Indiana played only those two ranked opponents all year (looking at their schedule now.. were there any others that were ranked when they played them?) and lost to both of them. It's hard to know how good they were since the only ranked defenses they played were OSU and Notre Dame really and they scored less than 20 against each. Saying they beat Michigan who beat OSU..and Alabama (a lot of teams beat Alabama)... they still lost to OSU 38-15.
PSU has played five ranked opponents and lost to two...both by one score and both were ranked in the top six.. Oregon and OSU.
I get that it's an opinion..but how is PSU one dimensional given the stats? Just not sold on Allar? The numbers are still pretty good for him. That was really the main part I didn't understand.
I don't really disagree with you all that much in that I have no idea if PSU will beat Notre Dame, just not seeing how it's so obviously one sided given how they've looked in the playoff.. and if we're saying Indiana was great in the regular season..well SMU was 13-3 and Boise St was 12-2 (One of those losses to Oregon by 3 points while they also destroyed most of their competition) and Penn State pretty much wrecked both of those teams.
I say all of that fully expecting PSU to find a way to lose to ND.