Another poster for the collection.
View: https://twitter.com/ChrisForsberg_/status/1737696469287567757
https://x.com/AdamHimmelsbach/status/1737717825262027134?s=20
Last edited:
Another poster for the collection.
View: https://twitter.com/ChrisForsberg_/status/1737696469287567757
I trust Tatum more in almost all situations…however, at the end of the game, I like Brown having the ball.I seem to trust JB’s ability to create offense more than Tatum, at least right now. He’s got more in his offensive arsenal.
You aren't the only one who has been actively biting their tongue (with the exception of a group of folks who haven't appeared in a while, but I'm sure are waiting for the next bad game he has). Obviously, my man crush on Jaylen Brown around here is really only rivaled by @tbb345 and we've been on that hill together for years. Frankly, what I'm seeing from Jaylen now isn't a whole lot different than what I've seen for a long time, with one exception. He seems to be accepting of the fact that his 3 ball isn't falling, and he recognizes that guys like White/KP/PP/Hauser are dropping them at insane rates, so instead of taking the 3, he's going to the hoop and blasting off and either finishing with ferocity or kicking it out. Last year, those kick outs always seemed to end up in the hands of Marcus Smart, now they're ending up in the hands of Derrick White. In the last 7 games, he's only had 1 game where he took more than 5 3PA's, and that was because he was smoking hot, going 5/8 in that game. Prior to that, he was averaging 7.0 3PA per game. He's not thinking, he's just doing and that's always been the best version of him. Full speed Jaylen.Last night was instructive. It may seem cheap to revisit this thread every time JB has a good game and drop in a told-you post.
Jaylen is absolutely killing it the last week or two. This team is a juggernaut at every level.Brown is averaging a career high in assists and the fewest turnovers in 5 years.
This just came into my head when reading this and maybe it's BS but I think it's worth a discussion...You aren't the only one who has been actively biting their tongue (with the exception of a group of folks who haven't appeared in a while, but I'm sure are waiting for the next bad game he has). Obviously, my man crush on Jaylen Brown around here is really only rivaled by @tbb345 and we've been on that hill together for years. Frankly, what I'm seeing from Jaylen now isn't a whole lot different than what I've seen for a long time, with one exception. He seems to be accepting of the fact that his 3 ball isn't falling, and he recognizes that guys like White/KP/PP/Hauser are dropping them at insane rates, so instead of taking the 3, he's going to the hoop and blasting off and either finishing with ferocity or kicking it out. Last year, those kick outs always seemed to end up in the hands of Marcus Smart, now they're ending up in the hands of Derrick White. In the last 7 games, he's only had 1 game where he took more than 5 3PA's, and that was because he was smoking hot, going 5/8 in that game. Prior to that, he was averaging 7.0 3PA per game. He's not thinking, he's just doing and that's always been the best version of him. Full speed Jaylen.
I'm not sure if I really believe this, but some would say that getting the giant contract has made Jaylen less concerned about scoring and his numbers now that he's got the bag. That has led to better playmaking and maybe more effort on the defensive end.It's great to see that the big contract has not led to a diminished effort. He's going full blast on offense and defense, and he's still learning to play better.
Sounds like a cool story, someone should inform DARKO of his leap on both ends.I'm not here for "I told you so"; I'm here to enjoy a 27 year-old somehow making a big leap on both ends.
Yeah there's something to be said for the bolded for sure. I've noticed that he seems to have a much better idea of where the cost/benefit line is now on passes, without having to think and process mechanically real-time. Not to say that he won't force still (he's testing the fences), but on the whole he seems to have expanded his vision concentrically if that makes sense.This just came into my head when reading this and maybe it's BS but I think it's worth a discussion...
I think Jaylen's weakest reads/vision/ability to pass are to the corners. This year it's been a lot more of pick and pop and passes that are to the middle of the floor/NOT the corners.
I believe that's why KP has helped him so much. He can run those pick and pops, pop and get a high percentage 3 off quick. I LOVE Al Horford but his shooting motion is slow as fuck. Those pick and pops with Horford popping just aren't that scary to the defense because most of the time they can recover.
IMO, this steady diet of being able to feed KP/White has improved his confidence markedly and we are now seeing him think less and read more.
It's really a joy to watch.
