JD and the opt out

Danny_Darwin

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 19, 2005
1,239
Don't worry, I'm not going to talk about whether or not it benefits the team or not. But I do think this will be one of the more significant stories hanging over the Red Sox between now and November, and, since it came up in the "Down on the Farm" thread, and it's been a slow news week, I figured why not see if there's a discussion worth having. If nothing else, this can be a place to talk about his performance over the course of the unofficial second half and how it will affect his decision-making.

For what it's worth, he was asked about it during All-Star week, and basically said he has no idea what he's going to do. He says he wants to stay, but, what else would he say? Dombrowski, who's usually pretty upfront about things, also said they're not really considering an extension at this time, although obviously that could change.

He's having a pretty good year, not quite at last year's level, and the market for his services would be pretty different than even last year, so that's two factors right there. But it's something to keep an eye on for now.
 

DeadlySplitter

Member
SoSH Member
Oct 20, 2015
17,696
He’s had worse nagging back issues this year than last. He’s going to rapidly become DH only and already was a below average fielder. He shouldn’t find better than 3/75 as a DH, but Boras could convince him he can, or some dumb team would.
 

Sandy Leon Trotsky

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 11, 2007
2,274
I think they'll resign him for something like 4/$100M. I doubt anyone will offer him more than 20M per but DD must know they got a ton of value for him last year
 

moondog80

heart is two sizes two small
SoSH Member
Sep 20, 2005
5,151
I've never thought he was going to opt out. He didn't have many suitors last time around, and now he'll be two years older, and two years more of a DH. I think it would be very risky for him.

This is true. It's also true that he was still regarded as something of a fluke last time around, and that won't be the case now. With the very-good-but-not-great first half he had, I think he's on the cusp, let's see what happens the rest of the way.
 

NDame616

will bailey
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2006
1,740
I don't think he opts out nor the Sox extend him. Extending a 32 year old DH with a recurring back problem seems like a bad idea
 

DisgruntledSoxFan77

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 12, 2015
696
Quincy
I think he stays one more year. Believe he's scheduled to make the same next year as he did this year and last, and after next year his salary drops quite a bit. Just a hunch
 

brandonchristensen

mad photochops
SoSH Member
Feb 4, 2012
23,537
I think they'll resign him for something like 4/$100M. I doubt anyone will offer him more than 20M per but DD must know they got a ton of value for him last year
I hope they don't increase his salary if the market doesn't dictate it. I'd be surprised if they give him a raise coming off a down year.
 

E5 Yaz

Transcends message boarding
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 25, 2002
59,669
Oregon
They're under zero pressure to give him even more money. Why would, or should they?

He's not going to get a bigger contract should he opt out; but, if he wants to test the market, thanks for being a big part in the fourth title in 14 years.
 

azsoxpatsfan

Member
SoSH Member
May 23, 2014
255
I hope they don't increase his salary if the market doesn't dictate it. I'd be surprised if they give him a raise coming off a down year.
I agree with you about not increasing the salary, but he’s on pace to hit .304 with like 35 home runs. Not as good as last year, but hardly a down year
 

chawson

Well-Known Member
Bronze Supporter
Aug 1, 2006
1,449
The Yankees are losing Gardner and Encarnacion, the White Sox were shut out of free agency last year and have to replace Abreu, and the Astros could use a DH once they trade Reddick and move Alvarez to the outfield. I think there may be competition for JDM.
 

jon abbey

Shanghai Warrior
Dope
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
42,637
The Yankees are losing Gardner and Encarnacion, the White Sox were shut out of free agency last year and have to replace Abreu, and the Astros could use a DH once they trade Reddick and move Alvarez to the outfield. I think there may be competition for JDM.
I mean, those guys don't all just vanish, if they are leaving, they need destinations. As of now, I think NY will resign Gardner (and they still have Clint Frazier and Andujar for now), they will probably let Encarnacion go but I don't see them in on JDM. Chicago really likes Abreu, so he might re-sign there, and Houston doesn't like to sign big FA deals plus they have Cole up for FA who they probably want to keep and will have to spend big for if they do. If anything, I think they would prefer to keep Alvarez at DH, but they have Tucker itching for a OF spot and waiting in AAA also.
 

Mueller's Twin Grannies

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 19, 2009
4,495
Of course the Yankees will go after JDM; he'd probably hit 15 short porch HR a season and will replace Encarnacion as the strict DH. Not looking into him would be GM malpractice for a team that appears poised to go on a long run of being a contender, plus it would really hurt their biggest division rival. And they clearly have the pieces, as illustrated by their early season dominance despite being a M*A*S*H* unit fielding a lot of AAA players, to make deals to shed some salaries and restock with shrewd moves.

If JDM opts out and wants to go where the money is, I can't see the Yankees passing on him.

