My post was predicated on the premise that Bill doesn't see much difference in performance beteween Mac and Cam in practice, which in my mind would mean the difference between them on the field wouldn't mean making the playoffs vs. punting on the season. If he thinks Cam has been better then sure, start him. My argument was the tie goes to the rookie, not that Bill should play Mac regardless (even though I would).Depends what we mean by competitors. If we mean potential playoff teams... no very few are, and even fewer successfully. We have discussed it a bunch, but rookie QBs by and large suck. Now you could argue maybe Bill cares more about getting Mac experience than making the playoffs, but I really doubt that based both on what we know about him and how this roster is built heavily around vets on short deals.