2020 Patriots Draft Prospects

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I finally got around to Tee Higgins. He might be the captain of my Why are We Overthinking This team. Honestly, he was so impressive. I watched A&M, South Carolina and Virginia and all I saw was a #1 WR. Long, crazy catch radius, great body control. He separated against press and zone, intermediate and deep. Really good stop and start, and smooth in his transitions. I guess the knock is speed and separation but I saw no issues in the three games. Not doing the combine is a red flag, but the tape is what it is. 6'4, 215#, productive from an elite program. I still like Juedy better, but Higgins was very impressive.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
Chase Claypool, I had him at a 6.5 - quality role player as a big slot. I thought he was going to run at 4.58 (not posted to SOSH but somewhere else so I can cite it if need be). In other words I thought he was going to relatively fast for a big guy. I didn't see him as a 4.45. Could he be a starting slot? Maybe. I think with him he needs to work on his blocking (Edit: blocking if he wants to be more than just a slot and get some TE lite work in and even as a slot even if at that position it isn't that important) but I think he gets a bump from 6.5 to 7.0. He ran and did some work as an X at Notre Dame even if he struggled with press and looked like his best fit was a big slot (he had success there). I think he deserves consideration sometime later on in day 3 given that he might be someone who can play a variety of roles in the offense. He is definitely a red zone threat and I like him as a vertical threat from the slot too.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
Don't write-off AJ Epenesa:

Thanks to Kent Lee Platte (@MathBomb) for posting these RAS scorecards.

Here are AJ's scores graded on a DL curve:

28735

Here are AJ's scores graded as an edge:

28736


We know from this piece what is important for DTs under 310:

Height (positive coefficient), weight (negative coefficient), BMI (positive coefficient), Weight Speed Score, 3-Cone (negative correlation).

AJE is tall for an edge and a tackle, has a small weight, good weighted speed, and a great 3-cone. Also when you look at his tape he excels lined up as an interior pass rusher. If he is going to boot inside 33%+ of the time you're going to get pro-bowl caliber play.

We knew he was going to test average. He uses his length, power, and good burst to soften the edge. His hand technique is also exceptional. He solves his problems differently than most edges. He is someone you can use in the stunt game too.

It's eerie how similar some of AJ's numbers are compared to Trey Flowers.

28737

They both have long arms, are only 8 pounds apart, have 7.34 3-cones, and almost identical shuttles. Flowers was/is more explosive whereas Epenesa is the stronger of the two. Bench press is going away soon - it is worthless so please ignore that. If you take out bench press their overall athletic scores are even closer.

The Pats were able to get Flowers in the 4th but AJE is either going sometime day 1 or early day 2.

Epenesa has the ceiling of Trey Flowers, maybe more, maybe less. Somewhere around there. So what is that worth? Would you be comfortable gambling a late first or early 2nd? I would. I'm not saying he should be the pick at 23 or if they trade back whenever they pick but I wouldn't be unhappy if that is what materialized. The ideal situation would be trading down from 23 into the 2nd and picking him up there.

Quick edit: he is a monster against the run. He’s going to start right away. And again please watch him playing in the interior. This year go to 9:49 of the YouTube of him vs IIRC Nebraska to see him destroy a guard with a push-pull move.

I look forward to hearing from DJ what the buzz is around him after the combine.

I’ve been thinking about this throughout the weekend. What is his value? What if his upside As a pass rusher is Trey Flowers, 6-8 sacks per year, an appropriate level of pressures and sometimes put in a favorable position on stunts so schemed up? Is that worth a pick in the 23-45 range assuming they either pick or trade back? I’m wrestling with it now. I didn’t post my edge grades here but I think I might move him from an 8.0 to a 7.99.

What do you all think?
 
Last edited:

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
I got through 20 edge guys and I am here to tell you after the top 7 there is a considerable drop-off:

1) Chase Young 8.75
2) YGM (Yetur Gross-Matos) 8.0 Aside from Chaisson he has the highest ceiling in the class and is most ready to start contributing day 1 with his run defense as he learns more about dropping back into coverage occasionally and works on his hand technique and counters. Prototypical size, length, speed, bend, and explosiveness.
3) AJ Epenesa 7.99 Where we ding AJ is his positional value. Would it surprise anyone here if AJE had an AJ Brown like slide to the back of the 2nd round? Not me. There isn't a ton of ceiling here but he will be a v solid player for a long time. He's a 5 tech.
4) Zach Baun 7.99 - Think Kyle Van Noy 2.0 and some of the best hands in the class. I wrote about him ere before so no need to repeat myself.
5) Chaisson 7.75 I've wrestled with where to put him for a while now. Here's his deal. He is an athletic freak and is surprisingly developed for someone who hasn't played that many snaps. He's someone who I don't have an issue with taking very early. But he needs even more time in the development machine than YGM so I put him here. He will excel vs the run so you could argue he belongs at 8.25 where I originally had him because he will start from day 1. I just worry that he won't start year 1 so that drops his grade a bit.
6) Okwara 7.75 Another high ceiling athletic OLB who is a prototypical size, length, build, speed, burst, bend, rusher. He is good in coverage. He has some technical issues and functional strength issues with tackling. You can see that lack of strength show up as he struggles to set an edge as well as hold the POA. Another guy who needs to develop his hands and counters.
7) Uche 7.5 A lot of the same positives and negatives as Okwara however he is not as long. Uche needs to stop exposing his chest to OTs because once they get a hold of him he is sunk. He also showed some natural fluidity in coverage as well. Same issues vs the run and needing to keep improving his hands and counters.
8.) Greenard 7.25 Long armed and powerful with good but still developing hands and counters. He can start right away. He can hold the POA against the run, set an edge, and as a pass rusher with his hand in the dirt has some juice to him. I like his floor but playing edge it's hard to have a high ceiling if you don't have the athleticism and bend to consistently win that way. Think a lighter version of AJ Epenesa who is not as polished. Fantastic tackler. He gets a hold of any body part and you are going down.
9) Anae 7.25 He's a lot like Baun but unfortunately is just not nearly as good of an athlete. He's a solid low tier starter. He is going to have to give up playing much in coverage due to his lack of athleticism. He such an impressive set of hand moves and counters. He "plays the game the right way" he just has mediocre length and a mediocre athletic profile.
10) Lewis 7.25 Injury concerns have stunted his development. He's raw but improved a lot over the course of 2019. Another guy whose calling card is strength. Has a medium ceiling. He has good burst. He has set a perfect edge and also got his clock cleaned by Thad Moss. Inconsistent. I am a big hands and counters guy and while you can watch that part of his game improve he has a v long way to go.
11) Coe 6.99 5-tech, big guy, wins with power and is great two-gapping against the run. Needs work in the pass rush game.
12) Jennings 6.99 - not a great scheme fit and has a low ceiling but is super polished and does everything right. I might be too low on him. Highly developed hands and counters.
13) Kareem 6.75 Long and can two-gap but not overly athletic and has a long way to go as a pass rusher.
14) Willekes 6.75 Not a good scheme fit, is more of a one gap penetrator. T-Rex arms.
15) Zuniga 6.75 Not a great scheme fit, T-Rex arms, wins with power and burst.
16) Weaver 6.49 I just don't get this guy. He tested ok but he looks lethargic on tape. Tons of missed tackles on tape. Great hands and counters though. You'd think I'd like him more.
17) Robinson 6.49 He's raw, athletic, needs to work on hands/counters and profiles as a rotational pass rusher. Burst and bend are v good. Can't hold up at the point of attack and poor tackler and tackling radius. Has processing issues.
18) Highsmith 6.49 He's a rotational pass rusher who actually has a high ceiling because he has a prototypical body and length as well as athletic traits of an edge/LB. He is a scheme fit for the Pats. Good processor and read-react is there. Super hot motor. He needs to learn how to drop into coverage. He is a team leader. Of the guys I have on day 3 Highsmith is probably my favorite. He's also a good tackler. His issue is functional strength and specifically the lack of it as well as needing development all over his game. I think Bill will like his character. He's my day 3 edge binkie.
19) Wonnum 5.49 Processing issues, poor angles, no functional strength, his pass rush plan is flawed. I don't have a lot of positive things to say minus he has good burst and speed but average bend. He's a guy you'd develop based on his size, build, and athletic profile but not my cup of tea.
20) (Darrell Taylor DISQ but would have been a 6.49) He has had on and off-field issues.

Bottom line? This edge class is... pretty uninspiring. Like the TE's lots of low ceiling guys or guys who might have a high ceiling but need a lot of development. To me this class starts to drop off significantly after Uche at least in terms of ceiling.
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
This is a great list, SMU. Excellent work, as always. The only places I see things a little differently from you:

Chaisson is my #2 edge player. Fully agree that he's raw and a project, but the ceiling is too high for me to put him behind the others. He has a special get-off, and he just moves differently than the other guys. He doesn't strike me at all as a typical NE 1st. round pick, so I'm not getting my hopes up. But man, he could be special.

I like Kareem a bit more than you do. He's tough and physical, and does strike me as a NE pick. I remember hearing him being described as the quintessential Baltimore pick, one of those PITA DL they always seem to get their hands on. That's him to me. Physical, long, will probably be a better rusher than what he's shown so far. He's at least a rotational player from the start. Clean selection.

