How to get back in this thing

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,328
Hingham, MA
To be honest I'm not so much looking at their record as I am the WC standings. They've climbed to within 3 games of the final spot, with only one team (the ChiSox) in between them. If they can jump the ChiSox and get within a game of the WC soon, then at that point it's "season on" and it becomes about just getting into one of those spots and playing ever so slightly better than the remaining nine teams to hold onto a playoff spot.
 

Smiling Joe Hesketh

Throw Momma From the Train
Moderator
SoSH Member
May 20, 2003
35,848
Deep inside Muppet Labs
They're at 21-23 with six games left in the month. My goal for them (or my hope anyway) was to be at .500 by the end of the month. Just need to go 4-2 to make that happen, with five games against Baltimore (18-27) and one against Cincinnati (14-30). Hope they can pull that off.
This is where I'm at. They're still much to far out of the divisional race to care about that, they really need to continue working to righting the ship and recovering from their historically awful start. It's telling that the hot streak they've been on still hasn't been yet able to overcome the damage of April.

Get to .500, continue improving on the things you noted (I'm glad to see Cora being more willing to let starters go deeper into games) and make some tough personnel decisions. I suspect Barnes' time here has come to an end after last night, he's simply not a major league pitcher right now.
 

pokey_reese

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 25, 2008
16,311
Boston, MA
After the offensive show last night, run differential is +21. The AL teams ahead of them by that measure are the Yanks, Twins, Astros, and Angels. That's it. Losing basically every close/extra-innings game early on hurt them a lot, but I am hopeful that trend will have reversed itself by season's end.
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
To be honest I'm not so much looking at their record as I am the WC standings. They've climbed to within 3 games of the final spot, with only one team (the ChiSox) in between them. If they can jump the ChiSox and get within a game of the WC soon, then at that point it's "season on" and it becomes about just getting into one of those spots and playing ever so slightly better than the remaining nine teams to hold onto a playoff spot.
That's one way of looking at it. Re: the bolded, one has to consider the unbalanced schedule and the AL East though. The Yanks, Rays, and Jays will be gunning for the postseason and represent more difficult opponents than, say, what the ChiSox will be facing for the rest of the year.

Ultimately, you can only deal with what's in front of you - day by day, game by game.

I think a path is still there. But again, the margin is very tight. A major losing streak or even not capitalizing on a series against weaker opponents might tell in the end.
 

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,328
Hingham, MA
That's one way of looking at it. Re: the bolded, one has to consider the unbalanced schedule and the AL East though. The Yanks, Rays, and Jays will be gunning for the postseason and represent more difficult opponents than, say, what the ChiSox will be facing for the rest of the year.

Ultimately, you can only deal with what's in front of you - day by day, game by game.

I think a path is still there. But again, the margin is very tight. A major losing streak or even not capitalizing on a series against weaker opponents might tell in the end.
Absolutely true, and the same probably applies to the Angels (if they're for real) with the Rangers, A's, and M's in their division. The Sox will need to tread water against the MFY / Rays / Jays and beat up on the dregs of the league to have a shot.

To your last point, the Sox next 10 are against Baltimore, Cincy, and Oakland. Will a 4-6, 5-5, or 6-4 stretch end the Sox season? Of course not, it's too early. But if they only go 5-5 and miss out on a WC spot by a game, it could be looked back at as a missed opportunity (along with all of the early extra inning losses).
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
Absolutely true, and the same probably applies to the Angels (if they're for real) with the Rangers, A's, and M's in their division. The Sox will need to tread water against the MFY / Rays / Jays and beat up on the dregs of the league to have a shot.

To your last point, the Sox next 10 are against Baltimore, Cincy, and Oakland. Will a 4-6, 5-5, or 6-4 stretch end the Sox season? Of course not, it's too early. But if they only go 5-5 and miss out on a WC spot by a game, it could be looked back at as a missed opportunity (along with all of the early extra inning losses).
I'd agree generally. But I think these next few games are very important, in a gather ye rosebuds way. If they can't use this stretch against weak teams to better position themselves, it's going to be more difficult to do it later.

