Let's Talk about the manager -- The John Farrell Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

RedOctober3829

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
55,298
deep inside Guido territory
The worst move was to sub out Drew. I could care less about his bat. I want him in the field. I said it in the top half of the inning it was a mistake and it turned out correct. He makes that play to start the inning off.
 

czar

fanboy
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
4,312
Ann Arbor
Not that it was all his fault (and this is somewhat reactionary), but Breslow's playoff xFIP is still on the upswing.

Farrell's insistence on using him as a high-leverage guy for multiple outs has burned him last two games.
 

smastroyin

simpering whimperer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2002
20,684
RedOctober3829 said:
The worst move was to sub out Drew. I could care less about his bat. I want him in the field. I said it in the top half of the inning it was a mistake and it turned out correct. He makes that play to start the inning off.
 
Presumably part of this move was to get WMB's defense in.  I would love to know how they ended up with him in such lousy position if they intended to use him that way.
 

One Red Seat

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Oct 30, 2003
1,221
Guilderland, NY
Dummy Hoy said:
Given all the concern for Buchholz tomorrow, especially after hearing reports of how he looked throwing today, why the hell would you burn Doubront today when Clay may need someone sooner?
Bringing Doubront in there isn't the issue. Taking him out when he was cruising is the head scratcher.
 

smastroyin

simpering whimperer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2002
20,684
I agree, but he is a better 3B than Xander, and Xander may or may not be (he took a lousy route to Carpenter's ball) worse than Drew.  And he is a better hitter right now than Drew, particularly against a lefty.  So I can see making the move.  I just (still) don't understand his positioning.  
 
And yeah, he choked on the play too.  Can't whiff there, at least you have to knock it down.
 

djhb20

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Feb 7, 2004
1,887
10025
What the hell is this? Why not Napoli?!?!?!

Just to be clear. Napoli and then Uehara. I mean, what the hell was that?
 

Ed Hillel

Wants to be startin somethin
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2007
43,559
Here
Maybe Workman will strike out the next 35 batters in a 24 inning game, but I literally do not believe what I just saw.
 

Plympton91

bubble burster
SoSH Member
Oct 19, 2008
12,408
I trust Workman more than anyone left other than Uehara, and they need a bunch more innings tonight. Get past Rosenthal, then go to Napoli.


Edit, now I don't understand.

This may be the series whee the loss of both Bailey and Hannrahan finally bites them in the ass
 

LostinNJ

New Member
Jul 19, 2005
479
I don't want to blame this one on Farrell. Uehara's not supposed to give up a double there, Saltalamacchia's not supposed to throw the ball away, and Middlebrooks is not supposed to trip the runner.
 

Paul M

Moderator
Moderator
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 2, 2000
10,387
Falls Church, VA
Farrell seems out of his element managing in the NL.
 
They battled like hell to come back and were on the verge of getting blown out, but the 7th inning two games in a row was costly.
 
Not sure why they didn't walk Jay to load them for Kozma and the pitcher/pinch hitter.
 
Do they go to Breslow again when it counts?
 
Most frustrating post-season loss since Game 7 of the ALCS in 2003.
 

Paul M

Moderator
Moderator
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 2, 2000
10,387
Falls Church, VA
Yes, hope I never see a throw to 3B on a 50-50 play again. With Pete friggin Kozma on deck.
 
Having said that, why pitch to Jay with first base open and Pete Kozma due up?
 
There had to be some way to avoid having Workman bat, but yes, seems like a reliever short though when you get 4 innings from your starter, what can you do?
 

RedOctober3829

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
55,298
deep inside Guido territory
Farrell had multiple fireable moves tonight. His absolute worst game of the season. Mike Napoli not getting a chance in the 9th while letting Brandon Workman(?????????) hit is not acceptable. So is taking out Drew. His fielding positioning with WMB on Holliday's hit in the 7th. Not walking the bases loaded in the 9th to pitch to .550 OPS Pete Kozma.

