Manning Legacy: Scrotal Recall

jcd0805

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 3, 2007
4,012
Florida
it doesn't make sense that Sly was "testing" the reporter because he brought him to his house and offered him a syringe full of drugs taken from his refrigerator that was also full of drugs, I mean why would he incriminate himself like that if he thought Liam was really a reporter? Makes zero sense, I hope there are multiple agencies looking into this guy now.
 

mwonow

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 4, 2005
7,137
There are a lot of different discussions going on.

1) Is the report reliable?
2) Does the report, even if true, show that Peyton used HGH (for example, could his wife have been using them to get pregnant)?
3) Is there enough information for the NFL to take action against Peyton?
4) Is the NFL's action (or lack thereof) consistent with their actions in the deflation story?
5) Is the media's reaction to this story consistent with their reaction to the deflation story?
6) Are the NFL rules regarding usage by players of HGH in particular antiquated?
7) Are the NFL rules regarding usage by players of PEDs in general antiquated?
I think this is a good list, but I believe there's at least one omission: 8) is there enough here to interest the government in launching a probe?

The NFL will bury this, because apart from DFG, BountyGate, and to a lesser extent, the cap stuff with the Cowboys and Skins, that's what it does. "Consistency" (#4) is a complete joke - the league didn't take any meaningful action against the Broncos for cap stuff, or against multiple other teams/players for ball inflation stuff.

But independent oversight is something the NFL desperately wants to avoid, even to the extent of having Goodell make up new charges against Brady to provide additional substance to his court case and appeal. If the feds step in, the most nervous party won't be Peyton, Keller or Mike Neal - it'll be Czar Roger.

Personally, that would suit me just fine - and if Peyton (and/or Keller, and/or the sainted Pack) end up as collateral damage, so much the better.
 

Marciano490

Urological Expert
SoSH Member
Nov 4, 2007
62,317
I'm not going to engage anymore in the debate about PED's not being harmful or dangerous. Been in two communities the last 30 years - bodybuilding and drug recovery - and have seen way too much of this. If you choose not to believe it's a big deal, fine. But there's a reason this shit is illegal.

Aside from the obvious danger is the inescapable unfairness issue. Yes, it does sound hokey but it really does get to the very essence of competitive sports and insuring a level playing field. And that in and of itself is what makes this an important sports story.
How has your experience in the bodybuilding community convinced you of the dangers of responsible PED use?
 

BigSoxFan

Member
SoSH Member
May 31, 2007
47,238
I am 99% convinced that Sly is covering his ass now. If he were really testing Liam's purpose, why would he mention James Harrison? How many Brits would know who he is? Like 5? He also mentions on tape that he just got a text from Clay Matthews. If the Feds want to investigate, and they probably will given the high profile of some of the names, they could easily ask AJ for the time/date of the footage and cross reference that with cell phone records. The NFL can ignore all they want but if the Feds get involved like with MLB, they won't be able to sweep it under the rug.
 

pappymojo

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 28, 2010
6,684
I know it's asking too much to ask people to watch the documentary, but Manning really isn't the central figure in this case.

If I were an investigator and the league showed a genuine interest in pursing this case (unlikely, unless AJ forces their hand), the primary guys that I'd be looking into are Dustin Keller (who is retired, and obviously has nothing to gain by cooperating with an investigation, unless criminal charges are involved) and Mike Neal (seems to be a central figure in getting the Packers access to Sly).
Thread title = Report: Peyton Manning linked to HGH
 

pappymojo

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 28, 2010
6,684
I think this is a good list, but I believe there's at least one omission: 8) is there enough here to interest the government in launching a probe?

The NFL will bury this, because apart from DFG, BountyGate, and to a lesser extent, the cap stuff with the Cowboys and Skins, that's what it does. "Consistency" (#4) is a complete joke - the league didn't take any meaningful action against the Broncos for cap stuff, or against multiple other teams/players for ball inflation stuff.

