of ways. Do I believe the job is done? No. Do I believe that racism still exists? Yes. But I do not believe it is accepted culturally in Boston at large. There may be pockets of such behavior - as there are pockets of all manner of behaviors that society does not approve of. At this point I believe that racist examples are the outliers in our city.

In my opinion, if you get 30K people to group together for a sports event and could perform instant analysis you'd find all manner of behaviors. You would find X percent of people who still in this day and age drink and drive (probably from that very event). You would find X percent who have an issue with domestic violence (maybe overlapping the drinking?). You'd find X percent that have been arrested for violent crimes. You'd find find X percent that have a white collar criminal past - caught or not. You'd have X percent that have crossed modern society's line for consensual sex, whether it was recent or far in their past. And yes you'd have X percent that are guilty of racism. None of these items would be acceptable to many responding here, but realistically they are still present in our community. But in that group of 30K or 1 million residents of the Boston area the question is - are these behaviors outliers? I believe they are - and as such wince at the perpetuation of a reputation that was true some time ago but I believe we have substantially grown past.

I reject the tired narrative that Boston is racist. There are outliers in every city, in every town, in every gathering of people in our society. I don't believe Boston is any more racist than the next town. What Boston has due to its past, and due to the mindset of those who live here, and the media who report here, is an extremely strong spotlight for these (and other) behaviors. And the act of shining a strong light on unacceptable behaviors is good. But painting an entire city with the broad brush of any label because of the acts of outliers isn't acceptable either.
I agree with a lot of what you say here, but I have a huge problem with the last part. Who the fuck cares if people paint the city with a broad brush? Boston, the city is NOT the victim here. Does it happen in other cities? Do other cities have huge amounts of racists like Boston? Yup. Maybe it's time we acknowledge that we still are a somewhat racist society.
 

richgedman'sghost

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
May 13, 2006
1,878
ct
This was touched upon earlier today. Yawkey Way. It's existence is remarkably tone deaf and undermines ownership's credibility when proclaiming that racism will not be tolerated and has no place at Fenway. I expect the national media to start drilling down on this. If so, more embarrassment.

If the Red Sox powers that be want to make a very clear statement that racism has no place at Fenway, that name should come down - now. Since the Yawkey Red Sox took a pass on Willie Mays, there is no African American home town team HOF'er superstar to use as a replacement. (Although renaming the street after Mays would be quite a repudiation of the team's past.) However, Jackie Robinson Way would do quite nicely.

And that address - 4 Yawkey Way - would be history.
How about Jim Rice or Mo Vaughn or even Big Papi? You seem to have forgotten a few good players.
 

Kenny F'ing Powers

posts way less than 18% useful shit
SoSH Member
Nov 17, 2010
14,468
But the street is named after Tom Yawkey and Tom Yawkey's legacy on the race issue is simply terrible. It is a hard sell to maintain that racism has no place at Fenway and Fenway is at 4 Yawkey Way.
Are we really going to rehash changing the faces on our money again?
 

RoDaddy

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jun 19, 2002
3,258
Albany area, NY
Regardless of how much Jones is believed (and most seem to believe him) or embraced as a victim, tonight is a great opportunity for Boston to make a symbolic stand against racism as in a standing ovation is not enough. How about when Adam Jones comes to bat for the first time, in addition to a SO, the Sox players led by Pedey (and here's his chance to redeem himself as a leader) and other white players leave the dugout to greet/hug him at home plate followed by the rest of the team, Henry, Werner, Kennedy and even Mayor Walsh if he's there?
 

RetractableRoof

tolerates intolerance
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2003
3,836
Quincy, MA
But the street is named after Tom Yawkey and Tom Yawkey's legacy on the race issue is simply terrible. It is a hard sell to maintain that racism has no place at Fenway and Fenway is at 4 Yawkey Way.
I'm fine with this approach as long as we go back in time and rename all the streets that were named after JFK because I for one don't want public streets named after adulterers, or public buildings/streets named after industrialists who were also racists and made millions off the backs of child labor. If you want to white-wash (obviously no pun intended) history, lets be thorough about it. Other than Yawkey, what names should we be checking out next???

Are we really going to rehash changing the faces on our money again?
Or what he said.
 

RedOctober3829

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
55,430
deep inside Guido territory
Regardless of how much Jones is believed (and most seem to believe him) or embraced as a victim, tonight is a great opportunity for Boston to make a symbolic stand against racism as in a standing ovation is not enough. How about when Adam Jones comes to bat for the first time, in addition to a SO, the Sox players led by Pedey (and here's his chance to redeem himself as a leader) and other white players leave the dugout to greet/hug him at home plate followed by the rest of the team, Henry, Werner, Kennedy and even Mayor Walsh if he's there?
Jeez, that's a bit much.
 

