24-25 CFB Playoff Semifinals

Sille Skrub

Dope
Dope
SoSH Member
Mar 3, 2004
6,181
Massachusetts
Thursday, January 9th
Notre Dame (-1.5) vs Penn State
Orange Bowl, Miami FL
7:30pm ESPN

Friday, January 10th
Ohio State (-6) vs Texas
Cotton Bowl, Dallas TX
7:30pm ESPN
 

BaseballJones

slappy happy
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
27,287
I'm not a gambler, but I doubt many people had successfully wagered on this exact foursome to be left in the playoffs.
 

Traut

lost his degree
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2005
13,068
My Desk
Thursday, January 9th
Notre Dame (-1.5) vs Penn State
Orange Bowl, Miami FL
7:30pm ESPN

Friday, January 10th
Ohio State (-6) vs Texas
Cotton Bowl, Dallas TX
7:30pm ESPN
This has been a fantastic tournament. The Boise States, SMUs, Indianas and ASU’s had their chance.

A narrow loss by tOSU on the road at Oregon didn’t cost them a shot at the Championship.

The SEC got exposed. And yes, I know Texas is still in. But Georgia and Tennessee.

And I think we have 2 great games coming up along with a great Championship. I’m here for it.
 

BaseballJones

slappy happy
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
27,287
Of the four possible championship matchups, which one would you all most like to see?

ND vs. Ohio State
ND vs. Texas
Penn St vs. Ohio State
Penn St vs. Texas

I really think that Ohio State and Texas are the two best teams remaining, and either should wipe out either ND or Penn State, but this whole playoff tournament hasn't really gone as expected so who knows.
 

canderson

Mr. Brightside
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
42,124
Harrisburg, Pa.
This will be the first game Texas is an underdog since its winning road trip to Tuscaloosa in September 2023.

Texas’ D coordinator Pete K. has from what I can tell has never lost to a Chip Kelly-coached team.

Maybe Texas can remind Howard that he is a Kansas State player again.

Gonna be a tough sledding. If we had our top two RBs I’d feel much better.
 

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
40,770
Hingham, MA
Of the four possible championship matchups, which one would you all most like to see?

ND vs. Ohio State
ND vs. Texas
Penn St vs. Ohio State
Penn St vs. Texas

I really think that Ohio State and Texas are the two best teams remaining, and either should wipe out either ND or Penn State, but this whole playoff tournament hasn't really gone as expected so who knows.
Any of the 4 would make for a great matchup. I think I'm rooting for a Texas-ND final.

I think we're going to get a PSU-OSU final.
 

Dave Stapleton

Just A Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Oct 11, 2001
9,609
Newport, RI
I think the only team that got there without much of a test is PSU. I think this is easily the weakest in the bunch and has this weakest game day coach. I fully expect ND to win and the question will be can they finally be competitive in a championship game. It’s a great matchup for ND as PSU is extremely one dimensional on offense and ND/Golden will have every answer for whatever they present. And I hate ND!

Really wish we had Texas/PSU and OSU/ND. That would be a semifinal!
 

Kremlin Watcher

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 20, 2005
5,456
Orleans, MA
Would kind of prefer to play Penn State because I am certain we would win that one, but emotionally would prefer to beat Notre Dame. We are 3-9 all time against the Domers, our worst record against another major program.
 

trekfan55

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Oct 29, 2004
11,913
Panama
Very good friend of mine os a big time Longhorns fan (alumni) and this game falls smack down on Shabat for him.

Bad luck I guess.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
13,189
I think the only team that got there without much of a test is PSU. I think this is easily the weakest in the bunch and has this weakest game day coach. I fully expect ND to win and the question will be can they finally be competitive in a championship game. It’s a great matchup for ND as PSU is extremely one dimensional on offense and ND/Golden will have every answer for whatever they present. And I hate ND!

Really wish we had Texas/PSU and OSU/ND. That would be a semifinal!
Wait.. you think Penn State's offense is one dimensional? Or extremely so? They have two great RBs but also have a great TE.. their receivers aren't that bad either.. the RBs and TE are obviously their strengths. Allar threw for over 3000 yards (only 600 more yards than Leonard).. The two RBs have rushed for 1k each. They've scored 30 TDs passing and 32 TDs running (ND has 42 running and 21 passing). They ran for 3,033 yards and passed for 3,511 yards.

Allar is a lot better than the QB that ND just played.. and their offense is a lot better than Georgia's is currently. If Carter is back for the game their defense is very legit as well...especially in the second half.