If the roles were reversed and JDM was in a position to leave the Yankees and the Red Sox had Encarnaction and Gardner on expiring deals, I'd be really upset if Dombrowski didn't dial JDM's agent to talk shop.
 

j44thor

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
8,951
NYY have to consider Judge as their long-term DH. As good as he is in the OF there is little chance of his body holding up and he'll be 28 next year. If they want him healthy for the next 5-8yrs DH is his spot. Keep him in the OF and I'll be surprised if he lasts 3 more years full time. MLB is simply not a sport for guys Gronk's size.
 

Red(s)HawksFan

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 23, 2009
10,529
Maine
NYY have to consider Judge as their long-term DH. As good as he is in the OF there is little chance of his body holding up and he'll be 28 next year. If they want him healthy for the next 5-8yrs DH is his spot. Keep him in the OF and I'll be surprised if he lasts 3 more years full time. MLB is simply not a sport for guys Gronk's size.
Shouldn't Stanton be in the same category? And they've got him locked up for 9 more years, unlike Judge who they only have control of for three more years. Seems like the Yankees would be better served to have the DH slot as a respite to rotate guys through rather than lock in a full time occupant for that spot.

Edit: I know Stanton has the opt-out following next year, but with the way contracts have been trending, I can't see him getting a longer deal than the 8 year one he'd be walking away from.
 

Al Zarilla

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
49,117
San Andreas Fault
NYY have to consider Judge as their long-term DH. As good as he is in the OF there is little chance of his body holding up and he'll be 28 next year. If they want him healthy for the next 5-8yrs DH is his spot. Keep him in the OF and I'll be surprised if he lasts 3 more years full time. MLB is simply not a sport for guys Gronk's size.
A good comp, Dave Winfield played OF into his 40s. I don’t know if it was the case with him, but some outstanding hitters, like Manny, have put their foot down and refused to DH. And he was a marginal outfielder, to say the least. If Judge wants to play RF, I don’t think Boone, or Boone with Cashman next to him are going to go against him. JMO of course.
 

maufman

Anderson Cooper x Mr. Rogers
Staff member
Dope
Gold Supporter
A good comp, Dave Winfield played OF into his 40s. I don’t know if it was the case with him, but some outstanding hitters, like Manny, have put their foot down and refused to DH. And he was a marginal outfielder, to say the least. If Judge wants to play RF, I don’t think Boone, or Boone with Cashman next to him are going to go against him. JMO of course.
I’m not sure if modern statistical analysis would back this up, but Winfield was considered an elite defender in his prime. I don’t see him as a good comp for anyone we’re discussing.
 

j44thor

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
8,951
A good comp, Dave Winfield played OF into his 40s. I don’t know if it was the case with him, but some outstanding hitters, like Manny, have put their foot down and refused to DH. And he was a marginal outfielder, to say the least. If Judge wants to play RF, I don’t think Boone, or Boone with Cashman next to him are going to go against him. JMO of course.
Winfield's listed playing weight was 220 lbs. Judge is closer to 270 lbs. Manny was puny compared to Judge.
The question to me isn't if Judge wants to play the OF it is what will his body allow him to do.
 

glennhoffmania

but still failing
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 25, 2005
8,396,594
NY
Judge has a very good arm, and he's fine for RF in Yankee Stadium since it's little league dimensions, but I wouldn't say he's a very good OF overall. His defensive abilities shouldn't be a reason to prevent him from becoming a DH. Whether he'll do it willingly or be more like Manny is another story.

I didn't realize he was that old. So he isn't going to be a FA until he's 30. I doubt someone will give him a big contract to be a RF when he's 31.
 

Red(s)HawksFan

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 23, 2009
10,529
Maine
A good comp, Dave Winfield played OF into his 40s. I don’t know if it was the case with him, but some outstanding hitters, like Manny, have put their foot down and refused to DH. And he was a marginal outfielder, to say the least. If Judge wants to play RF, I don’t think Boone, or Boone with Cashman next to him are going to go against him. JMO of course.
Winfield ceased to be a full time outfielder by the time he hit age 40. Starting with his age 40 season, he was the DH in more than 80% of his games played (350 out of 422).
 

Minneapolis Millers

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
1,939
Twin Cities
The MFYs can go after anyone I suppose, but RH DH power bat isn't super high on their list. They could use more lineup balance and SP.

Astros will likely need to spend on pitching, too. And they've got plenty of OFs.
 