I say that mostly because from a real politik baseball view is that we're really looking at the trade deadline as a significant cutoff point. There are a lot of possible outcomes (including holding pat and hoping for the best if we're reasonably in contention) but a fire-sale ends the season.

This year the deadline is August 2. July 17 is the last game before the ASB, and we might reasonably consider it a near-final take-stock moment, giving them 2 weeks to put trades together (one way or the other.) Although they might not pull the trigger on something till the deadline.

FWIW, the ASB is 93 games into the season. We're on 45 tonight, so by the end of the Birds/Reds series, we'll be a bit more than halfway there. It's probably worth putting the schedule here for discussion purposes. As a back-of-the-envelope strength of schedule, teams in red currently have a pythag of .500 or above, representing harder opponents. Green is a negative pythag.

BAL - 5
CIN - 2
@OAK - 3

@LAA - 4
@SEA - 3
OAK - 3

STL - 3
DET - 3
@CLE - 3
@TOR - 3

@CHI - 3
TBR - 3
NYY - 4
@TBR - 3
@NYY - 3

***ASB***
TOR - 3
CLE - 4
MIL - 3
@HOU 3
(Trade deadline on the second game)

So yes, the strategy ought to be: "Gather ye rosebuds, right fucking now!"

It's also why a 2-8 stretch (which I don't expect) would lead me to consider the season as most-likley done.
 

donutogre

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 20, 2005
3,236
Philadelphia
You're right that it's make a move now or likely it's going to be over. That's a pretty brutal stretch on both sides of the all-star break.
 

Red(s)HawksFan

Member
SoSH Member
Jan 23, 2009
20,872
Maine
This is where I'm at. They're still much to far out of the divisional race to care about that, they really need to continue working to righting the ship and recovering from their historically awful start. It's telling that the hot streak they've been on still hasn't been yet able to overcome the damage of April.

Get to .500, continue improving on the things you noted (I'm glad to see Cora being more willing to let starters go deeper into games) and make some tough personnel decisions. I suspect Barnes' time here has come to an end after last night, he's simply not a major league pitcher right now.
Believe it or not, but the Sox have lost ground in the division during this hot streak. Since May 8, the Sox are 11-4 but the Yankees are 13-5. Even without the piss poor April, they might still be pretty far out in the division.

I think you're right about things going forward, though. All they can do is get over .500 and continue improving both on the field and on the roster margins, and hope the Yankees come back to earth a bit in the meantime.
 

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,328
Hingham, MA
recovering from their historically awful start
You know this, but there was nothing historically awful about their start, unless you are limiting this to the past ~30 years of Red Sox baseball. When the Sox were 10-19 there were three other teams with worse records.

It was a terrible start and a huge hole to overcome (and thankfully they've dug a decent amount of the way out). But historically awful is complete hyperbole and you know that.
 

Smiling Joe Hesketh

Throw Momma From the Train
Moderator
SoSH Member
May 20, 2003
35,848
Deep inside Muppet Labs
You know this, but there was nothing historically awful about their start, unless you are limiting this to the past ~30 years of Red Sox baseball. When the Sox were 10-19 there were three other teams with worse records.

It was a terrible start and a huge hole to overcome (and thankfully they've dug a decent amount of the way out). But historically awful is complete hyperbole and you know that.
It was IIRC their worst start since 1966.

So my point remains.
 

TheYellowDart5

Hustle and bustle
SoSH Member
Apr 16, 2003
9,297
NYC
For what it's worth, Boston's playoff odds per FanGraphs bottomed out at 19.3% back on May 15; they're all the way up to 39% as of today. Granted, they started the season at 61.3%, so it's still a big fall, but they've clawed back a good amount of ground in just two weeks. They're still way behind in the division and overall — Tampa is next in the East at 64% and Minnesota is the next lowest at 60% — but the good news is there's no one within a mile of them either; Cleveland has the next highest odds, and those are just 9.4%. It's a long road back, but there's no one on their tail at least.
 

ookami7m

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
5,678
Mobile, AL
Believe it or not, but the Sox have lost ground in the division during this hot streak. Since May 8, the Sox are 11-4 but the Yankees are 13-5. Even without the piss poor April, they might still be pretty far out in the division.