Whether people want to admit it or not, last night was a game where there were a lot of people waiting in the weeds to shit on Jaylen if it didn't go well. No Tatum and he was the hub of the offense...and he knocked it out of the fucking park.
I am going to toot my own horn here and say that I called this in the "Hot Takes" thread (I believe @Jimbodandy was on this as well). His passing ability and ability to read the defense has been gradually improving for the last two years but you had to squint to see it. Now it's fully on display
DARKO does something weird with forward looking projections. If you change the time scale x-axis to games played the trend line goes out to somewhere close to 700 games. Jaylen has only played 601 games to date (496 regular season and 105 playoffs). I don't trust that he is actually trending down the way the curves indicate for the right most portions of the graphs.Sounds like a cool story, someone should inform DARKO of his leap on both ends.
I see pretty much the same guy honestly (still a very good and useful player of course).
Really good individual scorer, some highlight dunks, mental lapses on D, trending down 3 PT%, maybe a bit more ornery with the media. His ball handling looks about the same to me (maybe taking a few less risks?), the TO% is a tick down and the assists are a tick up.
He does have some nice chemistry with KP so far, but big picture he's the same (very good) guy with worse 3 PT shooting.
View attachment 75390View attachment 75391View attachment 75392
Yeah I kinda agree with this too. And while some have stated it as some kind of confidence in the guys that JB and JT are passing too, I don't think that's it really. I think that JH and KP are more intelligent offensive players and know where to be, know how to shake defenders, have more physical attributes that help with scoring (height/explosiveness), and better skills to convert those good looks. I love Grant, Marcus, and Rob, but none are the offensive basketball savants that Jrue and KP are. And DW is a certified genius.I'm not sure if I really believe this, but some would say that getting the giant contract has made Jaylen less concerned about scoring and his numbers now that he's got the bag. That has led to better playmaking and maybe more effort on the defensive end.
I think a big thing this year is the team is just much better offensively in terms of spacing and having high IQ players that now how to cut. We know the two-man game with Porzingis has been great, and you add in Jrue and D-White in a bigger role, it's a different squad and that has given Jaylen more space to attack and more options to playmake for.
DARKO is weighing a set of pretty bad games still into the regressions, not just the last few weeks of awesomeness. If JB keeps playing like this, the line should start moving back up. He didn't finish last year's regular season well, was spotty in the playoffs, and took a bit to get going this year. All data matters.DARKO does something weird with forward looking projections. If you change the time scale x-axis to games played the trend line goes out to somewhere close to 700 games. Jaylen has only played 601 games to date (496 regular season and 105 playoffs). I don't trust that he is actually trending down the way the curves indicate for the right most portions of the graphs.
I'm not going to address the DARKO graph. I am not smart enough to understand all that goes into that secret sauce and I am not going to pretend that I am. So I am just going to address the eye test portion of this...Sounds like a cool story, someone should inform DARKO of his leap on both ends.
I see pretty much the same guy honestly (still a very good and useful player of course).
Really good individual scorer, some highlight dunks, mental lapses on D, trending down 3 PT%, maybe a bit more ornery with the media. His ball handling looks about the same to me (maybe taking a few less risks?), the TO% is a tick down and the assists are a tick up.
He does have some nice chemistry with KP so far, but big picture he's the same (very good) guy with worse 3 PT shooting.
That makes sense. It is interesting to me that the leading 10-15% of each trend line is projected data while the trailing 85-90% is based on actual data.DARKO is weighing a set of pretty bad games still into the regressions, not just the last few weeks of awesomeness. If JB keeps playing like this, the line should start moving back up. He didn't finish last year's regular season well, was spotty in the playoffs, and took a bit to get going this year. All data matters.
Think about those players (in the bolded, I removed Rob because I think I could get an assist or two to prime TimeLord on a pick and roll) that are being replaced though and where they thrive/what their limitations are and what Jaylen's strengths and limitations are....Yeah I kinda agree with this too. And while some have stated it as some kind of confidence in the guys that JB and JT are passing too, I don't think that's it really. I think that JH and KP are more intelligent offensive players and know where to be, know how to shake defenders, have more physical attributes that help with scoring (height/explosiveness), and better skills to convert those good looks. I love Grant, Marcus, and Rob but none are the offensive basketball savants that Jrue and KP are. And DW is a certified genius.