But independent oversight is something the NFL desperately wants to avoid, even to the extent of having Goodell make up new charges against Brady to provide additional substance to his court case and appeal. If the feds step in, the most nervous party won't be Peyton, Keller or Mike Neal - it'll be Czar Roger.

Personally, that would suit me just fine - and if Peyton (and/or Keller, and/or the sainted Pack) end up as collateral damage, so much the better.
Not trying to derail the thread, but I don't think the bolded above is true (unless you are referencing another violation).

http://yourteamcheats.com/DEN#Salarycapgate-1996

PUNISHMENT: The Broncos were fined on two separate occasions for salary cap shenanigans between 1996 and 1998. The first punishments were announced in 2001 and the second in 2004. Their fines totaled a staggering $1,918,000 and they lost a total of two third-round draft picks.
 

jcd0805

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 3, 2007
4,012
Florida
I am 99% convinced that Sly is covering his ass now. If he were really testing Liam's purpose, why would he mention James Harrison? How many Brits would know who he is? Like 5? He also mentions on tape that he just got a text from Clay Matthews. If the Feds want to investigate, and they probably will given the high profile of some of the names, they could easily ask AJ for the time/date of the footage and cross reference that with cell phone records. The NFL can ignore all they want but if the Feds get involved like with MLB, they won't be able to sweep it under the rug.
If he were testing Liam's purpose why would he show him a refrigerator full of (probably) illicit drugs?
 

mwonow

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 4, 2005
7,137
Not trying to derail the thread, but I don't think the bolded above is true (unless you are referencing another violation).

http://yourteamcheats.com/DEN#Salarycapgate-1996
Guess I'd blipped that part out of my memory - thanks for the reminder (of the fines and the need to research before posting!). I'd probably still argue that losing cap space in future years, as the NFC East teams did, is a more fitting punishment (rather than just docking an owner a fraction of his annual NFL profits), but your point stands - my apologies for the misrepresentation.
 

djbayko

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
25,965
Los Angeles, CA
Yeah, and I suggested that the title be changed, because as I pointed out earlier, Manning is really a peripheral figure in the case.
The thread title seems fine to me. Surprise! Shady doctors everywhere are willing to write scripts for athletes for money. Surprise! Athletes are willing to take PEDs and pain killers for money and fame. Peyton Manning - all-time great country boy - is what everyone wants to talk about. Add more angles if you want, but his name needs to stay in it or we're not being honest with ourselves.
 

dabombdig

New Member
Aug 14, 2008
261
quincy, ma
Yeah, and I suggested that the title be changed, because as I pointed out earlier, Manning is really a peripheral figure in the case.
Agree with this but Manning has really made himself even more of a central figure with his full court media press of piss and vinegar.

Also it is crystal clear to me that Sly is using Mort to cover his own ass. This to me is not even up for debate.
 

SumnerH

Malt Liquor Picker
Dope
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
32,013
Alexandria, VA
It's a fake line, the 'level playing field' argument. It's arbitrary and not very helpful. The playing field will never officially be level when you're talking about contracts that go into the hundreds of millions of dollars, but it certainly is level enough. Because every player is doing something. That something might be diet and exercise and yoga and drinking a lot of water. And another might be taking HGH. I am clear that I couldn't care less what people take.
Leaving morality and legality aside, sports are entirely about setting up a system of arbitrary rules and then seeing who can win under those rules. Yoga and exercise and diet and water are inside the arbitrary rules. HGH is outside them. Making the opponent's goalposts a bit narrower isn't harmful or immoral in any abstract sense, but it's still cheating and should be punished accordingly.

How has your experience in the bodybuilding community convinced you of the dangers of responsible PED use?
Even in medically controlled cases, HGH causes increased rates of diabetes and joint problems/carpal tunnel problems.
 