Wonnum is a guy I'm on an island with. I see the frame and physical skills and think about what he could be vs. what he is. Then again, he reminds me a lot of Pierre Woods, so that's telling (I always thought Woods would turn into something, too.)
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
This is a great list, SMU. Excellent work, as always. The only places I see things a little differently from you:

Chaisson is my #2 edge player. Fully agree that he's raw and a project, but the ceiling is too high for me to put him behind the others. He has a special get-off, and he just moves differently than the other guys. He doesn't strike me at all as a typical NE 1st. round pick, so I'm not getting my hopes up. But man, he could be special.
Man he's a tough one because he clearly improved and had more responsibilities that he did well at as the season wore on. He is excellent against the run and setting an edge playing at 235 pounds. I want to put my thumb on the grading scale for him because I believe in Chaisson and his sky high ceiling. I will tinker with the rankings before the draft most likely and the first 5 guys are in a fluid situation minus Chase Young on top.

I want to listen to the John Ownings of the world and hear others opinions. He's going to be posting something today on Edges.

If I had to rank them for their ceilings: only 4 guys have that elite potential

1) Chaisson
2) Yetur Gross-Matos
3) Okwara
4) Baun

At the same time I think Baun has a higher floor than any of the guys above him. Floors:

1) Baun
2) Yetur Gross-Matos
3) Chaisson
4) Okwara

Not including AJ Epenesa because unlike the guys above him AJ won't be dropping into coverage. Also, I might need to drop Anae giving his testing was as mediocre as we thought it would be. Sad because Anae has such good instincts and hand technique. First round intangibles, hah.

The more I think about Highsmith the more I think the Pats are going to take him. 3 year captain, leader, motor as hot as anyone's in this entire years class regardless of position, etc. Hello day 3 lottery ticket.

Kareem is a good scheme fit - I like his power. My question is will he ever be more than a 4-6 sack guy with corresponding pressures or do you think he has some untapped ceiling?
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I don't think Kareem is going to be a big sack guy, but he can play in a base D and handle run responsibilities. Length and power is generally a pretty good combo, and I think there's enough athletic ability to say there's some untapped upside in his rush. 4-6 sacks as a rotational end isn't a bad thing. I think he's a good third round pick; not sure if you had him in that range or not. I like him better than Jennings, Coe and Anae.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
The more I think about this draft I think they are going to go defense heavy early on.

A few things for that: 1) The way the top tight end talent isn't there and the ones who are the guys at the top need a ton of development. Kmet and Trautman don't have the floors as some of the defensive players. You can get TE2 depth on day 3. 2) WR is super deep. Can wait for day 3. 3) Corner and safety also are deep and have depth into day 3. They have Froholdt and Cajuste and need to see what they can do along with vet help they hopefully bring in (at least some camp bodies).

Front 7 talent on D is very top heavy this year in the 2020 draft. I think with Hightower aging and with an expensive contract they are going to take a hard look at replacing him down the road with Malik Harrison. KVN Can go and be replaced by Zach Baun or Julian Okwara. I could see them trading back for Zach Baun, trading up for Malik Harrison and then getting Davon Hamilton in the third.

I think they need veteran guys on the offense to help Brady if he comes back so to make up for that they will invest draft capital on more immediate impact and highly polished and ready to go defenders.
 
Last edited:

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
Evan Weaver is someone I think they can grab most likely day 3 or end of day 2. Guy has incredible processing. I think he is going to be a high floor MIKE or WILL in the 3-4 scheme. He is so dominant against the run. Such a smart processor. Huge tackle radius and the guy is surprisingly agile around the LOS. I think his lateral mobility is under appreciated and he is not as horrific dropping back into coverage. NFL will undervalue him. Pats will probably overvalue him a bit - would be an immediate role player. Again really like his floor and think he could be a good old-school LB. His long speed will be an issue so having him paired up to slots or faster TEs or RBs could be a problem.
 

Mugsy's Jock

Eli apologist
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 28, 2000
15,069
UWS, NYC
Looking forward to the OL assessments. As I start playing around with Fanspeak, I have a hard time letting one of the top OL (Wills, Wirfs, Benton, Thomas, maybe Jackson) go by if I’m picking at 23, and one of them always seems to get there. Very concerned about OL which was just okay last year and now stands to lose Thuney and Karras, with Andrews no sure thing. Meantime, it seems like there’s ample WR depth to wait and no TE justifies a first or second round pick.

Of course please bear in mind a.) my lack of expertise leaves me way out of my league in this exceptionally informative thread, and b.) I’d be fairly shocked if the Pats pick at #23 and then not again until #87. I‘m hoping they turn their first rounder and some Day 3 capital into a 2nd and a top 10 3rd. (Thanks, Mohammed!)
 
Last edited:

Super Nomario

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 5, 2000
14,012
Mansfield MA
Looking forward to the OL assessments. As I start playing around with Fanspeak, I have a hard time letting one of the top OL (Wills, Wirfs, Benton, Thomas, maybe Jackson) go by if I’m picking at 23, and one of them always seems to get there. Very concerned about OL which was just okay last year and now stands to lose Thuney and Karras, with Andrews no sure thing. Meantime, it seems like there’s ample WR depth to wait and no TE justifies a first or second round pick.
With respect to OL, in addition to Andrews' return (and presumably a full season from Wynn), we also have to consider that they used two mid-round picks last year on Cajuste and Froholdt. There's at least the potential for them to compete for the LG or a top backup spot. They definitely need a backup G / C, but I don't view it as a top need.
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to see them go OL in the first round, to be honest. They tend to like clean, high floor players in the 1st, and there could be good value there:

Becton
Jackson
Jones
Thomas
Wills
Wirfs

All six of those OTs look like 1st rounders. Jackson looks like more of a LT-only type, and might have a lower floor than what they'd normally like. The other five would probably all be in play at #23, if they were around. Jones and Jackson probably have the best chance (I prefer Jones) of making it to #23. I could certainly see them taking a 1st round OT as a day one RT starter and moving on from Cannon (and letting Cajuste and a Newhouse type battle it out for swing OT).

For interior OL, they do have Froholdt and Eluemunor coming back (with the later being an RFA, I believe). Eluemunor was disappointing, but he does have talent. If Karras and Thuney both leave, I imagine they're looking at a high floor Day 2 pick, a trade, or an undervalued FA option. None the IOL in this draft class look like a good value for #23. But there are definitely some solid Day 2 guys.
 

Super Nomario

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 5, 2000
14,012
Mansfield MA
I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to see them go OL in the first round, to be honest. They tend to like clean, high floor players in the 1st, and there could be good value there:

Becton
Jackson
Jones
Thomas
Wills
Wirfs

All six of those OTs look like 1st rounders. Jackson looks like more of a LT-only type, and might have a lower floor than what they'd normally like. The other five would probably all be in play at #23, if they were around. Jones and Jackson probably have the best chance (I prefer Jones) of making it to #23. I could certainly see them taking a 1st round OT as a day one RT starter and moving on from Cannon (and letting Cajuste and a Newhouse type battle it out for swing OT).

For interior OL, they do have Froholdt and Eluemunor coming back (with the later being an RFA, I believe). Eluemunor was disappointing, but he does have talent. If Karras and Thuney both leave, I imagine they're looking at a high floor Day 2 pick, a trade, or an undervalued FA option. None the IOL in this draft class look like a good value for #23. But there are definitely some solid Day 2 guys.
Cajuste might be a LG option, too. His height / length is a little below average for OT and some of the scouting reports had him there.

I'm not wild about letting Cannon go - he's still got more than $5 MM in bonus money that would hit the cap as dead money, he's still pretty good when he's healthy, and they're going to have enough OL turmoil with Thuney (presumably) gone and questions about Andrews' health. If they take a OT at 23, they could use him as a swing tackle as a rookie; that's what they did with Vollmer and Solder, though both wound up playing some with injuries.
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I don't know that Cajuste is below average in height and length. 6'4 7/8", 34" arms, 82 1/4" wingspan. I think those are all about what you'd expect from an NFL OT.

That said, I don't love the idea of moving on from Cannon either. $5m in dead money is a lot to eat, and when healthy, he's still a winning starting OT in this league. Devil's advocate, he hasn't been particularly durable (though credit to his toughness, he's played through a lot of bumps and bruises the past 2 years), he's getting up in years, he just switched agents, and beyond the dead money, they save about $4.5m moving on from him. So if there is an OT on the board at #23 that they really like, I could certainly see that scenario playing out. Not my first choice, but plausible.
 

Super Nomario

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 5, 2000
14,012
Mansfield MA
I don't know that Cajuste is below average in height and length. 6'4 7/8", 34" arms, 82 1/4" wingspan. I think those are all about what you'd expect from an NFL OT.
I think his build works either way. Per mockdraftable, he's only 16th percentile for height but he's 42nd percentile for arm length and 45th for weight, so he's in shouting distance of average. But that build also works at G - he's 62nd for height, 47th for weight, 76th for arm length. I would not rule him out at either position. I'm just pointing out that he could be in the mix at LG given that there's no obvious starter there.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
I am only 3 IDL's in (Derrick Brown, Neville Gallimore, and Javon Kinlaw) but I have a hot take that I wanted to share with you all.