If DARKO thinks that Jaylen Brown has been trending down the past 1-2 months, the problem is DARKO, not Jaylen.Sounds like a cool story, someone should inform DARKO of his leap on both ends.
I see pretty much the same guy honestly (still a very good and useful player of course).
Really good individual scorer, some highlight dunks, mental lapses on D, trending down 3 PT%, maybe a bit more ornery with the media. His ball handling looks about the same to me (maybe taking a few less risks?), the TO% is a tick down and the assists are a tick up.
He does have some nice chemistry with KP so far, but big picture he's the same (very good) guy with worse 3 PT shooting.
View attachment 75390View attachment 75391View attachment 75392
Just the difference between KP and TL is pretty dramatic if you just think from an offensive skillset perspective. TL was a very good roller and lob threat, but that was pretty much it. KP not only provides a lob threat, but he also can stretch the floor with his shooting, and is way, way more advanced passer out of the high post than Rob was (although TL could be sneaky good at that at times). Swapping those two players and it's no surprise everyone's offense is going to hum better.Yeah I kinda agree with this too. And while some have stated it as some kind of confidence in the guys that JB and JT are passing too, I don't think that's it really. I think that JH and KP are more intelligent offensive players and know where to be, know how to shake defenders, have more physical attributes that help with scoring (height/explosiveness), and better skills to convert those good looks. I love Grant, Marcus, and Rob, but none are the offensive basketball savants that Jrue and KP are. And DW is a certified genius.
I won't pretend to understand the statistical details of DARKO, but personally I don't really look at the line as much as the data points.DARKO is weighing a set of pretty bad games still into the regressions, not just the last few weeks of awesomeness. If JB keeps playing like this, the line should start moving back up. He didn't finish last year's regular season well, was spotty in the playoffs, and took a bit to get going this year. All data matters.
He's played 600+ games and you're talking about a 13 game sample size. I think people are looking at they want to see and assuming it's some epiphany. He has had plenty of similar stretches in his career (or better).I'm not going to address the DARKO graph. I am not smart enough to understand all that goes into that secret sauce and I am not going to pretend that I am. So I am just going to address the eye test portion of this...
I am honestly stunned that you have watched him play, basically since the Charlotte game, and you see the same player.
As much as I sometimes appear to be the marketing department for DARKO, I don't think that I know more about how it calculates than most. What I will say is that it's factoring in all data, with some recency weighting for sure. But it wouldn't be very useful if it over-weighted the last few weeks of a guy in his eighth year.I won't pretend do understand the statistical details of DARKO, but personally I don't really look at the line as much as the data points.
Simplistically, it seems to be just smoothing out a "best fit" and not necessarily the most up to date version of the data (the most recent data points sometimes are in the opposite direction of the line, as you alluded to).
But is there some reason to not believe the actual data points? I don't see signs of some significant improvement on a more granular level, at least on DARKO.
The line is also (I assume) meant to be a nice smooth aesthetically pleasing view of the data. Bowiac can chime in if I'm way off here.As much as I sometimes appear to be the marketing department for DARKO, I don't think that I know more about how it calculates than most. What I will say is that it's factoring in all data, with some recency weighting for sure. But it wouldn't be very useful if it over-weighted the last few weeks of a guy in his eighth year.
I'm not going to argue about the 13 game sample size (nor that people are looking for what they want to see. I think we are all guilty of that around here)He's played 600+ games and you're talking about a 13 game sample size. I think people are looking at they want to see and assuming it's some epiphany. He has had plenty of similar stretches in his career (or better).
Jaylen is good and I do think he's had a stretch of improved play. I'm hoping the KP connection is real and he continues to pick his spots to attack in an efficient way. He does seem a bit more energetic on D to my eye, though still loses his man way to often off the ball.
But big picture, I see a pretty similar guy. I don't buy the downward trajectory of the best fit line going forward (as JBD said its weighting a lot of semi-recent poor performance heavily), but I also can't say I see some big leap at age 27. His 3 PT shooting is definitely dragging down his overall value.
Yeah I remember that same play. Read and react, help came his way, bam, super open 3 for KP. It portended good things to come last night. Last year, he was deciding what to do before the move.I'm not going to argue about the 13 game sample size (nor that people are looking for what they want to see. I think we are all guilty of that around here)
I feel like I am pretty good about noticing these changes for all Celtics players, and IMO, there's a real difference between right now and anything I've ever seen from him.