I don't complain about this crap much, but there was move after move after move that made absolutely no sense. Get it together.
 

glennhoffmania

meat puppet
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 25, 2005
8,411,591
NY
I said this in the game thread- it seems like Farrell didn't fully prepare for NL baseball. Overall I like the guy but he looked like he was in over his head tonight.
 

Seels

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2005
4,948
NH
RedOctober3829 said:
Farrell had multiple fireable moves tonight. His absolute worst game of the season. Mike Napoli not getting a chance in the 9th while letting Brandon Workman(?????????) hit is not acceptable. So is taking out Drew. His fielding positioning with WMB on Holliday's hit in the 7th. Not walking the bases loaded in the 9th to pitch to .550 OPS Pete Kozma.

I don't complain about this crap much, but there was move after move after move that made absolutely no sense. Get it together.
This was my biggest issue of the night. I don't really care about the Workman call because they clearly intended on him going another inning, and you can save Napoli for WMB or a pitcher later.
 
What I don't get is the positioning of the corner infielders and outfielders in late innings. Middlebrooks playing that far out is crazy, and Nava playing basically centerfield in the 9th was fucking idiotic. What is the rational for this?
 

FredCDobbs

Member
SoSH Member
Feb 5, 2004
563
Austin
I don't utterly hate letting Workman hit then pulling him after one batter.  He was hoping he could go longer, saw he didn't have much left and didn't compound his mistake by leaving him in.  Uehara had NOTHING tonight.  
 
Not walking Jay to set up the force is the just plain wrong decision that he should get shit for.  
 
The one I'm personally mad at is Salty.  That throw and the decision to throw were an abomination.  Kozma on deck fuck me!
 

NomarRS05

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 13, 2006
3,393
McLean, VA
I just hate that he brought in Uehara in the middle of an inning instead of giving him a clean slate. Koji hadn't pitched in five days and it's game three, you count on him to go two innings one way or another. Lots of baffling decisions there. If you're going to leave Workman in, then why remove Doubront earlier in the game when he did? I thought this was by far Farrell's worst game of the post-season.
 

smastroyin

simpering whimperer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2002
20,684
Yeah, the thing about the Workman decision is that you were forced into putting yourself into that position with the earlier call to not let Doubront try and get you more outs.  If you let Doubront pitch the seventh then you have all of your options available for the 8th and 9th.  Yes, it was terrible luck that they gave up the two runs in that inning (combined with terrible play/positioning by WMB), but that doesn't change the facts all that much.  In the same way that Salty's ill-conceived throw was only the impetus for the two bad things that happened afterward (missed catch and crap call) this decision caused the cascade that led to Brandon Workman batting in the ninth inning of a tie game 3 in the World Series.
 
And again, the Gomes PH is a problem for me not just because he did it at all.  It's because he did it with Gomes, who is slumping as much as anyone on the team not named Drew, and he did it with two outs and nobody on.  And he did it knowing that he needed to get at least 9 outs from his bullpen.  If literally any of those factors were different I would buy the argument.  But none of them were.
 

JimD

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 29, 2001
8,681
I've been giving Farrell the benefit of the doubt all month long, but I can't excuse tonight's brainfarts.  It's not all on him but he certainly is not helping.
 

JCizzle

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 11, 2006
20,530
Can he really start Salty again? I hate pretty much everything he did today other than PH'ing Carp and starting Nava. 
 

Gunfighter 09

wants to be caribou ken
Moderator
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2005
8,548
KPWT
I have no problem with stealing an out with Workman and handing Koji the ball with a man on 1st and one out with a tie game in the 9th. With the slowest man on the planet at 1st and Craig and Jay coming up, I felt like Farrell's bullpen management had put them in a good spot. 
 
The game was lost by: 
 
1. Salty's terrible decision to throw to third
2. Koji giving up a double to Craig
3. Not walking Jay
 

soxhop411

news aggravator
SoSH Member
Dec 4, 2009
46,276
Could Felix being pulled be related to tomorrow's game given the uncertainty of Clay? If he cannot last long your only option would then be Dempster.
 

