I still listen to The Watch, but yeah, Andy can be a bit much at times. Like on the most recent episode, he ripped this week's episode of House of the Dragon for being boring. If you want to rip it as creepy because of the foot stuff, fine. If you want to want to say you don't understand why Rhaenys didn't have her dragon incinerate the usurpers in the final scene and it's a plot armor copout, fine. But to say that episode is boring is just trolly.
That said, Andy is a fantastic interviewer. That's his true calling. He should be doing a late night show like Tomorrow, or whatever that show that followed the late late night shows was called (was it Later?) I could see him being successful in a half-hour interview show with one interview subject (or a duo like Tegan and Sara).