RetractableRoof

tolerates intolerance
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2003
3,836
Quincy, MA
I agree with a lot of what you say here, but I have a huge problem with the last part. Who the fuck cares if people paint the city with a broad brush? Boston, the city is NOT the victim here. Does it happen in other cities? Do other cities have huge amounts of racists like Boston? Yup. Maybe it's time we acknowledge that we still are a somewhat racist society.
Then we should make that argument instead of simply stopping with "Boston is racist" which is what the media is doing.
 

iayork

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 6, 2006
639
Its interesting this comes up shortly after Prices allegations a couple of months ago. CC says he never heard anything since becoming a Yankee. Crawford only mentioned being called a Monday at a minor league rehab start. Now all of a sudden we have a rash of it at Fenway?
Yeah, it's almost like there was some national event since last season that made racists and bigots feel empowered and emboldened.
 

JohntheBaptist

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 13, 2005
11,404
Yoknapatawpha County
No actually he's right. Do you sit in the bleachers? I have gone to minimum 15-20 games a year in those seats yearly. I've said something to "that guy" before and for my troubles ive had beer thrown on me, swung at, and one time ejected from my own seats.

So look Captain America while you may think there's never a good reason to remain quiet maybe you need to actually be in that situation a few times yourself
Believe it or not, Captain America has been in this situation a few times. Captain America gets that despite it being hard, you do it. Not doing it makes you complicit, and creates a culture where it is easier for that guy to do it, and sends a message to the person on the receiving end: "sorry, it's too hard to speak up."

You know, lessons you learn in grade school.

Signing off,
Captain America
 

RetractableRoof

tolerates intolerance
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2003
3,836
Quincy, MA
How about Jim Rice or Mo Vaughn or even Big Papi? You seem to have forgotten a few good players.
Not Mo Vaughn please, anyone who allows their lawyers call a State Policeman in court a liar and accuse them of making up facts around a highway accident is not someone I want to use as a role model. Thanks.
 

Lose Remerswaal

Experiencing Furry Panic
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Was there a college ticket give away of some sort last night at Fenway? I find it strange they would have 3X the number of arrests on a Monday night game, and early weekday games are typically when the Sox would offer discounted bleacher seats to colleges to help fill their community outreach quota.

I don't know how much it will change the national narrative if it turns out the idiots involved were drunk frat kids from Northeastern who come from areas scattered throughout the country rather than the stereotypical "Sully from Old Colony projects" Boston racist caricature.
It was a tier 5 game, so regular seats out there were as cheap as ten bucks. Plus the $9 college deal does mean lots of folks there who didn't pay much to get in.
 

mauf

Anderson Cooper × Mr. Rogers
Moderator
SoSH Member
Are we really going to rehash changing the faces on our money again?
George Washington was the father of our country. Thomas Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence. Even Andrew Jackson (whose face probably shouldn't be on our currency) was a war hero. Tom Yawkey has considerably less in the positive column than those men, and his attitudes lagged farther behind his peers' than any of them.

Unless you're a serial killer or something, donating millions of dollars to a charity gets your name on a building, if not the institution itself -- no one is suggesting we rename Duke, Vanderbilt or Carnegie Mellon because those men made their fortunes in a way that wouldn't be acceptable today. Likewise, the cancer center at MGH will continue to bear the Yawkey name, and appropriately so.

Naming a street after someone is different. It suggests that your community is proud of you. I don't think Boston feels that way about Tom Yawkey anymore. Of course, that's for the City of Boston to decide, not the Red Sox.
 

fineyoungarm

tweets about his subwoofer!
SoSH Member
Oct 20, 2011
9,187
New Orleans, LA
George Washington was the father of our country. Thomas Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence. Even Andrew Jackson (whose face probably shouldn't be on our currency) was a war hero. Tom Yawkey has considerably less in the positive column than those men, and his attitudes lagged farther behind his peers' than any of them.

Unless you're a serial killer or something, donating millions of dollars to a charity gets your name on a building, if not the institution itself -- no one is suggesting we rename Duke, Vanderbilt or Carnegie Mellon because those men made their fortunes in a way that wouldn't be acceptable today. Likewise, the cancer center at MGH will continue to bear the Yawkey name, and appropriately so.