Paul M

Moderator
Moderator
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 2, 2000
10,387
Falls Church, VA
I'm surprised folks are ok with Uehara not starting the 9th. Managers that hold out their best reliever usually get grief. I can sort of live with it, and obviously once Workman hit, it's a non-starter, but if Workman gave up a HR to the first batter, I bet the outcry would be deafening. Having already burned through the key set up arms, I guess you had to try to squeeze another inning out of Workman. But then he's lifted after one batter...hope the accelerates the learning curve for Farrell.
 

Lynchie

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2003
1,862
Willoughby
Throwing the ball around was not Farrell, given. Seems like they should have talked about that after last game. However his removal of Doubront when he was clearing baffling the Cards set in motion some soon to be felt events. Breslow looks over his head the last two times out then we all saw the cascade of bad things.
 

Lynchie

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 21, 2003
1,862
Willoughby
Throwing the ball around was not Farrell, given. Seems like they should have talked about that after last game. However his removal of Doubront when he was clearly baffling the Cards set in motion some soon to be felt events. Breslow looks over his head the last two times out then we all saw the cascade of bad things.
 

Paul M

Moderator
Moderator
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 2, 2000
10,387
Falls Church, VA
Have to think Morales as frightening as the prospect is, might need to be an early option given St. Louis' relative performance vs. LH. Doubront could go another 25-30 pitches I guess, but how many times has he had to come back after throwing 25 pitches like tonight? And what can you expect from Workman again since he threw 30 pitches. Just hoping Buchholz can summon the strength a la Pedro in 1999 to give them 6 strong innings. A 4 or 5 inning outing two nights in a row would be very difficult to manage especially with the pitcher having to bat.
 

JimD

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 29, 2001
8,681
Really worried about game 4.  This is as must-win as it gets, but the Sox cannot count at all on Buchholz for much of anything, never mind the ideal six or seven.  Farrell has to manage the pitching aggressively and lean on Jon Lester to give the pen a breather on Monday.  I just don't have much faith in his decision-making right now.
 

Harry Hooper

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jan 4, 2002
34,368
Paul M said:
Have to think Morales as frightening as the prospect is, might need to be an early option given St. Louis' relative performance vs. LH. Doubront could go another 25-30 pitches I guess, but how many times has he had to come back after throwing 25 pitches like tonight? And what can you expect from Workman again since he threw 30 pitches. Just hoping Buchholz can summon the strength a la Pedro in 1999 to give them 6 strong innings. A 4 or 5 inning outing two nights in a row would be very difficult to manage especially with the pitcher having to bat.
 
Doubront gets maybe a batter, but is probably better used behind Lester in Game 5. Dempster is the man after Buchholz for tomorrow, apparently.
 
 
Farrell is right about one thing, the Sox can't win with Nava starting.
 

JimD

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 29, 2001
8,681
I'd love to know what John Henry is thinking right now about Farrell's performance.  He cannot be happy with what he is seeing.
 

Paul M

Moderator
Moderator
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 2, 2000
10,387
Falls Church, VA
Dempster is the first man? Oh boy...we're f*cked barring Clay dealing a miracle. St. Louis hits RHP very well; Ryan Dempster was horse-crap vs. RH hitters like Holliday, Molina, and even Freese. Maybe out of the pen he's more effective, but you can't expect a very effective multi-inning performance. So, lifting Doubront arguably prematurely for Game 4 is not a rationale. Relying on Dempster for the 5th-7th innings is just too risky. It's also just harder to get one of these performances in a close game in an NL park.
 

Reverend

for king and country
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jan 20, 2007
64,026
JimD said:
I'd love to know what John Henry is thinking right now about Farrell's performance.  He cannot be happy with what he is seeing.
I honestly can't even ken what an appropriate response to this would look like.
 