Javon Kinlaw is a better prospect for the Patriots than Derrick Brown. Here's why: Kinlaw is a better scheme fit. Kinlaw can 2-gap and anchor better than Brown. Brown is on the ground a lot. Also Brown gets uprooted vs double teams much more than Kinlaw. Brown gets overextended too often. Side note: I don't care about Brown's agility drills at the combine. On tape he is nimble and can get around tight corners quickly. I think he just didn't have good drills that day. He is a good to great athlete for his size. End of side note. Kinlaw has all the traits the Patriots like in a 3-4 DE. His power is elite too. He's another guy if we got at 23 and didn't trade back I would be over-the-moon.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
Just for shits and giggles this is my board so far for those following along:


Name Position Grade Position Rank Overall Rank
Chase Young Edge
8.75​
1​
1​
Isaiah Simmons Off-Ball LB
8.75​
1​
2​
Ceedee Lamb WR
8.5​
1​
3​
Henry Ruggs III WR
8.5​
2​
4​
Javon Kinlaw IDL
8.5​
1​
5​
Derrick Brown IDL
8.5​
2​
6​
Jerry Jeudy WR
8.49​
3​
7​
Justin Jefferson WR
8.25​
4​
8​
Denzel Mims WR
8.25​
5​
9​
Zach Baun Edge
8​
2​
10​
Malik Harrison Off-Ball LB
8​
2​
11​
Kenneth Murray Off-Ball LB could do some edge
8​
3​
12​
Michael Pittman WR
7.99​
6​
13​
Quintez Cephus WR
7.99​
7​
14​
KJ Hamler WR
7.99​
8​
15​
Tyler Johnson WR
7.99​
9​
16​
AJ Epenesa Edge/IDL
7.99​
3​
17​
Justin Madubuike IDL
7.99​
3​
18​
Marlon Davidson IDL
7.99​
4​
19​
Patrick Queen Off-Ball LB
7.99​
4​
20​
Devin Duvernay WR
7.75​
10​
21​
Jalen Reagor WR
7.75​
11​
22​
Brandon Aiyuk WR
7.75​
12​
23​
Cole Kmet TE
7.75​
1​
24​
Chaisson Edge
7.75​
4​
25​
Yetur Gross-Matos Edge
7.75​
5​
26​
Julian Okwara Edge
7.75​
6​
27​
Ross Blacklock IDL
7.75​
5​
28​
Laviska Shenault WR
7.5​
13​
29​
Bryan Edwards WR
7.5​
14​
30​
Jauan Jennings WR
7.5​
15​
31​
Tee Higgins WR
7.5​
16​
32​
Uche Edge
7.5​
7​
33​
K.J. Hill WR
7.25​
17​
34​
Greenard Edge
7.25​
8​
35​
Anae Edge
7.25​
9​
36​
Lewis Edge
7.25​
10​
37​
Donovan Peoples-Jones WR
7​
18​
38​
Chase Claypool WR/TE
7​
19​
39​
Evan Weaver Off-Ball LB
7​
5​
40​
Antonio Gibson WR/RB
6.99​
20​
41​
Isaiah Hodgins WR
6.99​
21​
42​
Adam Trautman TE
6.99​
2​
43​
Kareem Edge
6.99​
11​
44​
Neville Gallimore IDL
6.99​
6​
45​
Raekwon Davis IDL
6.99​
7​
46​
Leki Fotu IDL
6.99​
8​
47​
James Lynch IDL
6.99​
9​
48​
McTelvin Agim IDL
6.99​
10​
49​
Jordyn Brooks Off-Ball LB
6.99​
6​
50​
Logan Wilson Off-Ball LB
6.99​
7​
51​
Devin Asiasi TE
6.75​
3​
52​
Coe Edge
6.75​
12​
53​
Willekes Edge
6.75​
13​
54​
Zuniga Edge
6.75​
14​
55​
Davon Hamilton IDL
6.75​
11​
56​
Antonio Gandy-Golden WR
6.5​
22​
57​
Rashard Lawrence IDL
6.5​
12​
58​
James Proche WR
6.49​
23​
59​
Van Jefferson WR
6.49​
24​
60​
John Hightower WR
6.49​
25​
61​
Lynn Bowden WR
6.49​
26​
62​
Josiah Deguara TE
6.49​
4​
63​
Harrison Bryant TE
6.49​
5​
64​
Brycen Hopkins TE
6.49​
6​
65​
Hunter Bryant TE
6.49​
7​
66​
Alex Highsmith Edge
6.49​
15​
67​
Anfernee Jennings Edge
6.49​
16​
68​
Curtis Weaver Edge
6.49​
17​
69​
Robinson Edge
6.49​
18​
70​
Larrell Murchison IDL
6.49​
13​
71​
Jordan Elliot IDL
6.49​
14​
72​
Strnad Off-Ball LB
6.49​
8​
73​
Willie Gay Off-Ball LB
6.49​
9​
74​
Collin Johnson WR
6.25​
27​
75​
CJ O'Grady TE
6.25​
8​
76​
Albert O TE
6.25​
9​
77​
Colby Parkinson TE
6.25​
10​
78​
Cameron Brown Off-Ball LB
6.25​
10​
79​
Lawrence Cager WR
6​
28​
80​
Jason Strowbridge IDL
6​
15​
81​
Gabriel Davis WR
5.99​
29​
82​
Raequan Williams IDL
5.99​
16​
83​
Markus Bailey Off-Ball LB
5.99​
11​
84​
Carter Coughlin Off-Ball LB
5.99​
12​
85​
Joe Reed WR
5.49​
30​
86​
Jeff Thomas WR
5.49​
31​
87​
Wonnum Edge
5.49​
19​
88​
Thad Moss TE
5​
11​
89​
Jacob Breeland TE
5​
12​
90​
Quartney Davis WR
4.99​
32​
91​
Jarred Pinkney TE
4.99​
13​
92​
Mitchell Wilcox TE
4.99​
14​
93​
Isaiah Coulter WR
4.5​
33​
94​
Sean McKeon TE
4.5​
15​
95​
Tyrie Cleveland WR
4.49​
34​
96​
Kalija Lipscomb WR
4.49​
35​
97​
K.J. Osborn WR
4.49​
36​
98​
Austin Mack WR
4.25​
37​
99​
Aaron Parker WR
4​
38​
100​
Marquez Callaway WR
3.99​
39​
101​
Binjiman Victor WR
3.99​
40​
102​
Aaron Fuller WR
3.99​
41​
103​
Juwan Johnson WR
3.5​
42​
104​
Kendrick Rogers WR
3.5​
43​
105​
Nick Westbrook WR
3.25​
44​
106​
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
So WRs are pretty good huh
Depth, breadth, and all kinds of flavor variety.

I have 3 solid blue chip kind of grades, 2 borderline 1st/high 2nd for 5 total. I then have 16 guys who I would define as day 2. So 21 WRs who are day 1 or 2. It's ri-fucking-diculous out there.
 

tmracht

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 19, 2009
3,070
Depth, breadth, and all kinds of flavor variety.

I have 3 solid blue chip kind of grades, 2 borderline 1st/high 2nd for 5 total. I then have 16 guys who I would define as day 2. So 21 WRs who are day 1 or 2. It's ri-fucking-diculous out there.
I
I would guess you'll have a few slip these to day 3 or should expect all 21 gone by day 2?
 

Average Game James

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 28, 2016
4,346
SMU - away from the top 4, your WR start to deviate quite a bit from a lot of the pundit rankings out there that I’ve seen. Curious if you think that’s because you’re actually a bit out of consensus (and implicitly there could be some really 3rd round steals at the position) or if the gap between the guys in the next tier is just really narrow to the point that the 8th, 9th, and 10th WRs off the board are basically just as good at 5-6-7...
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I finally got around to Tee Higgins. He might be the captain of my Why are We Overthinking This team. Honestly, he was so impressive. I watched A&M, South Carolina and Virginia and all I saw was a #1 WR. Long, crazy catch radius, great body control. He separated against press and zone, intermediate and deep. Really good stop and start, and smooth in his transitions. I guess the knock is speed and separation but I saw no issues in the three games. Not doing the combine is a red flag, but the tape is what it is. 6'4, 215#, productive from an elite program. I still like Juedy better, but Higgins was very impressive.
Man, Tee Higgins had a BAD pro day workout. To the point where I don't think he goes in the 1st round any more. It's weird because on tape, you wouldn't project him as a subpar athlete. But I think we're at the point where we have enough data on athletic testing to say this is a big red flag. I still really like Higgins, but not at #23. If he's around in the 3rd, I absolutely take him based on tape, production and pedigree. But woof. That was a bad workout.
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I'll also say that McKinney was generally the player I zeroed in on for #23 when I did mock drafts. With McCourty and Chung both signed through this season and next, I doubt they go safety in the 1st round now. I'm starting to gravitate towards Murray or Queen, 3-down, off-the-ball LBs since I'm expecting KVN, Collins and Roberts to all depart. That leaves DHT and Bentley. I like Terez Hall (practice squad, UDFA) but he obviously can't be counted on. I'm sure they'll bring in some reinforcements, but I expect either Queen or Murray to be there. Queen was more instinctive and better in coverage, Murray was the more explosive striker and closer to NE's physical prototype.
 

Jed Zeppelin

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 23, 2008
51,333
So do folks think the Brady news affects how they approach the draft? My gut reaction as an armchair GM was to say they should double up on this historic WR class now that they don't need to make sure Brady has guys he can trust right away, but I'm sure it will be business as usual.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
WR is a position that has a steeper learning curve than average translating into the NFL. I try to have a Patriots lens on these guys (as in who I think would do well with them vs their typical prototypes). The pundits really like Laviska Shenault, Jalen Reagor, and Brandon Aiyuk. I can see the allure with Aiyuk - guy has the tools to beat press, he is an excellent returner and he has a huge catch radius. Decent route runner too. I have a round 2 grade on him. I see Mims and Aiyuk as the best pure X receivers after Ceedee and Ruggs (if you play Ruggs as an X). Laviska is special after the catch - same with Reagor. The issues I have with him and Reagor are all before the catch. Laviska is a schemed touch guy right now. I see him as CP84 but without the high end speed. He's not a natural route runner. He also has a ton of overlap with Harry. He needs to learn to beat press too. I think Laviska is one of the more overrated prospects this year. Reagor I need to get back to and see more 2018 film but he's a Z. He had poor QB play this year. He's not a physical receiver but he is a YAC monster. He can't make contested catches. He has a problem with drops and hand technique catching the ball. He runs a very limited route tree. He isn't the kind of guy you attack the middle of the field with and if he anticipates contact his hands get even sloppier. He's a finese player. So for what the Patriots want their receivers to be able to do I do not think he is a good fit for them. I also think there is more risk with Reagor than is being acknowledged. I don't think Devin Duvernay is that far behind Reagor and you could probably get Duvernay in rounds 3+ whereas Reagor will be gone most likely in the top 50 picks.