I think you're right about things going forward, though. All they can do is get over .500 and continue improving both on the field and on the roster margins, and hope the Yankees come back to earth a bit in the meantime.
I don't think that winning the division matters nearly as much when there are 3 wild card spots to reach for. The Yankees can run with the division so long as the Sox get IN.

For what it's worth, Boston's playoff odds per FanGraphs bottomed out at 19.3% back on May 15; they're all the way up to 39% as of today. Granted, they started the season at 61.3%, so it's still a big fall, but they've clawed back a good amount of ground in just two weeks. They're still way behind in the division and overall — Tampa is next in the East at 64% and Minnesota is the next lowest at 60% — but the good news is there's no one within a mile of them either; Cleveland has the next highest odds, and those are just 9.4%. It's a long road back, but there's no one on their tail at least.
See above - the bigger playoffs give teams a longer time to decide if they are in or out.
 

scottyno

late Bloomer
SoSH Member
Dec 7, 2008
11,339
You know this, but there was nothing historically awful about their start, unless you are limiting this to the past ~30 years of Red Sox baseball. When the Sox were 10-19 there were three other teams with worse records.

It was a terrible start and a huge hole to overcome (and thankfully they've dug a decent amount of the way out). But historically awful is complete hyperbole and you know that.
So are 95% of his posts, but that hasn't stopped them yet. You would have thought the same people crying during a bad stretch last year would have learned not to overreact this year, but here we are again.
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
Updated.
A trimmed version of a post in the "in season discussion thread" follows. 87 wins may, or may not, result in a WC berth.

They're playing the CWS (3), BAL (5), and CIN (2) over the next 10 games. Yes, there are two obvious sub .500 teams in there, but that's kind of the point. If we assume later series against the Rays and Yanks are going to be tougher and skew more toward splits, we have to win here and now.

If the Sox stay red-hot and go 10-0, they'll stand at 29-22, and a 90 win target (solid post season chance) in the remaining 111 games would require 61 wins (.549):
10-0 - .549
9-1 - .558

8-2 - .567
7-3 - .576
6-4 - .585
5-5 - .594
4-6 - .603
3-7 - .612
2-8 - .621
1-9 - .630
0-10 - .639


This is the set for the more modest 87 win target (which is maybe? a 50% chance of making the post season):
10-0 - .522
9-1 - .531

8-2 - .540
7-3 - .549
6-4 - .558
5-5 - .567
4-6 - .576
3-7 - .585
2-8 - .594
1-9 - .603
0-10 - .612


Last year they went .568 over the whole season, hot start and all. If .568 is the approximate talent level (against better teams in the remaining games), they're still right on the edge. That said, if they manhandle the next 10 games, and take stock the morning of the 11th. . .they'd be solidly in the mix for the postseason. Going 5-5 puts them in the question mark category. If they go below .500, they're pretty much done.
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
24,661
Well blowing a game to Baltimore when up 8-2 is not at all how I envisioned the start to this last stretch of the month for the Sox. Ugh.
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
Well blowing a game to Baltimore when up 8-2 is not at all how I envisioned the start to this last stretch of the month for the Sox. Ugh.
Yeah, the clock ticks down. (Per bRef the win expectancy from the 5th to 7th innings was 95-98%.)

The Sox can't afford to convert those kinds of opportunities into losses.
 

koufax32

He'll cry if he wants to...
SoSH Member
Dec 8, 2006
9,106
Duval
Well step one seems to be replacing Carlos “wave em in Wendell Kim” Febles.
 