Totally agree with you on Franklin as a coach... but PSU has legit talent.. they should've beaten OSU this year.. it was one of the only games they didn't score over 20...most games over 30. They were stopped twice going for it on fourth within the five against OSU... and on one of those their was obvious DPI but that may also just be my bias as a PSU alum...but even the OSU fans in front of me agreed it should have been a penalty.. and that OSU got the benefit of the whistle all game. (Their last drive was legit though and they deserved to win after running out the clock).

How tough was ND's road to get here? They played Indiana and Georgia with their second string QB that was out of sync for most of the game. (edit: and that second string QB threw for 234 yards on ND's D)

Will be an interesting game.. I've been bitten too many times in the Franklin era to be too confident, but I think their talent level isn't anywhere close to being 'easily the weakest'.. They're definitely going to be the toughest team ND has played in the playoff by a pretty significant margin...both RBs are better than both of Georgia's RBs.. and Georgia didn't have Warren either.
 
Last edited:

Dave Stapleton

Just A Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Oct 11, 2001
9,609
Newport, RI
I am not sold on PSU but obviously just an opinion. However, can we please dispense with the notion that IU was a pretender or weak team? When all is said and done they may very well have had two losses to the final two teams in the playoffs and at their stadiums! They blew out everyone but UM who then proceeded to beat OSU and Bama. They didn’t have a single close game against teams that they totally outclassed.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
13,189
I am not sold on PSU but obviously just an opinion. However, can we please dispense with the notion that IU was a pretender or weak team? When all is said and done they may very well have had two losses to the final two teams in the playoffs and at their stadiums! They blew out everyone but UM who then proceeded to beat OSU and Bama. They didn’t have a single close game against teams that they totally outclassed.
Indiana played only those two ranked opponents all year (looking at their schedule now.. were there any others that were ranked when they played them?) and lost to both of them. It's hard to know how good they were since the only ranked defenses they played were OSU and Notre Dame really and they scored less than 20 against each. Saying they beat Michigan who beat OSU..and Alabama (a lot of teams beat Alabama)... they still lost to OSU 38-15.

PSU has played five ranked opponents and lost to two...both by one score and both were ranked in the top six.. Oregon and OSU.

I get that it's an opinion..but how is PSU one dimensional given the stats? Just not sold on Allar? The numbers are still pretty good for him. That was really the main part I didn't understand.

I don't really disagree with you all that much in that I have no idea if PSU will beat Notre Dame, just not seeing how it's so obviously one sided given how they've looked in the playoff.. and if we're saying Indiana was great in the regular season..well SMU was 13-3 and Boise St was 12-2 (One of those losses to Oregon by 3 points while they also destroyed most of their competition) and Penn State pretty much wrecked both of those teams.

I say all of that fully expecting PSU to find a way to lose to ND. :)
 

cornwalls@6

Less observant than others
SoSH Member
Apr 23, 2010
6,800
from the wilds of western ma
Indiana played only those two ranked opponents all year (looking at their schedule now.. were there any others that were ranked when they played them?) and lost to both of them. It's hard to know how good they were since the only ranked defenses they played were OSU and Notre Dame really and they scored less than 20 against each. Saying they beat Michigan who beat OSU..and Alabama (a lot of teams beat Alabama)... they still lost to OSU 38-15.

PSU has played five ranked opponents and lost to two...both by one score and both were ranked in the top six.. Oregon and OSU.

I get that it's an opinion..but how is PSU one dimensional given the stats? Just not sold on Allar? The numbers are still pretty good for him. That was really the main part I didn't understand.

I don't really disagree with you all that much in that I have no idea if PSU will beat Notre Dame, just not seeing how it's so obviously one sided given how they've looked in the playoff.. and if we're saying Indiana was great in the regular season..well SMU was 13-3 and Boise St was 12-2 (One of those losses to Oregon by 3 points while they also destroyed most of their competition) and Penn State pretty much wrecked both of those teams.