I don't usually knock guys a ton for their testing but Tee Higgins is an X with 4.59 speed (4.54 prod day +0.05 for adjustment), only a 31 inch vertical jump, an even worse 1.66 10 yard split, and a 4.53 short shuttle. On film he makes a lot of contested catches using his tremendous wingspan. I like his tape - I think he is going to be a solid if not spectacular X.

Part of what I wanted to do this year was strike out or hit home-runs on my own. I know I am higher on Jauan Jennings, Devin Duvernay, Tyler Johnson, Quintez Cephus, and Michael Pittman than the pundits. Duvernay is a Z, Cephus is an X, Crabtree is an X/Slot, and Jennings and Johnson are big slots.

Let me talk about Cephus for a second. When you watch him on tape he looks fast. His form for the 40 was awful. When he retested at his pro-day he was a 4.56 which makes a lot more sense. Excellent hands, good routes, tremendous explosion, he beats press. He is a surprisingly advanced receiver. He also has the potential to be a fantastic blocker - his flaws are just technical right now and he has tremendous strength. He has had an off-field issue dismissed against him but he did miss 2018 because of it.

Jennings and Johnson are getting dinged because they are big slots with questions about their athleticism translating to the next level. Johnson didn't test and Jennings tested but poorly. Jennings was one of the best blocking receivers in the class. The guy can seal off LBs. Jennings is only 215 pounds but plays like a 230+ guy. His breaks are not crisp because his CoD isn't great but he works back to the QB and consistently manipulates DBs and/or boxes them out so that he has enough separation to make a catch. Will that translate to the NFL? I don't know. I know that he is always a YAC threat because he can break multiple tackles. He's fearless across the middle. Guy will take huge hits and hang onto the ball. You can probably get Jennings on day 3. You can also get Johnson day 3 too. Johnson has some character issues apparently although no one says what they are. Tyler Johnson has sick tape. His break-out age and dominator rating are in the top percentiles.

quick edit: sorry for the delayed reply @Average Game James dealing with a nasty stomach bug over here.
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I haven't done a deep dive on the QBs this year. My man crush on Stidham is known, and I think the team likes Kessler as a backup more than the fans do. There's a lot of Brian Hoyer to Kessler, and that's not bad. That being said, my short thoughts on QB's I like:

1st: Herbert. Burrow is going #1 and Tua will be long gone. But if Herbert is there at 23, or slides to the point where trading isn't prohibitive, I go for it. His physical skills are special. I compared him to Josh Allen a few years back, and that holds. He needs to make faster decisions and progressions, but he's got some franchise QB skills.

3rd: Hurts. I've gone back and forth on him, but I can't deny the It Factor. The guys just wins. Had a really good combine, very athletic, and his coaches and teammates universally love him.

Day 3: Nate Stanley. Reminds me of Bortles, which sure, laugh at. But the tools are there if the other stuff gets sorted out. 6'4, 240# with 4.81 40 speed is nice combo. I watched him live against Michigan, and he looked worse than a camp body. Watched him live against USC in his bowl game, and he looked like the real deal. He had flotsam at the skill positions this year, and I think there's upside.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
Tight end is probably the worst position group in the draft class. Now in all fairness I haven't gotten to QB, OT, IOL, and CB yet but easily the next thinnest group and especially at the top of the class is safety. I will post an update top 165-170 sometime tomorrow with a handful more Edge, IDLs, and LBs as well as 24 RBs and safeties :). I'd be more active talking about guys and fits here but I just want to make all of my reports (which I do plan on publishing somewhere and linking here) first and I still have 100 or so to go.

You're looking at 4-5 starting caliber prospects at single high FS depending on how you feel about Grant Delpit: Antoine Winfield Jr (he is a prototypical Patriot) and Ashtyn Davis (another guy who Bill would love) lead the pack. Terrell Burgess can do all the safety roles including play single high well - and he is also good in the slot. He might be a swiss army knife safety and a safety 3 which is basically a starting role here BUT he might also be an above average but not a great starter at FS. Lastly Justin Blackmon after a medical and acclimation adjustment year 1 can possibly take over but he is relatively new as a CB convert in 2019. There are some split deep guys or people who could play a rotational role like Harmon or backup Chung/nickel or dime safety types but no true FS single high potential starters but those 4-5. Grant Delpit - I am out on him due to his injury history and issues with tackling.

Strong safety: The best prospect here is Xavier McKinney who does not have top end athleticism (a prototypical Patriot). The more I look at McKinney the more I think he is going to slide into mid day 2. He's undersized for a SS and doesn't have elite long speed (his speed in general is lagging but he makes up for it with his elite processor). After McKinney it's to Burgess (I think he is a better fit as a FS not a SS but he can do SS at a starting caliber too) and then a huge drop to Dugger and Chinn who are far away from contributing in coverage. The only other guy in consideration is Brandon Jones who is also undersized and not a great athlete for the position. You have some quality role players like Antoine Brooks Jr. who is like a freight-train coming downhill against the run but that's about it. I think the Pats would like love Brooks Jr. on special teams and against the run but would worry about his zone or him in man getting exploited in coverage. I still have 9 safeties to go but none of the rest of the guys I am looking at are ranked higher than like 180th or so of the 5 boards I pulled together to average. Average boards to figure out which prospects to watch is a good strategy but that's a side topic for a different day.

The only good news is that unlike tight ends a bunch of these safeties are proto-typical Patriots and great fits here as starters or role-players as pointed out above.

Edit: of course the next guy I watch is Daniel Thomas who has himself a nice ceiling as a nickel-back or SS, a floor as a core-4 STer, but he needs help with his processing, getting around traffic in the box, vision, run fills, etc.


Paging @EL Jeffe - Daniel Thomas, what's your take?
 
Last edited:

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
Finished RBs and Safeties - I am not sorting for rank among the tied clusters. I will do that at the end when I am done the rest of the positions.