BaseballJones

ivanvamp
SoSH Member
Oct 1, 2015
24,661
After the split today, they're at 22-25 with three games to go in the month. .500 at best if they win the next three. Ugh. You can't lose like this to the Orioles and expect to get back in the race.
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
Updated, again for posterity's sake, as we narrow down to .500 ball during the easier stretch:
If the Sox stay red-hot and go 10-0, they'll stand at 29-22, and a 90 win target (solid post season chance) in the remaining 111 games would require 61 wins (.549):
10-0 - .549
9-1 - .558
8-2 - .567

7-3 - .576
6-4 - .585
5-5 - .594
4-6 - .603
3-7 - .612
2-8 - .621
1-9 - .630
0-10 - .639


This is the set for the more modest 87 win target (which is maybe? a 50% chance of making the post season):
10-0 - .522
9-1 - .531
8-2 - .540

7-3 - .549
6-4 - .558
5-5 - .567
4-6 - .576
3-7 - .585
2-8 - .594
1-9 - .603
0-10 - .612
 

jon abbey

Shanghai Warrior
Moderator
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
71,128
Letting the Orioles be more than competitive with them is certainly not going to cut it.
Although the Orioles are playing everyone tough the last few weeks, 2-2 against NY and 2-1 against TB in their seven games before this series.
 

CoffeeNerdness

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 6, 2012
8,851
Do you really look at this team and think that? I think this is a team that can compete at a 90-95 win level. Not that they will on paper but rather they're that level of quality team(thanks to the historically bad but flukey start of the season). Fully expect Bloom to shore up the pen and for this team to be the team nobody wants to play come October.

The 'this team can't afford these kinds of stumbles' because they lost 2-3 to the O's are a bit too much. Shit happens. Love, Josh Wincowski.
 

DeadlySplitter

Member
SoSH Member
Oct 20, 2015
33,542
I think this is a 82-88 win team that got really lucky / overperformed last year, and the worm turned so far this year. Pretty sure I'm not alone in those thoughts. "Can compete" at 90-95 win level is a fair assessment at their best.

The real problem with this team is Sale has been a 0, again. Whitlock may be a quality starter in time, but he looks a bit uncomfortable out there while leaving the pen empty at the same time. And we won't really know what Sale can give until close to the deadline, and that's assuming no more setbacks, which is way too big an assumption now for him.

With the 3rd WC they'll probably still be in it in July and do some semblance of half-buying at worst. They have a lot of rule 5 eligible minor leaguers to attempt to get value out of, too.
 

streeter88

Member
SoSH Member
Apr 2, 2006
1,807
Melbourne, Australia
Yeah, the clock ticks down. (Per bRef the win expectancy from the 5th to 7th innings was 95-98%.)

The Sox can't afford to convert those kinds of opportunities into losses.
Can I propose that the definition for “bone head loss” is related to win expectancy? Maybe if >98% in innings 5-7 or >95% in innings 8 or later?

That way we could use stats. If we have to judge bad decisions it could get messy.
 

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,328
Hingham, MA
After the split today, they're at 22-25 with three games to go in the month. .500 at best if they win the next three. Ugh. You can't lose like this to the Orioles and expect to get back in the race.
Letting the Orioles be more than competitive with them is certainly not going to cut it.
It's really just Friday night's loss. 23-24 with three games to go means 2-1 gets to .500.

I've been looking at this 10 game stretch (5 BAL / 2 CIN / 3 OAK) as the bellweather, with 6-4 the bare minimum needed and 7-3 or better as getting them back into the race. Unfortunately, a 1-2 start.
 

dynomite

Member
SoSH Member
It's really just Friday night's loss. 23-24 with three games to go means 2-1 gets to .500.

