from the BoB thread:
Not a great
track record at Pittsburgh based on PFF rankings. No idea what else was going on with Steelers at the time though.
Yeah, look at the line he had in 2021:
2019: Villanueva (16), Foster (14), Pouncey (13), Decastro (16), Feiler (16)
2020: Villanueva (16), Feiler (13), Pouncey (13), Decastro (13), Okorafor (15)
2021: Moore (16-ROOKIE), Dotson (9), Green (16-ROOKIE), Turner (7), Revolving door
Green didn't play a down last year after moving to guard and not beating out Kevin Dotson for the job.
Im more excited about this move than the BoB one.
But not because I think he's an awesome offensive line coach. I'm not going to pretend to have any idea how good he is at his job. An offensive line coach is so impacted by everything around him, its really difficult to parse out a good one from a bad one without a long track record (*cough* Patriots have only won SB's with Scarnecchia and had to pull him out of a 3-year retirement to fix their offensive line problems *cough*)
And it isn't just about how successful the line is, or the players on the line (as alluded to with the above stats).
Yes, the O-line coaches job is to lead the offensive line practice, work with them on drills, work on each players weaknesses, etc.
But the role is also to work with the offensive coordinator on determining what plays to use for the upcoming game. To understand the defense, how it attacks, where the weaknesses are with his players - This player is going to have trouble with the nose's strength, they stunt 40% of the time and our guard has trouble passing assignments, etc - and to help build the plays around all that information. And while thats true for all positional coaches, the offensive line coach should have the most pull with the offensive coordinator when building out gameplans.
So, yes, of course if a line is performing poorly, thats a big part of his role. But so much rides on the relationship with the offensive coordinator, the plays at their disposal, the strength and composition of the rest of the offense - "we have no pass catching backs, but our linemen are mobile and can get downfield for screen blocks...wtf are we doing?" - and so many other things, that I think its really, really difficult to gauge how good an offensive line coach is from the outside looking in. I think its one of the few times we really just have to trust his reputation around the league and with his former colleagues. If everyone thinks hes smart and will be successful, thats a good sign for us.
It'll be interesting to see how he and BOB work together. In relation to the teams weaknesses last season, I think it'll be one of the most important relationships on the team this year. O'Brien comes off as stubborn and hard-headed, but hes also been around the block for a while now. Hopefully he understands how to let the coaches under him cook.
Either way, I'm just excited that we're getting a good blend of guys with experience (BOB) and guys on the rise (Klemm).