The contrast between Brady and Farve is fascinating. Brady remembers seemingly every game, every play. Farve not so much. That’s not even really a knock on Farve. Brady is just on another level (yes I already knew this)
Zo agrees.That BB/Brady segments were pure football porn.
Marino and Brees, right?Last two are anyone’s guess.
Hard to see Marino getting left off this list.
Marino and Elway is my thought.Marino and Brees, right?
Too bad he didn’t have such good lighting on that dick pic he harassed the Jets employee with.Ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
(My reaction to Favre being on set talking about himself in a heavenly light)
You’re right but he’s JOHN ELWAY. I can’t see him getting left off.When you look at Elway's page at footballreference, there's not a lot of black ink there.
In his defense, Dan Reeves was not the best coach for offensive creativity.You’re right but he’s JOHN ELWAY. I can’t see him getting left off.
Revolutionizing the game!!1Fun watching the Roger clips from half a century ago and thinking again about how any scrambling QB after him is some unprecedented unique weapon we've never seen before. Collinsworth right there, too.
He was plagued with weak supporting casts for most of his career. He was a one man band forever, because he could get away with it.When you look at Elway's page at footballreference, there's not a lot of black ink there.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/E/ElwaJo00.htm
Counterpoint, fuck John Elway.In his defense, Dan Reeves was not the best coach for offensive creativity.
Yep. The only thing that would have made this more enjoyable is Manning on set instead of Farve.Brett Favre is the career interceptions leader and has a career passer rating two points lower than Brady has this season. He also sounds like he just doesn’t really know what he’s talking about. He should not be top 10
Yeah that’s the thing that’s hard for me coming from always being a bigger baseball fan than football. The stats for baseball are so much more reliable and you kind of condition yourself to roll your eyes at “you had to watch him” or “the eye test”. But with football, everything is so dependent on the people around you that you have to put so much more stock into those things.In his defense, Dan Reeves was not the best coach for offensive creativity.
Circumventing the salary cap helped too.He was plagued with weak supporting casts for most of his career. He was a one man band forever, because he could get away with it.
There's a reason he put up the best statistical seasons of his career towards the end. And it wasn't because Elway was magically becoming a better QB as he aged into his late 30s.
I think I’d actually take Marino over Brees for this list and I bet he’s the pick.So, either Brees, the all time TD leader, or Marino is going to be left off.
Brees won a Super Bowl.
If they choose Marino, I hope Bill gets to say something on the order of " . . he played on a lot of Shula coached teams that couldn't get back to the big game but that wasn't Dan's fault."Brees is, in effect, a better version of Marino. but I bet it goes other way
Not Bill’s style, but from your lips to His ears.If they choose Marino, I hope Bill gets to say something on the order of " . . he played on a lot of Shula coached teams that couldn't get back to the big game but that wasn't Dan's fault."
That’s not what I heard.He seems like a really likable guy if you ignore the whole unsolicited dick pic thing. Which, of course, would be a big thing to ignore.
I was dying at the end when they were talking about how many of the Top 100 had chips on their shoulders, cuz nobody has a bigger chip than Rodgers and now he’s got another one, but he’s not that great anyone and fuck him.Rodgers is definitely a better QB than Favre was, but it’s so funny I’m not gonna complain.
He is the Nolan Ryan of QBsBrett Favre is the career interceptions leader and has a career passer rating two points lower than Brady has this season. He also sounds like he just doesn’t really know what he’s talking about. He should not be top 10
Yeah, he’s the guy most likely to be incensed by being omitted from the list, and the least likely to handle it constructively.I was dying at the end when they were talking about how many of the Top 100 had chips on their shoulders, cuz nobody has a bigger chip than Rodgers and now he’s got another one, but he’s not that great anyone and fuck him.
Yeah, like Brees probably shrugged his shoulders, tucked his kids in and put on a movie with his wife.Yeah, he’s the guy most likely to be incensed by being omitted from the list, and the least likely to handle it constructively.
Please let someone ask him about it, preferably 17 times.
Manning not unanimous? I need an explanation on that one.QUARTERBACK (10): Sammy Baugh, Tom Brady*, John Elway, Brett Favre, Otto Graham*, Peyton Manning, Dan Marino, Joe Montana*, Roger Staubach, Johnny Unitas*.
* Unanimous selection
nfl.com
If Peyton Manning isn't a unanimous selection, someone needs their voting rights stripped. All of the others make sense.QUARTERBACK (10): Sammy Baugh, Tom Brady*, John Elway, Brett Favre, Otto Graham*, Peyton Manning, Dan Marino, Joe Montana*, Roger Staubach, Johnny Unitas*.
* Unanimous selection
nfl.com
Manning not unanimous? I need an explanation on that one.
maybe it's a case of someone saying, he's going to make it, so I'll give a vote to someone else?If Peyton Manning isn't a unanimous selection, someone needs their voting rights stripped. All of the others make sense.
Curran being home team snarky. Bless him. But I don’t remember who votes, so...Manning not unanimous? I need an explanation on that one.
Play-off Peyton?If Peyton Manning isn't a unanimous selection, someone needs their voting rights stripped. All of the others make sense.
Smaller committee than you might think, only a handful of coaches/players/media, and Curran wasnt one of themCurran being home team snarky. Bless him. But I don’t remember who votes, so...
This is a very accurate comparisonHe is the Nolan Ryan of QBs