I've been looking at this 10 game stretch (5 BAL / 2 CIN / 3 OAK) as the bellweather, with 6-4 the bare minimum needed and 7-3 or better as getting them back into the race. Unfortunately, a 1-2 start.
This is a totally reasonable point of view, but especially with the 3rd Wild Card I just don’t view late May as the bellwether moment, especially because there are good reasons to think this team will be better in July/August than it is right now. Maybe I’m being naive, but as discussed in other places:

Last night I was at Fenway to watch a AAA filler cough up 4 ER to Baltimore. By July Sale and/or Paxton and/or Bello should be in the rotation, and despite how well the rotation has pitched it will allow us to move Whitlock back to the pen where he belongs and reshuffle elsewhere as needed. (I still harbor hope that Frankie Montas could be headed here from Oakland in exchange for a package built around Dalbec and Duran but I can put a pin in that)

Dalbec will either start hitting or be shuffled off to AAA or traded, whereupon Casas and/or Fitzgerald almost can’t help but be better than a .172 avg with a 52 wRC.

And I’m hopeful Chaim sees what we see in the bullpen and is planning to move Whitlock back to the pen when possible and also get help — trade for David Robertson on the Cubs or the much pricier (in terms of prospects) Bednar on the Pirates, etc.

So the overall ROS win numbers don’t mean as much to me.

If the team can be .500 through June with this flawed roster, let’s say 41-41 in early July, I still believe they can finish, say, 47-33 (.587) with a better roster in the 2nd half to finish with 88 wins. Not sure if that will be good enough, of course, but it’s what I’m telling myself.
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
Do you really look at this team and think that? I think this is a team that can compete at a 90-95 win level. Not that they will on paper but rather they're that level of quality team(thanks to the historically bad but flukey start of the season). Fully expect Bloom to shore up the pen and for this team to be the team nobody wants to play come October.

The 'this team can't afford these kinds of stumbles' because they lost 2-3 to the O's are a bit too much. Shit happens. Love, Josh Wincowski.
If you think their true talent level is a 90-95 win team (.555 to .586 WP), and they start playing like that tomorrow, they'll finish with a 64 to 69 additional wins. Their total wins would be 86-91.

These are the #6 spot for the AL:
2021, the #6 team had 91 wins.​
2019 - 93.​
2018 - 90.​
2017 - 80 (3 team tie).​
2016 - 86 (2 team tie).​
2015 - 85​
2014 - 87​
2013 - 91​
2012 - 90​

So a scenario where they play at .634 clip (better than all the other recent Sox teams, save 2018), and get the #5 or 6 spot with 95 wins is still possible. But it's not very likely.

But they are not dead yet re: the #6 spot. If they finish with 91 wins, they've got an excellent chance of going in. If they finish with 86, they're absolutely no guarantee they're in.

So, in context, every stretch of treading water raises the excellence of play that will be required for the rest of the season.

Would I love to see a 10 game winning streak against TBR and NYY? Yeah. But it's not exactly a reasonable thing to expect, when, for whatever reason, you can't pull yourself back to .500.
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
This is a totally reasonable point of view, but especially with the 3rd Wild Card I just don’t view late May as the bellwether moment, especially because there are good reasons to think this team will be better in July/August than it is right now. Maybe I’m being naive, but as discussed in other places:

Last night I was at Fenway to watch a AAA filler cough up 4 ER to Baltimore. By July Sale and/or Paxton and/or Bello should be in the rotation, and despite how well the rotation has pitched it will allow us to move Whitlock back to the pen where he belongs and reshuffle elsewhere as needed. (I still harbor hope that Frankie Montas could be headed here from Oakland in exchange for a package built around Dalbec and Duran but I can put a pin in that)

Dalbec will either start hitting or be shuffled off to AAA or traded, whereupon Casas and/or Fitzgerald almost can’t help but be better than a .172 avg with a 52 wRC.

And I’m hopeful Chaim sees what we see in the bullpen and is planning to move Whitlock back to the pen when possible and also get help — trade for David Robertson on the Cubs or the much pricier (in terms of prospects) Bednar on the Pirates, etc.

So the overall ROS win numbers don’t mean as much to me.

If the team can be .500 through June with this flawed roster, let’s say 41-41 in early July, I still believe they can finish, say, 47-33 (.587) with a better roster in the 2nd half to finish with 88 wins. Not sure if that will be good enough, of course, but it’s what I’m telling myself.
Things can change, certainly. Last year Sale, after a month of scaling up in the minors, came back in early August and gave us 9 starts. Most of the time he went 5 or 5.1 innings, and the team went 7-2.