Devizier

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 3, 2000
19,584
Somewhere
How has your experience in the bodybuilding community convinced you of the dangers of responsible PED use?
I don't know if this actually exists. Because they are controlled substances, PEDs aren't as extensively tested as commercial prescription drugs. Synthetic human growth hormone didn't even exist a generation ago (recombinant hGH was first purified in 1981). What we know about excessive GH levels in humans comes from people who suffer from a pituitary condition known as acromegaly. While there have been some small-scale studies designed to test the effects of GH on athletic performance, there aren't enough to form anything close to consensus. Acromegaly is also pretty rare, so there's not a lot of information out there on what GH actually does to adults. In that sense, people who are using synthetic hGH for performance enhancing purposes are self-experimenting.

Obviously, testosterone and its analogs has been available for a lot longer, and it's pretty much widely documented what steroid abuse does to your body.
 

E5 Yaz

polka king
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 25, 2002
90,565
Oregon
From nearly four years ago, an obituary for Facts:

"American society has lost confidence that there's a single alternative," she said. "Anybody can express an opinion on a blog or any other outlet and there's no system of verification or double-checking, you just say whatever you want to and it gets magnified. It's just kind of a bizarre world in which one person's opinion counts as much as anybody else's."

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2012-04-19/news/ct-talk-huppke-obit-facts-20120419_1_facts-philosopher-opinion
 

mwonow

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 4, 2005
7,137
Agree with this but Manning has really made himself even more of a central figure with his full court media press of piss and vinegar.

Also it is crystal clear to me that Sly is using Mort to cover his own ass. This to me is not even up for debate.
"Mort" has proven himself to be a flack for RG&Co. If he's covering for Sly, it's because a Sly cover-up is consistent with the NFL's objectives.

There's no reason to cite "Mort" as an authority on this or anything else - he should be treated with the same disdain as Dr. Chao.
 

Marciano490

Urological Expert
SoSH Member
Nov 4, 2007
62,317
I don't know if this actually exists. Because they are controlled substances, PEDs aren't as extensively tested as commercial prescription drugs. Synthetic human growth hormone didn't even exist a generation ago (recombinant hGH was first purified in 1981). What we know about excessive GH levels in humans comes from people who suffer from a pituitary condition known as acromegaly. While there have been some small-scale studies designed to test the effects of GH on athletic performance, there aren't enough to form anything close to consensus. Acromegaly is also pretty rare, so there's not a lot of information out there on what GH actually does to adults. In that sense, people who are using synthetic hGH for performance enhancing purposes are self-experimenting.

Obviously, testosterone and its analogs has been available for a lot longer, and it's pretty much widely documented what steroid abuse does to your body.
Abuse being the key word.
 

Marciano490

Urological Expert
SoSH Member
Nov 4, 2007
62,317
Most people I know get monthly blood panels analyzed. So abuse being doses that are messing with your liver or prolactin or lipids.
 

SumnerH

Malt Liquor Picker
Dope
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
32,013
Alexandria, VA
I don't know if this actually exists. Because they are controlled substances, PEDs aren't as extensively tested as commercial prescription drugs. Synthetic human growth hormone didn't even exist a generation ago (recombinant hGH was first purified in 1981). What we know about excessive GH levels in humans comes from people who suffer from a pituitary condition known as acromegaly. While there have been some small-scale studies designed to test the effects of GH on athletic performance, there aren't enough to form anything close to consensus. Acromegaly is also pretty rare, so there's not a lot of information out there on what GH actually does to adults. In that sense, people who are using synthetic hGH for performance enhancing purposes are self-experimenting.
While synthetic HGH is from the 1980s, cadaver HGH was used for decades before that and as early as the 1950s there were studies of the effects on adults..

The Annals of Internal Medicine did a metastudy that examined 31 different studies on HGH in adults (most of them studying it as an anti-aging drug*) and attempted to assess the risks; it's one of the biggest studies on the impact of HGH use in adults, but it's still very much an open field of inquiry.