Naming a street after someone is different. It suggests that your community is proud of you. I don't think Boston feels that way about Tom Yawkey anymore. Of course, that's for the City of Boston to decide, not the Red Sox.
Well said - although as for the final point, I bet the Red Sox could "convince" the city to address the name issue, if the city doesn't get there first.
 

richgedman'sghost

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
May 13, 2006
1,878
ct
Tyrone Biggums...You keep on saying that nobody did anything to stop the racist yelling. How do you know? Do you have the call logs of the Red Sox Security Staff? As has been mentioned numerous times, there were about 15 to 20 ejections last night. So somebody had to complain. Suppose the fans called or texted the advertised number or otherwise alerted security? Would you have a problem then? My main issue with you is that you have stated numerous times in this thread that not a single fan spoke up or reported the incident when we know that is untrue. I think your claim is untrue and is painting with too broad a brush. Howevrer, one racial incident is one too many and I am not defending the actions of the racists in any way shape or form.
 

tonyandpals

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 18, 2004
7,860
Burlington
Sox brass stressing fans can help.

Dear Season Ticket Holder,

We experienced an unacceptable event yesterday at Fenway Park and wanted to take this opportunity to reaffirm our commitment to ensuring that everyone visiting the ballpark feels safe and welcome.

A key part of maintaining a fun and inclusive atmosphere is you, the fans. We have hundreds of employees, security personnel, and Boston Police officials who monitor the ballpark during games to ensure that the few fans who detract from the inclusive environment are identified. We are asking for your continued help to be our eyes and ears in the places we can’t always be. If you see an incident that makes you, your family, or surrounding fans uncomfortable, we ask that you report it immediately in the following ways:


We are fortunate to have the most passionate fans in all of sports, and the energy and emotion that you bring to each game is unparalleled. We hope that same spirit helps keep Fenway Park inviting for all fans, players, and employees who walk through our gates. Thank you in advance for your ongoing partnership in this effort.

Sincerely,

Sam Kennedy
Red Sox President
 

RetractableRoof

tolerates intolerance
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2003
3,836
Quincy, MA
Boo-fucking-hoo.
Why don't we all meet at a bar, have a few drinks and tell each other all the things we've done/said in our past. We can all group think and agree which labels we should add to our linked in profiles, our resume, and how we should be labeled going forward. Any of us that complain about carrying those labels for the rest of our lives we can simply dismiss with "boo hoo". It will be fun :)

Or we can recognize that some things are actually in the past, and work on improving things going forward without simply insulting a whole city for the actions of a few outliers. Boo hoo indeed.
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,211
Believe it or not, Captain America has been in this situation a few times. Captain America gets that despite it being hard, you do it. Not doing it makes you complicit, and creates a culture where it is easier for that guy to do it, and sends a message to the person on the receiving end: "sorry, it's too hard to speak up."

You know, lessons you learn in grade school.

Signing off,
Captain America
So, by reading this post, can we make the assumption that you have spoken up every single time you have personally witnessed racism, bigotry, and any other form of discrimination in public and in private?
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
18,171
The only evidence that fans did nothing is the rantings of one poster who has yet to provide any supporting evidence.
 

DJnVa

Dorito Dawg
SoSH Member
Dec 16, 2010
54,016
I cannot wait to hear the pontifications of the O's broadcast team tonight--between this and Betts getting hit last night.
 

RetractableRoof

tolerates intolerance
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2003
3,836
Quincy, MA
Chris Young with a very well-reasoned take and one I agree with.

This is as good as it gets from an athlete. I guess due to his low profile I'd never heard much from him beyond baseball related topics. He's well spoken. I wish Pedroia (one of my favorites) would come across as this thoughtful.
 

DJnVa

Dorito Dawg
SoSH Member
Dec 16, 2010
54,016
I kinda wish Jones could pick his walk-up music tonight and went with something by NWA.
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
73,070
It's a Monday before finals in a cold night at the middle-end of a long homestand (the rest of which was expensive)with $9 student tickets.
Was there a college ticket give away of some sort last night at Fenway? I find it strange they would have 3X the number of arrests on a Monday night game, and early weekday games are typically when the Sox would offer discounted bleacher seats to colleges to help fill their community outreach quota.

I don't know how much it will change the national narrative if it turns out the idiots involved were drunk frat kids from Northeastern who come from areas scattered throughout the country rather than the stereotypical "Sully from Old Colony projects" Boston racist caricature.
 

RetractableRoof

tolerates intolerance
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2003
3,836
Quincy, MA
The city of Boston does deserve it. It was more than one person. You had hundreds of people in the bleachers that heard it and all made a decision to not do anything about it. They're just as bad. We deserve to get protests from any groups out there that want to.

However, I would also like to remind you that it's not only here. It happens everywhere and that's the problem. It shouldn't even exist in 2017.

A lot of white people have been racially empowered shall we say since T***P was elected in November.
I've experienced first hand a handful of racist incidents since he was elected. Each of them was committed by persons of color on another ethnicity. I view them as outliers, but if you want to show me how this correlates to his election I'm game to listen.
 

canderson

Mr. Brightside
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
39,558
Harrisburg, Pa.
This is a crisis the management is in. The team sucks right now, this brings crazy negative attention. It's a true crisis.