What's a reasonable expectation for him and/or Paxton this year?
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
Can I propose that the definition for “bone head loss” is related to win expectancy? Maybe if >98% in innings 5-7 or >95% in innings 8 or later?

That way we could use stats. If we have to judge bad decisions it could get messy.
This is all back-of-the-envelope stuff anyway. The point is to drill down a little bit on our two friends: But There Are More Games (how many, against who?) and They Can Still Get Hot (how hot, for how long, resultng in what?)

Our friends aren't irrational. They may even be correct. But they have a particular shape to them, and it's worth looking to see what it is.
 

dynomite

Member
SoSH Member
Things can change, certainly. Last year Sale, after a month of scaling up in the minors, came back in early August and gave us 9 starts. Most of the time he went 5 or 5.1 innings, and the team went 7-2.

What's a reasonable expectation for him and/or Paxton this year?
Its a good question. Some of this is inherently wishful because, well, it’s a beautiful Sunday in May and the Sox have 4 banners this century above home plate.

So could Sale and Paxton come back in mid/late July and give us 18-20 starts, 3.75 ERA, and the team go 12-6? I don’t see why not. Even 11-7 (.611) would still help the cause.

Edit: And Bello is another wild card who could help in short order (unless traded… for Montas?).

Personally I think Wacha has been smoke & mirrors (the .203 BABIP is why he has a 4.49 xFIP, one of the largest gaps between ERA and expected regression in the league).

But a rotation of Eovaldi/Sale/Pivetta/Paxton/Bello/Hill in some order with Whitlock leading the bullpen and Wacha filling the gaps seems potentially really strong to me.
 
Last edited:

tims4wins

PN23's replacement
SoSH Member
Jul 15, 2005
37,328
Hingham, MA
This is a totally reasonable point of view, but especially with the 3rd Wild Card I just don’t view late May as the bellwether moment, especially because there are good reasons to think this team will be better in July/August than it is right now. Maybe I’m being naive, but as discussed in other places:

Last night I was at Fenway to watch a AAA filler cough up 4 ER to Baltimore. By July Sale and/or Paxton and/or Bello should be in the rotation, and despite how well the rotation has pitched it will allow us to move Whitlock back to the pen where he belongs and reshuffle elsewhere as needed. (I still harbor hope that Frankie Montas could be headed here from Oakland in exchange for a package built around Dalbec and Duran but I can put a pin in that)

Dalbec will either start hitting or be shuffled off to AAA or traded, whereupon Casas and/or Fitzgerald almost can’t help but be better than a .172 avg with a 52 wRC.

And I’m hopeful Chaim sees what we see in the bullpen and is planning to move Whitlock back to the pen when possible and also get help — trade for David Robertson on the Cubs or the much pricier (in terms of prospects) Bednar on the Pirates, etc.

So the overall ROS win numbers don’t mean as much to me.

If the team can be .500 through June with this flawed roster, let’s say 41-41 in early July, I still believe they can finish, say, 47-33 (.587) with a better roster in the 2nd half to finish with 88 wins. Not sure if that will be good enough, of course, but it’s what I’m telling myself.
To clarify, by bellweather I didn't really mean "punt" vs. "go for it" based on this 10 game stretch. Just that they needed a good stretch to climb back into it.

5-2 over the next 7 gets them to 27-27 with exactly 2/3 of the season left to play. Just a ton of time.
 

dynomite

Member
SoSH Member
To clarify, by bellweather I didn't really mean "punt" vs. "go for it" based on this 10 game stretch. Just that they needed a good stretch to climb back into it.

5-2 over the next 7 gets them to 27-27 with exactly 2/3 of the season left to play. Just a ton of time.
Totally, that makes sense. So much of the season is left.