It was a very small play at the beginning of the game but I made a comment about it in the Game Thread. Jaylen initiated the offense and made a semi-no look chest pass to KP for a 3. It was completely in the shooting pocket, which allowed KP to step into the 3 and go up all in one motion. It was a high level pass that, quite frankly, you don't see a ton of around the NBA anymore. I will die on the hill that Jaylen doesn't make anything close to that read and pass before.
Two things.Maybe someday, Jaylen will level up to where Aaron Gordon is. Dare to dream:
Correct.This is why I never stick to any one advanced stat. Blend+eye test is the way.
Don't you think you're missing context and things we know about the individual with this? I mean, if we are talking about a generic create a player here, odds are heavily skewed in your favor.Well I for one certainly hope Jaylen's last dozen or so games have unlocked a new real level of playmaking from him.
I would say more often than not for someone with more than 600 games under their belt, it's more likely either entirely not real or not as real as some want to believe it is (as far as projecting future play).
I was constantly pointing out early in the season that Jaylen's turnover numbers this year were being heavily skewed by offensive fouls, moving screen variety in particular, which count as turnovers. His career high in offensives was 27 last season (before that, it was 21), this year, he was at like 9 through 16 games. Now, he's at 11 through 26 games, and his turnover #'s have plummeted as it has regressed.Up to and through the zero-assist 30 point game, JB was at 3.2/2.5 A/TO ratio. Really not that great.
Then ESPN put up an insta post calling him out, JB called them "corny," and he has produced a 5.1/2.1 ratio. Much better.
Maybe a coincidence, maybe a little extra motivation, maybe a penny dropping, maybe a little bit of each. But interesting to note.
The thing is I don’t think he has.He's played 600+ games and you're talking about a 13 game sample size. I think people are looking at they want to see and assuming it's some epiphany. He has had plenty of similar stretches in his career (or better).
It would be weird if it took that to change his approach, but whatever works. My hope is coaching has played a role. KP no doubt helps, but half of this has been with KP off the court, it’s more than that.Maybe a coincidence, maybe a little extra motivation, maybe a penny dropping, maybe a little bit of each. But interesting to note.
Don't you think you're missing context and things we know about the individual with this? I mean, if we are talking about a generic create a player here, odds are heavily skewed in your favor.
But the context about his new teammates that's been provided in this thread along with things that we know about Jaylen (maniacal worker, improves every offseason, a renewed offseason focus on reading defenses after the Miami debacle) I think it's much more likely that somethings been unlocked than you seem to be willing to admit.
If you ask the Kings, I'm pretty sure they'll all say KP is tangible.We watch Jaylen, we follow the Celtics, we can create a story that fits what we are seeing and make it seem “real”.
I have a feeling fans of most players with a similar short term improvement in one facet of their game can create similar stories to fit their narrative.
If the odds are heavily skewed in my favor for a generic situation, we should be careful assuming Jaylen is some outlier.
Why? He’s trying harder? It’s all the addition of KP? Maybe I dunno. I wish there was a more tangible reason, like he just got new contacts or something.
We want it to be real and it’s tempting to create an entirely logical reason that Jaylen has unlocked something.
Time will tell. I’ll be rooting for it along side everyone else here. But count me as at least moderately skeptical.
This is not exactly right, sample size is good and necessary for all kinds of statistical approximations. But sports statistics are confounded by the fact that you can’t repeat conditions. A player taking a hundred shots is not the same as a hundred rolls of the dice. Each shot is taken in a different context. Some are more alike than others, but even if you control for game situation or opponent (for example) there are a bunch of unknowns that are impossible to control for."Sample size" is only meaningful for activities with lots of variance.
Worth remembering also that progress is not linear. Tatum is a perfect example of that. He goes through stretches where things aren't clicking--particularly but not solely his outside shot--and then they are again. Brown still has some 0 assist 4 turnover games in him this season. But he has been on a good run of doing things that we're not used to seeing. Where the eyeball test factors IMO is in identifying whether a guy who has 5 assists is creating looks or just passing out of trouble to a shooter who buries a contested shot. What we have been seeing a lot of lately is the former, not the latter.This is not exactly right, sample size is good and necessary for all kinds of statistical approximations. But sports statistics are confounded by the fact that you can’t repeat conditions. A player taking a hundred shots is not the same as a hundred rolls of the dice. Each shot is taken in a different context. Some are more alike than others, but even if you control for game situation or opponent (for example) there are a bunch of unknowns that are impossible to control for.