That said, the Sox org has been proactive and outspoken today. I'm proud of that. It should continue.

They have the resources and public trust to launch an anti-racism/bigotry campaign that is badly needed imo. I hope they do it.
 

DJnVa

Dorito Dawg
SoSH Member
Dec 16, 2010
54,016
I've experienced first hand a handful of racist incidents since he was elected. Each of them was committed by persons of color on another ethnicity. I view them as outliers, but if you want to show me how this correlates to his election I'm game to listen.
If you guys wanna bring Trump and the election into this, could you do it via PM?
 

PC Drunken Friar

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 12, 2003
14,591
South Boston
I've experienced first hand a handful of racist incidents since he was elected. Each of them was committed by persons of color on another ethnicity. I view them as outliers, but if you want to show me how this correlates to his election I'm game to listen.
Mo Vaughn sucks because he had the gall to say a state trooper lied. Boston isn't racist, it's just a few people, and it hurts your feelings. You were never aware of how well-spoken Chris Young was. People of color have committed racists acts (against you?). You would t acknowledge that some people have become empowered since the election and are now ballsier in their racism. You win the thread.
 

mauf

Anderson Cooper × Mr. Rogers
Moderator
SoSH Member
It's a Monday before finals in a cold night at the middle-end of a long homestand (the rest of which was expensive)with $9 student tickets.
Half-price tickets for college students have been a bad idea since forever. That certainly explains the above-average number of ejections; of course, the racist(s) may well have paid full price.
 

Al Zarilla

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
59,234
San Andreas Fault
There are only 62 black major leaguers?
That sounds about right. You hear that blacks in MLB nowadays are at a low for quite a long time at about 7-8%. I think at peak it was somewhere around 20%. One reason cited is young blacks concentrate more on basketball over the last few years.
 

DJnVa

Dorito Dawg
SoSH Member
Dec 16, 2010
54,016
Buck Showalter said that had he heard last night he may have pulled team from field. He also said that this isn't the only place it happens.
 

soxhop411

news aggravator
SoSH Member
Dec 4, 2009
46,417
Mookie is pissed
“@IanMBrowne: ”For me to be here, and for me to represent Boston, and to hear something like that going on, that hurts me.“ — Mookie Betts.”

“@IanMBrowne: ”I don’t want to be a part of something like that. I don’t think anybody does. When we come to the park we’re here to have fun.“ — Mookie”
 

yep

Member
SoSH Member
Feb 3, 2006
2,465
Red Sox Natin
No actually he's right. Do you sit in the bleachers? I have gone to minimum 15-20 games a year in those seats yearly. I've said something to "that guy" before and for my troubles ive had beer thrown on me, swung at, and one time ejected from my own seats.

So look Captain America while you may think there's never a good reason to remain quiet maybe you need to actually be in that situation a few times yourself
Believe it or not, Captain America has been in this situation a few times. Captain America gets that despite it being hard, you do it. Not doing it makes you complicit, and creates a culture where it is easier for that guy to do it, and sends a message to the person on the receiving end: "sorry, it's too hard to speak up."

You know, lessons you learn in grade school.

Signing off,
Captain America
It's possible for both of you to be right. It is possible that the culture in the bleachers at Fenway is such that it's dangerous to speak out against racism, and that it is naive to think it would make a difference.

I hate to think that's true, and I don't believe it is. I typically sit in the cheap seats several times a year, and I don't ever remember someone repeatedly yelling the N word (I can't specifically recall ever hearing it at Fenway Park). I have definitely asked/yelled at people to watch their mouth, and pointed out that there are kids nearby (yes, in the bleachers, and no, the kids were not mine). I think the worst response I've ever got was stinkeye, but usually it's more like a sloppy drunken bropology, with the offender giving hi-fives for the nearby kids and telling them it's not good to talk like that.

Now, maybe my experience is unique to me. I am physically bigger than most people, so my manners reminders probably don't take as much courage as they would coming from someone who is more physically vulnerable. Maybe the fact that I reflexively start shouting "dude, watch your mouth, there are kids around" when it gets to the F word, helps prevent things from escalating to the N word. Or maybe I have just been luckier, with who I sit near.

The individual responsibility for shouting racist stuff is on the person who did it. But the cultural and community responsibility is on the community where that stuff is tolerated and allowed to happen. It's not that thestardawg or anyone else is individually responsible for what some racist says or does within earshot, but if Fenway Park is a place where it's okay to shout racial epithets, that's on all of us. If it is more scary/dangerous to confront someone for saying the n word than it is to say it, then something is wrong. If the guy shouting racial epithets does it with impunity, while the guy who confronts him gets swung on, beer poured on him, etc, then that is a racist culture, and a racist community.

It should be that the racist is afraid to speak, not the other way around.