It's an interesting puzzle.It appears likely that this weekend could be the first time that all of the OF/DH candidates are healthy at the same time (Duran, Rafaela, O'Neill, Abreu, Refsnyder & Yoshida). It'll be interested to see what they do with all of these options available.
Here are two ways I could see them utilizing them:
1. Duran in left, Rafaela in center, Abreu in right, Hamilton at SS, Valdez at 2b, Smith/Refsnyder at 1b, O'Neill/Yoshida at DH
2. O'Neill in left, Duran in center, Abreu in right, Rafaela at SS, Hamilton at 2b, Smith/Refsnyder at 1B, Yoshida/Refsnyder at DH
Refsnyder and O'Neill are both RHH OFers and both are having VERY good seasons thus far. Utilizing one or both of them at 1B seems like it would be the best way to upgrade the team as currently constituted thus removing Dalbec from the equation again.
It would seem to me that removing Rafaela from CF would hurt the team defensively. I think we might end up with 1 VERY expensive bench player in Yoshida going forward.
What do y'all think are the best ways to maximize the roster if everyone mentioned is healthy?
Looking at the roster, I think Dalbec is clearly the most expendable, so he goes down for Abreu.
The OF puzzle is then more simple. They just rotate the players. Yoshida is a DH and will only have value for the club if he's hitting, which he's really not doing right now. So from a long term POV, they'll play him at DH. From a short term "win this game" POV, O'Neill will occasionally take the spot from him.
Without Dalbec, the IF is: Smith/Valdez/Hamilton/Devers. Romy is the floater - this year he has played, SS, 2B, 1B, CF, RF. Even so, Rafaela may be called on to play some SS and give Hamilton a break. (Frankly, once Abreu is back, I don't want to see Romy in the OF again with the hamstring issue.)
I don't think we see Refsnyder at 1B unless it's an absolute emergency. He'd have been a clear upgrade over Cooper/Smith for the past month, and he wasn't used there once.