Name Position Grade Position Rank Overall Rank Cluster or Highest tie
Chase Young Edge
8.75​
1​
1​
1​
Isaiah Simmons Off-Ball LB
8.75​
1​
2​
1​
Ceedee Lamb WR
8.5​
1​
3​
3​
Henry Ruggs III WR
8.5​
2​
4​
3​
Javon Kinlaw IDL
8.5​
1​
5​
3​
Derrick Brown IDL
8.5​
2​
6​
3​
Jerry Jeudy WR
8.49​
3​
7​
7​
Justin Jefferson WR
8.25​
4​
8​
8​
Denzel Mims WR
8.25​
5​
9​
8​
J.K. Dobbins RB
8​
1​
10​
10​
Zach Baun Edge
8​
2​
11​
10​
Malik Harrison Off-Ball LB
8​
2​
12​
10​
Kenneth Murray Off-Ball LB
8​
3​
13​
10​
Michael Pittman WR
7.99​
6​
14​
14​
Quintez Cephus WR
7.99​
7​
15​
14​
KJ Hamler WR
7.99​
8​
16​
14​
Tyler Johnson WR
7.99​
9​
17​
14​
Zach Moss RB
7.99​
2​
18​
14​
Clyde Edwards-Helaire RB
7.99​
3​
19​
14​
Justin Madubuike IDL
7.99​
3​
20​
14​
Marlon Davidson IDL
7.99​
4​
21​
14​
AJ Epenesa Edge/IDL
7.99​
3​
22​
14​
Patrick Queen Off-Ball LB
7.99​
4​
23​
14​
Antoine Winfield Jr. S
7.99​
1​
24​
14​
Xavier McKinney S
7.99​
2​
25​
14​
Devin Duvernay WR
7.75​
10​
26​
26​
Jalen Reagor WR
7.75​
11​
27​
26​
Brandon Aiyuk WR
7.75​
12​
28​
26​
Cole Kmet TE
7.75​
1​
29​
26​
D'Andre Swift RB
7.75​
4​
30​
26​
Ross Blacklock IDL
7.75​
5​
31​
26​
Chaisson Edge
7.75​
4​
32​
26​
Yetur Gross-Matos Edge
7.75​
5​
33​
26​
Julian Okwara Edge
7.75​
6​
34​
26​
Ashtyn Davis S
7.75​
3​
35​
26​
Laviska Shenault WR
7.5​
13​
36​
36​
Bryan Edwards WR
7.5​
14​
37​
36​
Jauan Jennings WR
7.5​
15​
38​
36​
Tee Higgins WR
7.5​
16​
39​
36​
Jonathan Taylor RB
7.5​
5​
40​
36​
A.J. Dillon RB
7.5​
6​
41​
36​
Uche Edge
7.5​
7​
42​
36​
Terrell Burgess S
7.5​
4​
43​
36​
K.J. Hill WR
7.25​
17​
44​
44​
Greenard Edge
7.25​
8​
45​
44​
Anae Edge
7.25​
9​
46​
44​
Lewis Edge
7.25​
10​
47​
44​
Donovan Peoples-Jones WR
7​
18​
48​
48​
Chase Claypool WR/TE
7​
19​
49​
48​
Cam Akers RB
7​
7​
50​
48​
Evan Weaver Off-Ball LB
7​
5​
51​
48​
Antonio Gibson WR/RB
6.99​
20​
52​
52​
Isaiah Hodgins WR
6.99​
21​
53​
52​
Adam Trautman TE
6.99​
2​
54​
52​
Devin Asiasi TE
6.99​
3​
55​
52​
Rico Dowdle RB
6.99​
8​
56​
52​
Neville Gallimore IDL
6.99​
6​
57​
52​
Raekwon Davis IDL
6.99​
7​
58​
52​
Leki Fotu IDL
6.99​
8​
59​
52​
James Lynch IDL
6.99​
9​
60​
52​
McTelvin Agim IDL
6.99​
10​
61​
52​
Kareem Edge
6.99​
11​
62​
52​
Jordyn Brooks Off-Ball LB
6.99​
6​
63​
52​
Logan Wilson Off-Ball LB
6.99​
7​
64​
52​
Michael Warren II RB
6.75​
9​
65​
65​
Davon Hamilton IDL
6.75​
11​
66​
65​
Coe Edge
6.75​
12​
67​
65​
Willekes Edge
6.75​
13​
68​
65​
Zuniga Edge
6.75​
14​
69​
65​
Brandon Jones S
6.75​
5​
70​
65​
Antonio Gandy-Golden WR
6.5​
22​
71​
71​
Ke'Shawn Vaughn RB
6.5​
10​
72​
71​
Rashard Lawrence IDL
6.5​
12​
73​
71​
John Hightower WR
6.49​
23​
74​
74​
Lynn Bowden WR
6.49​
24​
75​
74​
Harrison Bryant TE
6.49​
4​
76​
74​
Josiah Deguara TE
6.49​
5​
77​
74​
Brycen Hopkins TE
6.49​
6​
78​
74​
Hunter Bryant TE
6.49​
7​
79​
74​
Darrynton Evans RB
6.49​
11​
80​
74​
Darius Anderson RB
6.49​
12​
81​
74​
Eno Benjamin RB
6.49​
13​
82​
74​
Larrell Murchison IDL
6.49​
13​
83​
74​
Jordan Elliot IDL
6.49​
14​
84​
74​
Alex Highsmith Edge
6.49​
15​
85​
74​
Anfernee Jennings Edge
6.49​
16​
86​
74​
Curtis Weaver Edge
6.49​
17​
87​
74​
Robinson Edge
6.49​
18​
88​
74​
Strnad Off-Ball LB
6.49​
8​
89​
74​
Shaquille Quarterman Off-Ball LB
6.49​
9​
90​
74​
Willie Gay Off-Ball LB
6.49​
10​
91​
74​
Grant Delpit S
6.49​
6​
92​
74​
Kyle Dugger S
6.49​
7​
93​
74​
Justin Blackmon S
6.49​
8​
94​
74​
Daniel Thomas S
6.49​
9​
95​
74​
Antoine Brooks Jr. S
6.49​
10​
96​
74​
Collin Johnson WR
6.25​
25​
97​
97​
Van Jefferson WR
6.25​
26​
98​
97​
CJ O'Grady TE
6.25​
8​
99​
97​
Albert O TE
6.25​
9​
100​
97​
Colby Parkinson TE
6.25​
10​
101​
97​
Lamical Perine RB
6.25​
14​
102​
97​
Mykal Walker Off-Ball LB
6.25​
11​
103​
97​
Cameron Brown Off-Ball LB
6.25​
12​
104​
97​
Tanner Muse Off-Ball LB
6.25​
13​
105​
97​
K'Von Wallace S
6.25​
11​
106​
97​
Jeremy Chinn S
6.25​
12​
107​
97​
Lawrence Cager WR
6​
27​
108​
108​
Deejay Dallas RB
6​
15​
109​
108​
Anthony McFarland RB
6​
16​
110​
108​
Jason Strowbridge IDL
6​
15​
111​
108​
Jonathan Garvin Edge
6​
19​
112​
108​
Casey Toohill Edge
6​
20​
113​
108​
J.R. Reed S
6​
13​
114​
108​
Reggie Robinson CB/S
6​
14​
115​
108​
Shyheim Carter S
6​
15​
116​
108​
Jaylinn Hawkins S
6​
16​
117​
108​
Josh Metellus S
6​
17​
118​
108​
James Proche WR
5.99​
28​
119​
119​
Gabriel Davis WR
5.99​
29​
120​
119​
Raequan Williams IDL
5.99​
16​
121​
119​
Trevis Gipson Edge
5.99​
21​
122​
119​
Markus Bailey Off-Ball LB
5.99​
14​
123​
119​
Carter Coughlin Off-Ball LB
5.99​
15​
124​
119​
Brian Cole II S
5.99​
18​
125​
119​
Geno Stone S
5.99​
19​
126​
119​
Patrick Taylor Jr RB
5.75​
17​
127​
127​
Jalen Elliott S
5.75​
20​
128​
127​
Joshua Kelley RB
5.5​
18​
129​
129​
Jordan Fuller S
5.5​
21​
130​
129​
Joe Reed WR
5.49​
30​
131​
131​
Jeff Thomas WR
5.49​
31​
132​
131​
JaMycal Hasty RB
5.49​
19​
133​
131​
Wonnum Edge
5.49​
22​
134​
131​
Thad Moss TE
5​
11​
135​
135​
Jacob Breeland TE
5​
12​
136​
135​
Broderick Washington IDL
5​
17​
137​
135​
Quartney Davis WR
4.99​
32​
138​
138​
Jarred Pinkney TE
4.99​
13​
139​
138​
Mitchell Wilcox TE
4.99​
14​
140​
138​
Javon Leake RB
4.99​
20​
141​
138​
Michael Pinckney Off-Ball LB
4.99​
16​
142​
138​
Jacob Phillips Off-Ball LB
4.99​
17​
143​
138​
Alohi Gilman S
4.99​
22​
144​
138​
Scottie Phillips RB
4.75​
21​
145​
145​
David Woodward Off-Ball LB
4.75​
18​
146​
145​
Isaiah Coulter WR
4.5​
33​
147​
147​
Sean McKeon TE
4.5​
15​
148​
147​
Tyrie Cleveland WR
4.49​
34​
149​
149​
Kalija Lipscomb WR
4.49​
35​
150​
149​
K.J. Osborn WR
4.49​
36​
151​
149​
J.J. Taylor RB
4.49​
22​
152​
149​
Austin Mack WR
4.25​
37​
153​
153​
Raymond Calais RB
4.25​
23​
154​
153​
Lavonte Bellamy RB
4.25​
24​
155​
153​
Aaron Parker WR
4​
38​
156​
156​
Marquez Callaway WR
3.99​
39​
157​
157​
Binjiman Victor WR
3.99​
40​
158​
157​
Aaron Fuller WR
3.99​
41​
159​
157​
James Smith-Williams Edge
3.99​
23​
160​
157​
Derrek Tuszka Edge
3.99​
24​
161​
157​
Juwan Johnson WR
3.5​
42​
162​
162​
Kendrick Rogers WR
3.5​
43​
163​
162​
Nick Westbrook WR
3.25​
44​
164​
164​
 
Last edited:

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
Edit: of course the next guy I watch is Daniel Thomas who has himself a nice ceiling as a nickel-back or SS, a floor as a core-4 STer, but he needs help with his processing, getting around traffic in the box, vision, run fills, etc.


Paging @EL Jeffe - Daniel Thomas, what's your take?
I'll be honest, Daniel Thomas didn't do a lot for me. I saw a lot of the hallmarks of a typical Day 3 safety; a bit tight in the hips, false steps in space. The further he got from the ball, the worse he looked. I think in NE's defense, he'd be playing the Chung role and I don't think he'd be remotely competitive against Chung or Phillips. If he has a future, it'd be as a core-4 STer who maybe develops as something more. I don't think he's nearly ready to cover NFL players and I'm not convinced he gets there.

Looking at your safety rankings, I'm higher on these guys than you are:

Wallace
Reed
Metellus
Stone

Reed is definitely a Day 3 safety I could see the Patriots liking. He has a lot of similarities to Harmon, in terms of physical skills/profile and playing style. I think he has a really good chance to carve out a nice career as a centerfield safety. Good range, good tackler, instinctive--does what you want back there. Athletically he's just okay, but he's got enough to make it.
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
SMU,

I think I see the edge class a bit different than you. This is how I'd stack them:

1st round grades:
Young (yeah right)
Chaisson (I'd run this pick to the podium)
Gross-Matos
Uche (I'm much higher on him than most, although Nagy also loves him)

2nd round grades:
Lewis
Okwara
Baun (think he's a bit overhyped)

3rd round grades:
Taylor
Zuniga (love his explosiveness)
Kareem
Anae
Robinson
Greenard
Jennings
Weaver

In fairness, I haven't looked too closely at Anae, Jennings, or Weaver. I did look at Highsmith, and he was a Day 3 guy for me; thought he was pretty bad against the run, not physical, stuck on blocks, and couldn't set an edge. He was quick off the snap and has some rush upside. Just too much of a Derek Rivers vibe.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
@EL Jeffe love the list. As corny as it sounds that is the great thing about the draft is when you are projecting a guy to the next level two people could look at someone and have different takes.

Look at last year and Paris Campbell. We had people who wanted him as early as maybe late one and people like me who didn’t want him until day 3.