*Spoiler alert: it doesn't stop or reverse aging
 

JimBoSox9

will you be my friend?
SoSH Member
Nov 1, 2005
16,677
Mid-surburbia
I've been saying for years Al Jazeera should have run all day and all night with "AJA News" as their brand when they stood up their America division, and I feel like the extra dose of 'consider the source' handwringing going on is total vindication. Fact: for my money, they're running the best general-purpose cable news network and national news website going these days. Mike Ditka has the mental activity of a block of wood.
 

soxfan121

JAG
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2002
23,043
From nearly four years ago, an obituary for Facts:

"American society has lost confidence that there's a single alternative," she said. "Anybody can express an opinion on a blog or any other outlet and there's no system of verification or double-checking, you just say whatever you want to and it gets magnified. It's just kind of a bizarre world in which one person's opinion counts as much as anybody else's."

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2012-04-19/news/ct-talk-huppke-obit-facts-20120419_1_facts-philosopher-opinion
Facts are survived by its illegitimate offspring, Willful Ignorance.
 

soxhop411

news aggravator
SoSH Member
Dec 4, 2009
46,506
A quick personal note. From 5th grade to 8th grade I was prescribed and took HGH(6 shots a week at home) (my doctor worked at children's hospital in LA) the reason for me being prescribed HGH was that I was growing at an extremely slow (and I mean slow) pace. Hight wise I was one of the smallest kids in my class and I was near the bottom on the height percentile chart (which compares your height to other children of the same age). While taking it it seemed like I grew 2 shoe sizes every year (I now wear a 10.5 shoe) and my hands grew a bunch (I can now palm a basketball and fully wrap my hands around an iPhone 6+)

After taking it my height was slightly above average for my age (I am now 5'9 at 23yrs).

I can probably say that had I not taken HGH as a child (and just let my body grow on its own) I would still be below average height wise which I'm kind of glad I'm not.
 

jtn46

Member
SoSH Member
Oct 10, 2004
9,771
Norwalk, CT
I watched it last night. There's nothing for Manning to sue over, the documentary never says "Peyton Manning used HGH" it lets Sly tell that story and elaborates on that story. Sly could be full of shit, the amount of namedropping he does is excessive, but AJ's plant doesn't even seem to know of many of the people Sly mentions, so it comes off as more of him trying to entice a prospective customer based on the array of services he offers to high profile customers (and bragging in 2015 about having Ryan Howard as a client isn't such a remarkable boast) plus they get Teagarden on camera, which gives Sly's account validation.

I don't know that this all means Manning is guilty as Manning was Guyer's client, not Sly's, but the documentary certainly makes a case that it's worth looking into and if HGH was being prescribed and sent to his wife that is going to put Peyton in one hell of a spot. Roger should probably ask for Peyton's cell phone, at least.
 

caesarbear

New Member
Jan 28, 2007
271
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/al-jazeera-peyton-manning-transcript_56814cf4e4b0b958f659d99c

Recorded Message “Thank you for calling the Guyer Institute of Molecular Medicine, if this is a true medical emergency please hang up and dial 911…”

Heather: This is Heather can I help you?

Deborah: Hello Heather, I wonder if you can. I need to do an employment verification on a gentleman called Charles Sly.

Heather: Yes

Deborah: He is a pharmacist and I believe he did a rotation with you is that right? Do you know him?

Heather: Yes. Uh-huh.

Deborah: Can you possibly give me the precise dates?

Heather: I can. It will be just a minute.

(Hold music)

Heather: Sorry to keep you waiting.


Deborah: No that’s fine thank you.

Heather: It looks like he was here in the fall of 2011. The start date we have, where we signed for him, was 10-17 of '11.

Deborah: 10-17-11. OK. Do you know how long he stayed with you?

Heather: I think it’s for a couple of months. Like 3 months maybe.