JakeRae

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 21, 2005
8,125
New York, NY
I fail to understand how anyone can argue that not walking Jay contributed to losing the game. Jay hit a ground ball that was fielded, a play was made at the plate, and there should've been 2 outs and runners on the corners. That's pretty much exactly what you are hoping for in that situation (it's not much different from a strikeout or pop up). Now, it may have been the wrong decision, I certainly won't argue that. Especially considering Uehara's command, it's hard to argue against setting up the double play. But, the decision, even if wrong, was not a factor in losing the game. The factors in losing the game were Salty making a terrible decision, Middlebrooks not coming off the bag to make sure that ball stays in front of him, and the umps decision to call obstruction. As for that last point, we have a thread on the subject already, and it probably should stay out of this thread, but it can't be ignored as a factor independent of the question of if it was correct.
 

Stitch01

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
18,155
Boston
That was quite the combination of poor decision making combined with not catching a single fucking break to get bailed out of a poor decision. I thought each tactic was probably defensible, but they fit together into a fucked up strategic whole.
 

ifmanis5

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 29, 2007
63,743
Rotten Apple
Ultimately the players decide the game. However, the following moves are Ron Washington level bad:
 
- Taking Felix out when he was clearly dealing
- Burning his bench in the 7th
- Yet, letting Workman hit
- Not using Napoli, esp in Workman's spot
- Not walking Jay to get to Kozma
 
The last is easily the worst in my mind. Just indefensible.
 

Paul M

Moderator
Moderator
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Mar 2, 2000
10,387
Falls Church, VA
Yep, walk Jay allows you to pitch to Kozma and with Molina on 3B you could almost play the infield back or not quite so far in and get the lead runner, and also with Molina you can afford to play the outfield a little bit closer to normal. First base was open and the run meant nothing. Uehara has walked, um, no one all year. It's impossible to offer a defense to that move.
 
And the more I think about Doubront not being able to pitch much tomorrow (game 4), you're not exactly conserving anything by lifting him. Their chances of winning were greater if that happened. In a game where they came back from 2 down twice and had some big-time tough outs and ABs, they pissed it away with poor managing and a couple bad on-field decisions.
 

teddykgb

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
11,016
Chelmsford, MA
JakeRae said:
I fail to understand how anyone can argue that not walking Jay contributed to losing the game. Jay hit a ground ball that was fielded, a play was made at the plate, and there should've been 2 outs and runners on the corners. That's pretty much exactly what you are hoping for in that situation (it's not much different from a strikeout or pop up). Now, it may have been the wrong decision, I certainly won't argue that. Especially considering Uehara's command, it's hard to argue against setting up the double play. But, the decision, even if wrong, was not a factor in losing the game. The factors in losing the game were Salty making a terrible decision, Middlebrooks not coming off the bag to make sure that ball stays in front of him, and the umps decision to call obstruction. As for that last point, we have a thread on the subject already, and it probably should stay out of this thread, but it can't be ignored as a factor independent of the question of if it was correct.
 
This is a really strange post... you sort of answer your own question.  But let's start with Jay's AB.  He didn't hit a routine ground ball to Pedroia.  Pedroia made a hell of a  play.  If we're going to play the alternate reality game, then there are lots of alternate realities where the winning run walks to the plate on a GB through a drawn in infield.  There's also an alternate reality where Kozma hits the same ball Jay did and they turn a double play on him to get out of the inning with the infield at medium depth.  Anyway, to come back to your post, I don't see how you can say that the fact that Pedroia managed to field the ball would mean that the decision didn't cost us. We don't get to see the world where JF does the right thing and walks Jay, but I feel pretty confident it doesn't end exactly as this did.  Maybe this is all semantics, if you're just trying to say that the game wasn't irrevocably lost at that point, then sure, but I'm not sure what that really changes.
 
To me, this is just basic strategy.  In the bottom of the 9th as an away team, the runner on first is completely irrelevant.  Unless the disparity between the hitters is large, you ALWAYS put the man on and create a force situation.  Hell, if Salty only has to force at the plate on a ball similar to the one Jay hit instead of tagging, that's likely the difference between turning the DP at first or getting the runner on the way to 3rd (assuming a better throw).  The only legitimate reason to pitch to Jay is if for some strange reason you think Uehara is far better in a matchup versus Jay than he is against Kozma, or, even worse, you think Kozma is a significantly better hitter than Jay.  I honestly think this is nearly indefensible, "hunch" managing.  You have to put the runner on base.
 