A few things I’d like to clarify. With Chaisson and 7.75s. 7.75s have first round talent, some guys like Chaisson have a lot of it. What holds me back with him is his hand work as a rusher is still developing and his coverage skills are really only in the back 5-7 games for LSU. Do you want to have him responsible for coverage at this point in his career? That makes me nervous. I am dinging him for sample size. His lack of production doesn’t bother me because I look for traits and not production. My 8’s and up I look at as the first round slam dunks. The 7.75s might be the next guys in the list instead of the 7.99s because the 7.75s might have the higher ceilings. I haven’t organized the order of guys at the same rank but I actually like Chaisson a lot and originally had him as an 8.25 (same with Yetur Gross-Matos). I got cold feet. He should be at the top of the 7.75s when I organize it. I may move him up. I have ranges for the prospects that I keep in my notes because I do reserve the right to change my mind. Of the people I interact with on the daily going over guys Chaisson, KJ Hamler, Cole Kmet, Adam Trautman, Antoine Winfield Jr., Neville Gallimore, Yetur Gross-Matos, and Justin Blacklock are the most divisive prospects. Another guy people are all over the place on is Bryan Edwards.

My 6.49 on Daniels reflects him being a core-4 ST with the potential to step into a 3rd safety role or backup SS role by year 2. That is a firm day 3 grade but round 4-5. I’ll be honest judging the day 3 guys is fucking hard. The guys where they are clearly not a starter BUT could they grow into one or be a backup? They take me longer to evaluate than a guy like Xavier McKinney or Chase Young.

I’m not that far behind you on Lewis or Uche. A 7.25 is a 2nd to 3rd round grade. Lewis has some injury history that is concerning and left him underdeveloped especially with his hands. His bend isn’t great for an edge and he’s not someone I would want going back into coverage. He has good power though - I like him more for a 4-3 team honestly but the thing that impressed me about him and Chaisson was how much better they got over the course of the season.

With Uche he exposes too much of his chest to tackles when he rushes. It’s going to limit his effectiveness. He needs to get less exposed and not give the tackle a target. His hands and counters are still a WIP. I would love him in the 2nd. I think he’s athletic AF and a quality Swiss Army knife player who can play all the LB roles.

Gross-Matos I have no qualms with taking in the first. Issues with him are when you look at his rushes his initial hand placement for the combos he tries to work are not ideal. His secondary counters are not as developed as you’d like and he also needs work in coverage. I’ve heard some chatter he is more of a 4-3 edge but I don’t think that is necessarily the case.

A word of caution on Nagy. Nagy is a great resource of information but his job is to hype up senior bowl players. He sometimes imo gets a little too jazzed up.

What makes you think Baun is overhyped? I see Baun as the next Kyle Van Noy and a perfect fit for our guys. Uche and Baun actually - they both could be on the field at the same time. Baun’s hands and counters are impressive. Maybe only Curtis Weaver has better hands of the edges. Curious what your issues are with him. Are they against the run and holding the point of attack?
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
What makes you think Baun is overhyped? I see Baun as the next Kyle Van Noy and a perfect fit for our guys. Uche and Baun actually - they both could be on the field at the same time. Baun’s hands and counters are impressive. Maybe only Curtis Weaver has better hands of the edges. Curious what your issues are with him. Are they against the run and holding the point of attack?
In fairness, I watched two Baun games. I generally only have time to watch 2-3 on a player. That said, I didn't see the suddenness, twitch or explosion that others see. He's an easy mover, drops fluidly, and he's fast in a straight line. That's all good. But I didn't see an explosive get-off, or an explosive close to the ball. His 1.60 10 yard split suggests some explosion, but his mediocre jumps suggest otherwise. That was an odd testing result. I also worry a bit about his size. As a 5th year senior at a good strength training program, he's 238#. How much bigger is he going to get? He looks close to maxed out to me. I see a lot to like with Baun (hence my 2nd round grade), but I don't see a special attribute. I'm not sold he has the length, power, or explosion to play edge consistently.

As for Chaisson, I do see some special attributes. He does have the explosive get-off while being an easy mover. He's two classes younger than Baun, but already ~15# heavier. Do I trust Chaisson to do everything NE asks of their edge players? Nope, not as a rookie. As a rookie, I think he'd essentially have Wino's 2019 role. But I think he'd get there in a year or two, with an absolute elite ceiling. And by elite, I mean All-Pro type ceiling. A guy with his skillset has no business being around at #23, but it's possible that he will. No combine workout, RS sophomore. Some teams will get cold feet.
 

Super Nomario

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 5, 2000
14,012
Mansfield MA
https://www.bostonglobe.com/2020/04/02/sports/it-may-be-time-patriots-make-big-play-tua-tagovailoa-draft/
There's nothing to this, but what would a package look like? Edelman isn't worth a first rounder so he will barely make a dent (and you'd want Tua to have someone to throw to).

2020 1st, 2020 3rd, 2021 1st, JC Jackson, 2021 2nd? More?
I don't see the Pats making a big move up to three, but there are rumors (FWIW, which is not much; it's lying season) that teams are scared off Tua and he might slide a little. If he gets to 10 (where trade-back-happy Cleveland is picking), that might make sense. KC traded 27, 87, and a future 1 for 10 to get Mahomes a few years ago. So maybe 23, a third, 2021 1st, maybe get a day three pick back?
 

jsinger121

@jsinger121
SoSH Member
Jul 25, 2005
17,677
I think Tua is going to be a massive flop. Would never trade up for him. I honestly think with his hip issues he is a massive risk plus I think the talent around him propped him up to be something better than he really is.
 

Mugsy's Jock

Eli apologist
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Dec 28, 2000
15,069
UWS, NYC
Of course the world is filled with disinformation and misinformation, but Lombardi reported that Tua flunked medicals for more than one team -- and it wasn't only his hip, but there were also problems with his ankle and wrist.

View: https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2885764-tua-tagovailoa-rumors-qb-failed-at-least-1-physical-due-to-multiple-injuries


Some mocks have shown Tua available into the late teens, some even further. Of course a.) that's probably bullshit, and b.) if it were likely, the bad medicals would probably be more indicator of fire than smoke... but if 2020 is a lost season anyway, it could be worth rolling the dice.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
I finished up my list. Some OL's are listed twice. One is for their first position the other is for their second. I got around to 254 prospects this year.

This is the scale I use. It doesn't have a round grade:

29947

If I had to come up with a draft grade per the scale I see 8 and above as a first round grade. Then comes the 7.99 or 7.75. 7.75 guys probably have higher upside but are bigger risks - whereas 7.99 guys have a higher floor but might not have as high of a ceiling. I see the 7.99 and 7.75 guys as 2nd rounders. Also, if you went for a 7.75 guy over a safer 7.99 I get that - I think you can go from the 8's right to the 7.75 if you want to roll the dice. The 7-7.5 scores are roughly equivalent to a third round pick. 6.5-6.99 are 4th round, 6-6.49 are 5th rounders, 5-5.99 are 6th/7th rounders and the rest are UDFA's.

Here are the total numbers of players graded as:
1st rounders 8+: 19
2nd rounders 7.99: 15
2nd rounders 7.75: 22
Total 2nd rounders: 37
Total 3rd rounders 7-7.5: 26
Total 4th round picks: 6.5-6.99: 38
Total 5th round picks: 6-6.49: 55
Total 6th/7th round picks: 5-5.9: 42
UDFAs or below: 4.99 or under: 43