Al Zarilla

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2005
49,117
San Andreas Fault
Winfield's listed playing weight was 220 lbs. Judge is closer to 270 lbs. Manny was puny compared to Judge.
The question to me isn't if Judge wants to play the OF it is what will his body allow him to do.
Winfield is listed at 6’6. With today’s weight training, what would he weigh? My bigger point is some guys have such stature that they play wherever they want (at least outfield vs. DH). I think Judge has that stature, at least so far.
 

geoflin

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Feb 26, 2004
377
Melrose MA
I don't see J.D. opting out after this year. He isn't having as good of a year as he had in 2017 and after that year the Red Sox were his only suitors. Since then the free agent market has, if anything, become more difficult for high priced players and he'll be two years older this time around. I don't think he would get more money this winter than his current contract already would pay him. Of course Boras might feel differently and try to convince him otherwise.
 

Sandy Leon Trotsky

Member
SoSH Member
Mar 11, 2007
2,274
Egos guys. JDM likely thinks he's worth more than he's making even with his down year (and I'm expecing to see a great second half). He'll opt out but likely just be looking for more $ and more years with the Red Sox. I realize his market isn't huge and the Sox may be bidding against themselves (teams actually do this all the time of course) and give him much more money and years than anyone else offers. But as a full time DH (AND HE SHOULD BE A FULL TIME DH!!!) he should be able to be worth that over the 2020-2024 seasons. Keeping him in a lineup with an emerging stud like Devers, Betts and X and this team will be able to stay competitive for that whole time.
 

chrisfont9

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 2, 2007
4,469
seattle
He's had three very good seasons in his career, and he'll be 32, so unless he adds a fourth one this year, two in a row, he won't have a good case for more $. Sox should be willing to take the risk if he wants to opt out.
 

E5 Yaz

Transcends message boarding
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Apr 25, 2002
59,669
Oregon
The Yankees are a very unlikely suitor for JDM. They have plenty of power, plenty of DH's, and some youngsters are going to start getting expensive before long.
Regardless, DD sure as hell isn't going to act out of fear over what the MFYs might possibly do.
the yankees are far more likely to make a play for Mookie
 

jon abbey

Shanghai Warrior
Dope
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
42,637
Judge has a very good arm, and he's fine for RF in Yankee Stadium since it's little league dimensions, but I wouldn't say he's a very good OF overall.
OK, but he is. Last year Mookie led all right fielders in MLB with 20 DRS, but Judge was second with 14, and that was only playing 112 games (DRS is a counting stat). He's not Mookie, but he is really good, covering a surprising amount of ground, and can even play CF in a pinch although NY tries to avoid it if at all possible.

But back to the context of this discussion, I don't think JDM will opt out, but if he does, the competition would not be the Yankees or Astros, it would more likely be a team trying to make a statement like the Orioles.
 

BaseballJones

goalpost mover
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
5,486
I think they'll resign him for something like 4/$100M. I doubt anyone will offer him more than 20M per but DD must know they got a ton of value for him last year
I like the idea of trying to extend him now for something like this. I'd say more like 4/92, averaging $22 million a season. Currently he's slated for (if he doesn't opt out) $23.75 in 2020, $19.35 in 2021, and $19.35 in 2022 for a total of $62.45 million over three seasons ($20.8 per year on average). If he agreed to opt out and then sign this new deal with the Sox (not even sure how they could actually legally agree on this ahead of time; what's to stop him from opting out, having a handshake agreement in place with the Sox, and then another team offers more? I don't know if MLB would work like the NFL on this.), he'd be getting an additional guaranteed $29.55 (they could round it up to an even $30 mil to make it look nice). For the Sox, it would lock him up at a pretty reasonable rate, nothing too crazy.
 
Jul 5, 2018
126
NYY have to consider Judge as their long-term DH. As good as he is in the OF there is little chance of his body holding up and he'll be 28 next year. If they want him healthy for the next 5-8yrs DH is his spot. Keep him in the OF and I'll be surprised if he lasts 3 more years full time. MLB is simply not a sport for guys Gronk's size.
If they use Judge as their DH they would lose about $10 million in value. They also have Stanton who would be a better candidate for DH.

His injuries to date have been related to batting; a fractured wrist from a HPB last year and an oblique strain this year.
I like the idea of trying to extend him now for something like this. I'd say more like 4/92, averaging $22 million a season. Currently he's slated for (if he doesn't opt out) $23.75 in 2020, $19.35 in 2021, and $19.35 in 2022 for a total of $62.45 million over three seasons ($20.8 per year on average). If he agreed to opt out and then sign this new deal with the Sox (not even sure how they could actually legally agree on this ahead of time; what's to stop him from opting out, having a handshake agreement in place with the Sox, and then another team offers more? I don't know if MLB would work like the NFL on this.), he'd be getting an additional guaranteed $29.55 (they could round it up to an even $30 mil to make it look nice). For the Sox, it would lock him up at a pretty reasonable rate, nothing too crazy.
I don't get why he needs to exercise his opt-out. There are only two parties so can't they agree to whatever they want?