- Jul 14, 2005
As others have said, I think Rolen's case may be slightly worse.I’m good with Rolen getting in. Similar to, slightly better case than, say, Dwight Evans, who should be in.
In any event, we've done some greatest HOF teams, greatest Sox teams, etc.
It would be interesting to see two lineups - a team of the worst HOF players at their position, against a team of Hall of the Very Good players, like Evans and Whittaker who just missed due to statistical reasons.
I'd exclude Bonds, Clemens, Schilling, Rose, etc. from that second group. A bit subjective, but the point would be to shade out more of a performance/statistical line in terms of who gets in, and who does not.