Name Position Grade Position Rank Overall Rank Cluster or Highest tie
Joe Burrow QB 8.75 1 1 1
Chase Young Edge 8.75 1 2 1
Isaiah Simmons Off-Ball LB 8.75 1 3 1
Jeffrey Okudah CB 8.5 1 4 3
Javon Kinlaw IDL 8.5 1 5 3
Ceedee Lamb WR 8.5 1 6 3
Derrick Brown IDL 8.5 2 7 3
Henry Ruggs III WR 8.5 2 8 3
Jedrick Wills Jr. OT 8.49 1 9 8
Jerry Jeudy WR 8.49 3 10 8
Tua Tagovailoa QB 8.49 2 11 8
Andrew Thomas OT 8.25 2 12 11
Tristan Wirfs OT 8.25 3 13 11
CJ Henderson CB 8.25 2 14 11
Justin Jefferson WR 8.25 4 15 11
Denzel Mims WR 8.25 5 16 11
J.K. Dobbins RB 8 1 17 16
Malik Harrison Off-Ball LB 8 2 18 16
Zack Baun Edge 8 2 19 16
Patrick Queen Off-Ball LB 7.99 3 20 19
Michael Pittman WR 7.99 6 21 19
Justin Madubuike IDL 7.99 3 22 19
Marlon Davidson IDL 7.99 4 23 19
AJ Epenesa Edge/IDL 7.99 3 24 19
Antoine Winfield Jr. S 7.99 1 25 19
Jeff Gladney CB 7.99 3 26 19
Jaylon Johnson CB 7.99 4 27 19
Xavier McKinney S 7.99 2 28 19
Quintez Cephus WR 7.99 7 29 19
Zach Moss RB 7.99 2 30 19
Clyde Edwards-Helaire RB 7.99 3 31 19
Bryan Edwards WR 7.99 8 32 19
Lloyd Cushenberry OC/OG 7.99 1 33 19
Damien Lewis OG 7.99 2 34 19
Mekhi Becton OT 7.75 4 35 34
K'Lavon Chaisson Edge 7.75 4 36 34
Ashtyn Davis S 7.75 3 37 34
Josh Jones OT 7.75 5 38 34
Robert Hunt OT/OG 7.75 3 39 34
Devin Duvernay WR 7.75 9 40 34
D'Andre Swift RB 7.75 4 41 34
Cesar Ruiz OC/OG 7.75 4 42 34
Ross Blacklock IDL 7.75 5 43 34
Yetur Gross-Matos Edge 7.75 5 44 34
AJ Terrell CB 7.75 5 45 34
Justin Herbert QB 7.75 3 46 34
Kenneth Murray Off-Ball LB 7.75 4 47 34
Julian Okwara Edge 7.75 6 48 34
Noah Igbinoghene CB 7.75 6 49 34
Cole Kmet TE 7.75 1 50 34
Jalen Reagor WR 7.75 10 51 34
Laviska Shenault WR 7.75 11 52 34
Brandon Aiyuk WR 7.75 12 53 34
Isaiah Wilson OT 7.75 6 54 34
Trevon Diggs CB 7.75 7 55 34
Jordan Love QB 7.75 4 56 34
Terrell Burgess S 7.5 4 57 56
Kristian Fulton CB 7.5 8 58 56
Tyler Johnson WR 7.5 13 59 56
Cameron Dantzler CB 7.5 9 60 56
KJ Hamler WR 7.5 14 61 56
Matt Hennessy OC 7.5 5 62 56
Tee Higgins WR 7.5 15 63 56
John Simpson OG 7.5 6 64 56
Jonathan Taylor RB 7.5 5 65 56
A.J. Dillon RB 7.5 6 66 56
Josh Uche Edge 7.5 7 67 56
Nick Harris OC 7.5 7 68 56
Davon Hamilton IDL 7.25 6 69 68
Jonathan Greenard Edge 7.25 8 70 68
K.J. Hill WR 7.25 16 71 68
Cam Akers RB 7.25 7 72 68
Bradlee Anae Edge 7.25 9 73 68
Lucas Niang OT 7.25 7 74 68
Terrell Lewis Edge 7.25 10 75 68
Bryce Hall CB 7.25 10 76 68
Damon Arnette CB 7.25 11 77 68
Hakeem Adeniji OT/OG 7 8 78 77
Amik Robertson CB 7 12 79 77
Matt Peart OT 7 8 80 77
Chase Claypool WR/TE 7 17 81 77
Josiah Scott CB 7 13 82 77
Jordan Elliot IDL 6.99 7 83 82
Price Tega Wanogho OT 6.99 9 84 82
Robert Hunt OT/OG 6.99 10 85 82
Ezra Cleveland OT 6.99 10 86 82
Logan Wilson Off-Ball LB 6.99 5 87 82
Jonah Jackson OC/OG 6.99 9 88 82
Troy Pride Jr CB 6.99 14 89 82
Darnay Holmes CB 6.99 15 90 82
Jalen Hurts QB 6.99 5 91 82
Adam Trautman TE 6.99 2 92 82
Javaris Davis CB 6.99 16 93 82
John Reid CB 6.99 17 94 82
Jauan Jennings WR 6.99 18 95 82
Neville Gallimore IDL 6.99 8 96 82
Khalid Kareem Edge 6.99 11 97 82
Donovan Peoples-Jones WR 6.99 19 98 82
Antonio Gibson WR/RB 6.99 20 99 82
Evan Weaver Off-Ball LB 6.99 6 100 82
Devin Asiasi TE 6.99 3 101 82
Isaiah Hodgins WR 6.99 21 102 82
Rico Dowdle RB 6.99 8 103 82
Leki Fotu IDL 6.99 9 104 82
Jordyn Brooks Off-Ball LB 6.99 7 105 82
Dane Jackson CB 6.99 18 106 82
Ben Bartch OT 6.75 11 107 106
Austin Jackson OT 6.75 12 108 106
Michael Warren II RB 6.75 9 109 106
Ben Bredeson OG 6.75 10 110 106
Logan Stenberg OG 6.75 11 111 106
Raekwon Davis IDL 6.75 10 112 106
Jabari Zuniga Edge 6.75 13 113 106
Brandon Jones S 6.75 5 114 106
Lamar Jackson CB 6.75 19 115 106
James Lynch IDL 6.5 11 116 115
Lavert Hill CB 6.5 20 117 115
Michael Ojemudia CB 6.5 21 118 115
Antonio Gandy-Golden WR 6.5 22 119 115
Ke'Shawn Vaughn RB 6.5 10 120 115
Alex Highsmith Edge 6.49 14 121 120
Jake Fromm QB 6.49 6 122 120
Grant Delpit S 6.49 6 123 120
Jacob Eason QB 6.49 7 124 120
Kyle Dugger S 6.49 7 125 120
Saahdiq Charles OT 6.49 13 126 120
Alex Taylor OT 6.49 14 127 120
Geno Stone S 6.49 8 128 120
AJ Green CB 6.49 22 129 120
Antoine Brooks Jr. S 6.49 9 130 120
K'Von Wallace S 6.49 10 131 120
Justin Strnad Off-Ball LB 6.49 8 132 120
Shaquille Quarterman Off-Ball LB 6.49 9 133 120
McTelvin Agim IDL 6.49 12 134 120
Rashard Lawrence IDL 6.49 13 135 120
Harrison Bryant TE 6.49 4 136 120
Willie Gay Off-Ball LB 6.49 10 137 120
Josiah Deguara TE 6.49 5 138 120
Brycen Hopkins TE 6.49 6 139 120
Larrell Murchison IDL 6.49 14 140 120
Kenny Willekes Edge 6.49 15 141 120
Hakeem Adeniji OT/OG 6.49 15 142 120
Anfernee Jennings Edge 6.49 16 143 120
Curtis Weaver Edge 6.49 17 144 120
Netane Muti OG 6.49 12 145 120
John Hightower WR 6.49 23 146 120
Shane Lemieux OG 6.49 13 147 120
Lynn Bowden WR 6.49 24 148 120
Darrynton Evans RB 6.49 11 149 120
Hunter Bryant TE 6.49 7 150 120
Darius Anderson RB 6.49 12 151 120
Alton Robinson Edge 6.49 18 152 120
Harrison Hand CB 6.49 23 153 120
Eno Benjamin RB 6.49 13 154 120
Reggie Robinson II CB 6.49 24 155 120
Jeremy Chinn S 6.25 11 156 155
Tyre Phillips OT/OG 6.25 14 157 155
Justin Blackmon S 6.25 12 158 155
Collin Johnson WR 6.25 25 159 155
CJ O'Grady TE 6.25 8 160 155
Mykal Walker Off-Ball LB 6.25 11 161 155
Albert O TE 6.25 9 162 155
Van Jefferson WR 6.25 26 163 155
Cameron Brown Off-Ball LB 6.25 12 164 155
Lamical Perine RB 6.25 14 165 155
Colby Parkinson TE 6.25 10 166 155
Tanner Muse Off-Ball LB 6.25 13 167 155
Jason Strowbridge IDL 6 15 168 167
Jonathan Garvin Edge 6 19 169 167
Deejay Dallas RB 6 15 170 167
Lawrence Cager WR 6 27 171 167
Anthony McFarland RB 6 16 172 167
J.R. Reed S 6 13 173 167
Reggie Robinson CB/S 6 14 174 167
Casey Toohill Edge 6 20 175 167
Charlie Heck OT 5.99 16 176 175
Michael Onwenu OG 5.99 15 177 175
Shyheim Carter S 5.99 15 178 175
Tyler Biadasz OC 5.99 16 179 175
Jon Runyan OT/OG 5.99 17 180 175
Kindle Vildor CB 5.99 25 181 175
Trevis Gipson Edge 5.99 21 182 175
Jaylinn Hawkins S 5.99 16 183 175
Stanford Samuels III CB 5.99 26 184 175
Raequan Williams IDL 5.99 16 185 175
Anthony Gordon QB 5.99 8 186 175
James Proche WR 5.99 28 187 175
Trey Adams OT/OG 5.99 18 188 175
Markus Bailey Off-Ball LB 5.99 14 189 175
Tremayne Anchrum OT/OG 5.99 19 190 175
Josh Metellus S 5.99 17 191 175
Danny Pinter OG 5.99 20 192 175
James Morgan QB 5.99 9 193 175
Gabriel Davis WR 5.99 29 194 175
Carter Coughlin Off-Ball LB 5.99 15 195 175
Daniel Thomas S 5.99 18 196 175
Brian Cole II S 5.99 19 197 175
Jack Driscoll OT 5.75 16 198 197
Jalen Elliott S 5.75 20 199 197
Calvin Throckmorton OT/OG 5.75 21 200 197
Patrick Taylor Jr RB 5.75 17 201 197
Javelin Guidry CB 5.75 27 202 197
Colton McKivitz OT 5.5 17 203 202
Joshua Kelley RB 5.5 18 204 202
Jordan Fuller S 5.5 21 205 202
Alohi Gilman S 5.5 22 206 202
Essang Bassey CB 5.5 28 207 202
Joe Reed WR 5.49 30 208 207
Jeff Thomas WR 5.49 31 209 207
DJ Wonnum Edge 5.49 22 210 207
JaMycal Hasty RB 5.49 19 211 207
Nick Coe Edge 5.49 12 212 207
Keith Ismael OC 5 22 213 212
Broderick Washington IDL 5 17 214 212
Thad Moss TE 5 11 215 212
Cole McDonald QB 5 10 216 212
Jacob Breeland TE 5 12 217 212
Calvin Throckmorton OT/OG 4.99 18 218 217
Michael Pinckney Off-Ball LB 4.99 16 219 217
Tremayne Anchrum OT/OG 4.99 19 220 217
Quartney Davis WR 4.99 32 221 217
Tyre Phillips OT/OG 4.99 16 222 217
Darryl Williams OC/OG 4.99 23 223 217
Tyler Huntley QB 4.99 11 224 217
Jarred Pinkney TE 4.99 13 225 217
Nate Stanley QB 4.99 12 226 217
Javon Leake RB 4.99 20 227 217
Jacob Phillips Off-Ball LB 4.99 17 228 217
Mitchell Wilcox TE 4.99 14 229 217
Scottie Phillips RB 4.75 21 230 229
Trey Adams OT/OG 4.75 20 231 229
Terence Steele OT/OG 4.75 21 232 229
David Woodward Off-Ball LB 4.75 18 233 229
Isaiah Coulter WR 4.5 33 234 233
Sean McKeon TE 4.5 15 235 233
Cameron Clark OT/OG 4.5 24 236 233
Tyrie Cleveland WR 4.49 34 237 236
Jake Hanson OC/OG 4.49 25 238 236
Kalija Lipscomb WR 4.49 35 239 236
K.J. Osborn WR 4.49 36 240 236
J.J. Taylor RB 4.49 22 241 236
Cohl Cabral OC 4.25 26 242 241
Kyle Murphy OG/OC 4.25 27 243 241
Austin Mack WR 4.25 37 244 241
Raymond Calais RB 4.25 23 245 241
Lavonte Bellamy RB 4.25 24 246 241
Aaron Parker WR 4 38 247 246
Simon Stepaniak OG 4 28 248 246
Marquez Callaway WR 3.99 39 249 248
James Smith-Williams Edge 3.99 23 250 248
Justin Herron OT/OG 3.99 29 251 248
Binjiman Victor WR 3.99 40 252 248
Aaron Fuller WR 3.99 41 253 248
Derrek Tuszka Edge 3.99 24 254 248
Steven Montez QB 3.99 13 255 248
Yasir Durant OT/OG 3.75 30 256 255
Solomon Kindley OG 3.75 31 257 255
Juwan Johnson WR 3.5 42 258 257
Kendrick Rogers WR 3.5 43 259 257
Nick Westbrook WR 3.25 44 260 259