I say all of that fully expecting PSU to find a way to lose to ND. :)
As an ND fan, I’m very nervous about this one. And not just the normal, big game paranoia. PSU probably brings the best combination of offensive weapons to the table that the Irish has seen. And great as the defense has been, I worry that this is the game where the injuries to key people won’t be covered up. I’m hoping for another low scoring rock fight, because ND is very comfortable/built for that kind of game. If it becomes any kind of a shoot out, I think that’s a significant advantage for PSU.
 

lars10

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
13,189
As an ND fan, I’m very nervous about this one. And not just the normal, big game paranoia. PSU probably brings the best combination of offensive weapons to the table that the Irish has seen. And great as the defense has been, I worry that this is the game where the injuries to key people won’t be covered up. I’m hoping for another low scoring rock fight, because ND is very comfortable/built for that kind of game. If it becomes any kind of a shoot out, I think that’s a significant advantage for PSU.
ND has seemed to have been able to make games a rock fight.. but I don't know much about them other than they've had some injuries on their lines. Against Georgia it looked like their main weapon was the QB running... PSU was very good at setting the edge and containing Boise State's RB.. I wonder if they'll concentrate on not letting Leonard out of the pocket.

The PSU OLine is pretty good and their two RBs find holes as good as any RBs in the country this year. If Abdul Carter is hurt then I'm not sure how well the defense will hold up. The D has been their strength most of the year as the offense has been inconsistent at times, but has scored over 20 basically every game. (Against OSU they didn't score a TD, the defense did)

On the one hand, I like PSU's chances.. on the other hand, if PSU beats ND and then has to play OSU again for the Title? Ugh.. (I think this is one of the weaker OSU teams I've seen over the years which will make it all the more painful losing to them again...if it comes to that.) ..I'd almost rather them lose to ND than have that happen..almost

Regardless.. fun to have a PSU vs ND game again...and the two teams are probably farther than anyone, including themselves, expected them to be.
 

luckiestman

Son of the Harpy
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
35,315
Really don’t want PS vs OSU because I hate conference discourse. Want ND because I’m a fan

Texas OSU, don’t care on outcome, hope it is a good game. Kind of need OSU to win so Vrabel doesn’t go there over the Jets.

Give me a ND win over OSU but Day somehow does a coaching masterclass in a loss.
 

Average Reds

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 24, 2007
36,364
Southwestern CT
For someone who has no direct rooting interest in these game, I will be rooting very hard for Texas over Ohio State.

I do not like Notre Dame, but I like Marcus Freeman, so I wouldn’t be that upset if Notre Dame won. Also, it would give me great joy to contrast the fortunes of Brian Kelly*/LSU with Notre Dame.

*Whatever one thinks of Kelly as a coach, it’s instructive to remember that he killed a kid and got Notre Dame to pay off the family and make it go away. He’s evil.
 

gmogmo

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
779
Hingham, Ma
I am not sold on PSU but obviously just an opinion. However, can we please dispense with the notion that IU was a pretender or weak team? When all is said and done they may very well have had two losses to the final two teams in the playoffs and at their stadiums! They blew out everyone but UM who then proceeded to beat OSU and Bama. They didn’t have a single close game against teams that they totally outclassed.
This couldn't be more spot on.....they also played at Ohio State significantly better than Tennessee did, never mind Oregon who got them on a neutral field.
 

natpastime162

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
3,598
Pennsylvania
ESPN had Schefter on this afternoon saying NFL teams are interested in Sarkisian. Anyone got a feel for how much interest Sark has at being a HC in the NFL?
 

canderson

Mr. Brightside
SoSH Member
Jul 16, 2005
42,124
Harrisburg, Pa.
Thanks goodness the Cotton Bowl is Friday because Dallas is going to get one of its bigger snowstorms ever Thursday it appears.

And Sark isn’t leaving Texas right now.
 

Kremlin Watcher

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 20, 2005
5,456
Orleans, MA
Forecasts for Dallas still calling for snow, but totals seem to be falling. It'll still be a mess (we were thinking of going, but driving up to Dallas in ice and snow with Texas drivers put paid to that) but the game will go as scheduled.

Ticket prices seem to be falling pretty fast though.
 

SoxJox

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 22, 2003
7,748
Rock > SoxJox < Hard Place
Not sure of the reputation or reporting veracity of this source, but Outkick is reporting...

Notre Dame Players Reportedly Have The Flu, Penn State May Have Food Poisoning

With just a few hours to go before tonight's Orange Bowl matchup between No. 5 Notre Dame and No. 4 Penn State, it appears some of the Fightin' Irish are currently Fightin' something else: The flu.

According to multiple reports, some Notre Dame players have been battling a "bad" flu for a couple of days now. However, the most recent update is that it has just been limited to "mostly backups and special teams players."

A flu that doesn't affect starters?! You don't say!
 

Ale Xander

Hamilton
SoSH Member
Oct 31, 2013
81,822
Did not go, so can go back to rooting for meteor. If I had to choose, go PSU.