Sorry I disagree. This is just loving a guy on your team too much. I never said anything in gamethreads when people gushed when he found a cutter who was wide open, becasue it was game threads, His exceptional athleticism allowed him to do things and get to places others couldn't and he had a good feel. Frequently his length quickness and jumping ability allowed him to effect plays few others could when he made a read. A lot of what people call smarts is often physical ability, especially reactions time. Was Manny really a smarter hitter than Terry Francona? Kevin Millar, etc? An athlete like TL with average IQ is elite player at least on D. Even when he was a beat late on closeouts his crazy length caused misses. I loved when a guy thought he was open because Rob ball watched then his go go gadget arms caused a miss anyway. Rob could stay down on fakes and jump after the defender and still block the shot. That isn't smarts, but allows him to not bite on fakes, which looks really smart. To his credit he learned to make the most out of his body. I am curious of your evidence he had elite IQ offensively. Who else is on your list? I measn he passed better than Tristan Thompson and didn't think he was a scorer like Daniel Theis. Don't you think an elite offensive mind would know to turn away from the d and drop step dunk? Especially when playin gon what to him was a nerf hoop. If Rob had elite IQ defensively he would be perhaps the best defender ever since he is at the very top of defensive athletes. If had elite D IQ he would be Bill Russell. I mean he was pretty great on D, but not the GOAT. He hovered around 1 steal per 36 minutes, pretty similar to Gianis, who we can agree relies on more on athleticism than IQ. Now Tatum has elite defensive IQ. He is so good at reading and directing closeouts. You have to rewind it to see just how perectly he read a play. When I rewound Rob's great plays you would frequently see him react the same time as other players, but the explosiveness and quickness were nuts. He had Hakeem quick jump skills, but got even higher.
My theory on Rob's his long build and extreme power are too much for the human body. He is like the WW2 fighter prototypes that flew so fast the wings fell off. His build allowed him to do things maybe nobody else could do, but the light, long frame cannot handle the Gs.