I am working on identifying the best fits for the Pats as well in one to view post here and not a massive spreadsheet. I did try to organize this with a Patriots lens.
 
Last edited:

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
Just a ridiculously impressive accomplishment, SMU. This is genuinely awesome. There's a ton of guys I'd want to pick your brain on. Right now, I'm a bit fixated on Zuniga. As a couch scout, he's hard for me to evaluate so I'm curious how you saw him. His junior year, all the athletic and talent flashes were there but I thought he was much too passive; lots of standing around and watching plays happen instead of hitting people. As a late basketball to football convert, I guess that makes sense. His senior year though, it's like a switch flipped and he was significantly more active and physical, the motor ran much hotter. Now, he only played a few games this past year due to the ankle, so who knows if it would have held up. But if I went solely off the Miami and UVA games and never saw his underclassman games, I'd think he was a 1st rounder. He destroyed Miami, they couldn't handle him. What did you make of Zuniga? For me, the upside is really high if the senior year motor is real and sustainable.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
The problem with Miami @EL Jeffe is their OL was trash this year. Jon Greenard went off on them too. Zuniga is an interesting guy. He has fantastic burst and speed but has a lot of hip stiffness and not that much bend. His pass rush plan is nothing to write home about and he doesn't have good counters. He exhibits tremendous power at the point of attack but gets stuck on blocks and needs work shedding. He also unfortunately has short arms and that with his limited lateral agility make tackling an issue. I think he has starting potential but like Terrell Lewis needs a lot of technical refinement.
 

BigJimEd

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 4, 2002
4,432
Baun had a "diluted" sample at the combine. Claims it was due to drinking significant amount of water before weigh in.
 

SMU_Sox

queer eye for the next pats guy
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2009
8,878
Dallas
He happens to be a guy I am pretty high on. Year one he has to go from running either all or almost all zone plays with the RCs to learning how to block in man concepts. I hit him with a 7.75 because he has unique potential to be an interior wrecking ball. He also has to go from RT most likely to guard. Why am I comfortable with that? Because what the Patriots want from their guys is smart, powerful, athletic enough and tough. That’s Hunt to the letter. He doesn’t just want to block you he wants to completely erase you and give you nightmares for years to come. There were probably 5-10 tackles and IOLs that I chuckled at how ferocious they were. Hunt is near the top of that pack. His mirroring ability in pass pro was good too and he rarely let up any pressure. His vulnerability against super fast edge rushers is overblown to begin with but is erased at guard. My only concern with him is that he doesn’t meet their standard guard prototypes because he is bigger and slightly less athletic. Liking Robert Hunt is like liking a good craft beer. I like your taste. If you liked him let me give you another beer recommendation: Logan Stenberg, guard and taker of souls. Not a great fit here and probably not a starter and certainly not in year one but just for his tape. If Robert Hunt is an IPA Logan Stenberg is the hoppiest IPA there is in and maybe too hoppy for mass market success (as a starter in the nfl).
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
I haven't done any type of deep dive on the prospects yet. I watched two ND games this weekend (UGA, VT) for Kmet; his blocking wasn't as good as I anticipated (although it looked better against VT later in the year). Physically, he looks really good and moves well. Good ball skills, some toughness. He's definitely not Hockenson as a prospect, but he reminded me some of Zach Ertz coming out of Stanford. I don't think Kmet is ready for prime-time as a rooke, so 23 might be a tad rich. But as TE1, he could easily get pushed up the board to that range.
Some momentum is building for Kmet in round 1, and Breer mocked him to NE today. As I said several weeks ago, 23 seems a bit high for him, but I thought he could end up getting pushed that high. Looks like that may be happening. Honestly, I wouldn't hate it. TE is the weakest area on the team--by far--and Kmet is TE1 by a good margin for me. Physically, he has just about all the tools but I don't think he'll be ready to block NFL edge players as a rookie. He's not Gronk strong. But I do think he'll eventually be at least league-average as a blocker (with the potential to be better than that). In the passing game, he should be a matchup problem at 6'6, 262#, 10.5" hands, 4.7 40, and a 37" vertical. Those are legit numbers.

For essentially a 1-year producer, I think he's a reasonably safe projection. He does have a really nice physical profile, he did get substantially better each season, and as a legit two sport collegiate athlete who gave up baseball recently, 100% dedication to football could certainly make a difference for him going forward. I'd rather pick him in the 40s, but the TE class is so weak I'm not sure you can afford to miss out on him.
 

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,069
Hingham, MA
I bet Kmet is off the board by 23. Similar to Hockenson last year, his stock continues to rise and some team will pick him earlier than he should really go.
 

Cellar-Door

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2006
34,464
Feels like people talking themselves into a TE just because he's the best in a really bad class. The value is just terrible, especially for a guy who doesn't really block. You can get a better weapon 70 picks later as a slot WR. Hockenson made sense because he was a good blocker so he had way more value.

Edit- to be more clear... unless a TE is a good blocker, he's basically a slot WR. And particularly in this draft you can get a good slot WR way later than a TE and have more on-field value.
 

EL Jeffe

Member
SoSH Member
Aug 30, 2006
1,314
Kmet definitely isn't Hockenson as a blocker, that's for sure. But I don't think it's fair to say Kmet doesn't really block; he does, he's just very inconsistent. Lots of lunging, ends up on the ground at times, loses his balance, etc. Other times, he looks really good. He needs reps, technique work, and added strength--though he weighed in at 262# at the combine but reportedly played at around 250#, so the added strength is on the way.

He's not Mark Andrews coming out of Oklahoma who just didn't bother blocking anyone. Kmet did a lot of Y work, but with very mixed results. He's a projection, but I'm a sucker for projections (Chaisson and Uche are two of my favorites in this class). As I said earlier, as far as projections go, Kmet is probably a safer bet than most. The floor is reasonably high just based on his physical profile and receiving production in a conventional offense.
 

Super Nomario

Member
SoSH Member
Nov 5, 2000
14,012
Mansfield MA
Kmet definitely isn't Hockenson as a blocker, that's for sure. But I don't think it's fair to say Kmet doesn't really block; he does, he's just very inconsistent. Lots of lunging, ends up on the ground at times, loses his balance, etc. Other times, he looks really good. He needs reps, technique work, and added strength--though he weighed in at 262# at the combine but reportedly played at around 250#, so the added strength is on the way.

He's not Mark Andrews coming out of Oklahoma who just didn't bother blocking anyone. Kmet did a lot of Y work, but with very mixed results. He's a projection, but I'm a sucker for projections (Chaisson and Uche are two of my favorites in this class). As I said earlier, as far as projections go, Kmet is probably a safer bet than most. The floor is reasonably high just based on his physical profile and receiving production in a conventional offense.
I'm with you on this. Kmet's blocking was inconsistent, but I wouldn't call him a bad blocker, and they put a lot on his plate in terms of different blocking assignments. But his route tree was really small, too, and he's got work to do there. I like him the best for the Pats in this class, but I wouldn't expect a lot of production Y1. Hell, Hockenson had like 350 receiving yards last year. But Kmet is going to check the boxes for the Pats in terms of size, physical profile, and off-field / intangible stuff.

FWIW Pioli was gushing about Kmet on Tom Curran's podcast, saying that he noticed Kmet as a freshman when scouting upperclassmen and that Kmet would work before and after practice with the offensive line, which is something you don't see a lot. And while it took him until this year to get a lot of run, he still had to beat out Brock Wright, who came in as the #1 TE in the same recruiting class.

EDIT: I could see a Devin McCourty situation where the Pats wind up taking Kmet in the first but trade back to 29 or something.