That is where scouting comes in, among other things. But the reason why statistics work so well is that we still have biases and preconceptions that cloud our vision. I agree with everyone here that Jaylen has made a kind of leap. But it’s worth proceeding with caution and not dismissing lines of evidence that disagree with us.
3 TO and 0 assists Dec 1 against Philly and 3 TO and 0 assists Dec 4 against Indy. Were those games before or after he was sprinkled with the magic playmaking dust? Perhaps we can throw out those games from our memory and evaluationBrown still has some 0 assist 4 turnover games in him this season.
Best part about this shit is that we get to watch it play out.3 TO and 0 assists Dec 1 against Philly and 3 TO and 0 assists Dec 4 against Indy. Were those games before or after he was sprinkled with the magic playmaking dust? Perhaps we can throw out those games from our memory and evaluation
Agree on progress not being linear and if even a portion of this is sustainable rather than inevitable variation, I will be stoked. But people here pretending he's somehow suddenly unlocked some masterful playmaking dimension to his game are likely to be disappointed.
I'm actually more hopeful the 3 pointer comes back closer to his peak. That's something he's shown he can do over the course of 2 seasons.
Sure, but we’ll continue to disagree here. Those of us who think Jaylen is flawed but good will likely continue to see that, and attribute a lot of what others are seeing to the fact that his teammates, and thus the team, are better. Others will see Jaylen as improved and lifting the team. Like, earlier people were posting about how this is a 50 win team without Tatum. That’s probably not far off but in my mind it’s not because Jaylen is a guy who can carry a team to 50 wins, it’s because each of Porzingis, Jrue, White, and Jaylen are very good players and Horford is still pretty good too. So we’re seeing the same thing from the team, but our belief as to the cause is different.Best part about this shit is that we get to watch it play out.
I think the bolded is true, but this is also what people are seeing in Jaylen's improvement: he's learning to maximally work with those other guys, particularly KP and DWhite.Sure, but we’ll continue to disagree here. Those of us who think Jaylen is flawed but good will likely continue to see that, and attribute a lot of what others are seeing to the fact that his teammates, and thus the team, are better. Others will see Jaylen as improved and lifting the team. Like, earlier people were posting about how this is a 50 win team without Tatum. That’s probably not far off but in my mind it’s not because Jaylen is a guy who can carry a team to 50 wins, it’s because each of Porzingis, Jrue, White, and Jaylen are very good players and Horford is still pretty good too. So we’re seeing the same thing from the team, but our belief as to the cause is different.
...
+11 for Brown without Tatum is massive, and includes the whole season, not just cherrypicking the past month.The Celtics have typically had a big gap in performance with Tatum on the court (and Brown off it) compared to the flip side of that. Not anymore. Even with Tatum on the bench, lineups with Brown in them have stomped opponents by more than 11 points per 100 possessions. That success is not entirely because of Brown’s improvements, but his newly refined floor game has helped the Celtics flow smoothly. His playmaking opportunities have jumped significantly when Tatum hits the bench. Brown has more than doubled his assists from 4.1 per 100 possessions to 8.3 per 100 possessions during his minutes without Tatum on the court, according to PBP Stats. The latter number is much improved compared to last season.
I enjoy having the title favorite, personally lol. I’d also say let’s see where the numbers look like by the midseason point and further. I’d expect them to still be really good without Tatum either way, but 5 games ago, the team had a net of +4 with Jaylen on and Tatum off. It’s still early enough that a small stretch of games really affects the overall numbers.From Jay King today:
+11 for Brown without Tatum is massive, and includes the whole season, not just cherrypicking the past month.
Even if one (correctly imo) thinks that KP and DWhite have a ton to do with this, it's non-trivial to find the guy who turns KP+DWhite+whomever into world-beaters.
DWhite is similar without Tatum, and I think my conclusion from that would be that he and JB are an elite duo, fringe All-NBA, around whom you could build quite a decent team, if not a title contender.
https://theathletic.com/5155775/2023/12/22/jayson-tatum-celtics-boston-bench/