Deborah: Great. Can I just check one other thing? Was he in house in your pharmacy or was he also out and about on rounds?

Heather: Oh. He was in our pharmacy.

Deborah: OK. That’s great. It sounds like you know him then?

Heather: Yes. I knew him when he was here.


Deborah: Thank you so much.
 

Bone Chips

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2009
736
South Windsor, CT
How has your experience in the bodybuilding community convinced you of the dangers of responsible PED use?
Jeez where to start? I guess I'll give an example of the worst tragedy I witnessed - one of my best friends from childhood. After 15 years of steroid abuse the guy became an unrecognizable mess of a human being, to the point that when he eventually committed suicide it was generally viewed as a merciful end for both him and his family. I was also friends with Bill Romanowski before and after he became famous. Obviously not as horrific an ending as the first case, but the all-consuming anger and deteriorating mental condition of what was truly a good guy - was exactly the same and still leaves me shaking my head when I think about what was wasted. But I guess you could say that these weren't examples of responsible PED use. Kind of a trick question, and maybe my sarcasm meter is busted?

In any event, let's get back to bashing the media. It's more fun and we all seem to agree at how much they suck.
 

Marciano490

Urological Expert
SoSH Member
Nov 4, 2007
62,317
Jeez where to start? I guess I'll give an example of the worst tragedy I witnessed - one of my best friends from childhood. After 15 years of steroid abuse the guy became an unrecognizable mess of a human being, to the point that when he eventually committed suicide it was generally viewed as a merciful end for both him and his family. I was also friends with Bill Romanowski before and after he became famous. Obviously not as horrific an ending as the first case, but the all-consuming anger and deteriorating mental condition of what was truly a good guy - was exactly the same and still leaves me shaking my head when I think about what was wasted. But I guess you could say that these weren't examples of responsible PED use. Kind of a trick question, and maybe my sarcasm meter is busted?

In any event, let's get back to bashing the media. It's more fun and we all seem to agree at how much they suck.
Not a trick question, just pointing out the difference between use and abuse. Sorry for your loss. Sincerely.
 

djbayko

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 18, 2005
25,965
Los Angeles, CA
Alright, that's good enough for me. Good on AJ for putting that out there.

The likelihood of Manning announcing retirement after this season has got to have just gone up.
It should also give everyone more confidence in other claims made in the doc...when AJ makes a definitive statement, they've shown an ability to back it up.
 

PedroKsBambino

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 17, 2003
31,369
Alright, that's good enough for me. Good on AJ for putting that out there.

The likelihood of Manning announcing retirement after this season has got to have just gone up.
I've got "On the advice of doctors, who fear permanent damage from continued attempts to play, Peyton Manning today tearfully announced his retirement from the NFL. Manning said it was a difficult choice, and only concerns about his family should he be injured led him to walk away from the game"
 

GeorgeCostanza

tiger king
SoSH Member
May 16, 2009
7,286
Go f*ck yourself
I happen to think Manning is guilty as sin. Now I'm very curious to see how far down the rabbit hole of lies he's willing to go.

To explain shipments of HGH in her name do we get a press conference with Manning and wife tearfully coming out with her having HIV from a charity appearance with Charlie Sheen gone wrong?
 

brandonchristensen

Loves Aaron Judge
SoSH Member
Feb 4, 2012
38,559
Really? I have to go out for a while and recorded Monday Night Countdown for scanning later. Can always erase it.
Eh, ya never know. But ESPN.com and their Football section don't have anything. The NFL subreddit has nothing.

Bleacher Report has nothing.
 

wibi

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
11,843
Eh, ya never know. But ESPN.com and their Football section don't have anything. The NFL subreddit has nothing.

Bleacher Report has nothing.
There are two posts up about it on the NFL subreddit front page. One is the Brady support and the other is the Manning saying he is going to sue. Is there a master thread? No but saying the NFL subreddit has nothing is a bit misleading