Similarly, the entire sequence that led to Workman batting was a disaster.  Farrell has admitted as much, but I'm completely flabbergasted that they seemingly didn't understand the mechanics of a double switch enough.  You can argue that maybe they didn't know they wanted more out of Workman until they saw that he was pitching well, but deferring the pitcher/pinch hitter decision when strikeout machine Saltalamacchia was up was a relatively basic maneuver.  I'm almost certain Matheny would have done it.  Especially since it was setup so well with the end of the order spot, this was pretty much the textbook for it.
 
Pinch hitting Gomes was also a complete waste.  Maybe they wanted to save Doubront, or they felt Doubront had given them all they had.  At least I hope that is true.  With 2 outs they were really forcing it and were far too aggressive.  Gomes hasn't been hitting and you need him to hit a double for that to work out at all, and realistically you need him to hit a HR, because even a double didn't guarantee anything.  In a lot of ways, they played the situations backwards, as others have pointed out, and left Workman in when they should have made a move, and were too quick to pull on Doubront, burning Gomes in the process.  When the time to take a lead came up, they were once again stuck with Salty at the plate and very few PH options.  
 

brs3

sings praises of pinstripes
SoSH Member
May 20, 2008
5,200
Jackson Heights, NYC
This game was easily the worst managed postseason game I've ever witnessed. The comedy of errors by Farrell is deafening, and I can only hope the team rallies around the idea of an injustice rather than notice the incompetence of a manager to compete in an NL ballpark. It's like Farrell took a day off.

I rarely criticize a manager. Tonight's game was a head scratcher early and often. The umps didn't blow this game, JF did.
 

smastroyin

simpering whimperer
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2002
20,684
It's also worth noting that WMB's positioning on the Holliday 2B is probably something Farrell has to answer for as well.  I have to assume Taz missed location badly given WMB's positioning, but this isn't the first time this year that the fielders and pitchers haven't been on the same page with the plan of attack.  I realize that Holliday golfed a pitch way out of the strike zone and maybe that was a set up to induce weak contact on pitches on the outer half of the plate, but it still seems odd.
 
And yes, I think the right move would have been to try and leverage Doubront for as many outs as you can.  They are going to need 12 outs from the bullpen tomorrow most likely.  Would have been nice to avoid work for Breslow or Workman or both.
 

JCizzle

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 11, 2006
20,530
Paul M said:
Dempster is the first man? Oh boy...we're f*cked barring Clay dealing a miracle. St. Louis hits RHP very well; Ryan Dempster was horse-crap vs. RH hitters like Holliday, Molina, and even Freese. Maybe out of the pen he's more effective, but you can't expect a very effective multi-inning performance. So, lifting Doubront arguably prematurely for Game 4 is not a rationale. Relying on Dempster for the 5th-7th innings is just too risky. It's also just harder to get one of these performances in a close game in an NL park.
 
I agree pulling Doubront was likely premature. He was cruising and his spot was up with nobody on and two out, just take the out and let him pitch another inning or two to save the pen for whatever the hell Clay gives you tomorrow. 
 

Sox and Rocks

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 16, 2013
5,826
Northern Colorado
brs3 said:
This game was easily the worst managed postseason game I've ever witnessed. The comedy of errors by Farrell is deafening, and I can only hope the team rallies around the idea of an injustice rather than notice the incompetence of a manager to compete in an NL ballpark. It's like Farrell took a day off.

I rarely criticize a manager. Tonight's game was a head scratcher early and often. The umps didn't blow this game, JF did.
Agreed.  Farrell started shitting all over this game from the moment he filled out a lineup card with Salty's name in it til' the 9th.  Just horrendous all around
 
Status
Not open for further replies.