Maybe the reinforcements will never come, in which case that's a whole other problem, but my hope is they do slightly better than tread water until there's reinforcements. Say something like 19-16 (.542) over the next 6 weeks of games gets them to 41-41 and .500 by roughly the ASB. June won't be a cakewalk but apart from the 7 @ LAA & TOR none of it seems daunting until they run the Rays/Yankees gauntlet from July 4th to 17th as others have said. That's the 14 games that could break the season, I think, if they bellyflop, or theoretically help make the season if they crush it.
 

YTF

Member
SoSH Member
Its a good question. Some of this is inherently wishful because, well, it’s a beautiful Sunday in May and the Sox have 4 banners this century above home plate.

So could Sale and Paxton come back in mid/late July and give us 18-20 starts, 3.75 ERA, and the team go 12-6? I don’t see why not. Even 11-7 (.611) would still help the cause.

Edit: And Bello is another wild card who could help in short order (unless traded… for Montas?).

Personally I think Wacha has been smoke & mirrors (the .203 BABIP is why he has a 4.49 xFIP, one of the largest gaps between ERA and expected regression in the league).

But a rotation of Eovaldi/Sale/Pivetta/Paxton/Bello/Hill in some order with Whitlock leading the bullpen and Wacha filling the gaps seems potentially really strong to me.
Bello has a total of 12 career AAA innings pitched, he's not going to be a meaningful part of this season's rotation. Maybe he gets a doubleheader call up like Winckowski did yesterday, but this organization isn't going to rush his progress.
 

dynomite

Member
SoSH Member
Bello has a total of 12 career AAA innings pitched, he's not going to be a meaningful part of this season's rotation. Maybe he gets a doubleheader call up like Winckowski did yesterday, but this organization isn't going to rush his progress.
Maybe, but maybe not. If by the ASB Bello continues to pitch well at AAA I don't think it's out of the question the team might prefer to bring him up to the Majors without feeling like they're "rushing" him.

Tanner Houck was a special case because of the pandemic, but he only pitched 25 IP in AAA before his callup in 2020, and another 21 IP in AAA in 2021 before he was called up last year.

Also, a fair number of players (pitchers in particular) skipped AAA altogether in recent years, in large part of course because of the pandemic disruption to rosters. But it often went okay. For 2020 alone:

 
Last edited:

YTF

Member
SoSH Member
With all due respect, I don't see Bloom doing something just because all the other kids are doing it and I'm guessing very few (if any) of those starting pitchers listed were elevated into a situation where the team already had 7-8 potential starting options on the 26 man roster. The rotation has been a strength thus far and Paxton and Sale (in theory) move one or two of the current starters to the pen. I can't see them elevating Bello into that rotation unless they are forced to. Maybe a few spot starts to spell guys in the dog days, maybe as one of the two additional call ups in September perhaps if one or both of Sale and Paxton can't perform, but I highly doubt he's elevated along with Paxton and Sale. There has been a greater need at first base and in the outfield this season, yet Jarren Durran and Tristan Casas have a total of 5 MLB plate appearances this season between them.
 

dynomite

Member
SoSH Member
With all due respect, I don't see Bloom doing something just because all the other kids are doing it and I'm guessing very few (if any) of those starting pitchers listed were elevated into a situation where the team already had 7-8 potential starting options on the 26 man roster.
That may be the case, but it's not just "all the other kids" -- under Bloom's watch they brought Houck up after just a handful of starts in AAA. Again, the pandemic played a major role there, and the 2020 team was a dumpster fire, but it's not as if this would be unprecedented.

Anyway, here's hoping Sale and Paxton come back strong and there's no need for Bello. I will say I'm a little worried about Hill (4.62 xFIP) and Wacha (4.49 xFIP) hitting some regression in the coming weeks, but for now all is well.
 

Rovin Romine

Johnny Rico
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jul 14, 2005
24,409
Miami (oh, Miami!)
Updated, for posterity's sake; trending in the right direction for the 10 game easy stretch. Hopefully, they add another today.

If the Sox stay red-hot and go 10-0, they'll stand at 29-22, and a 90 win target (solid post season chance) in the remaining 111 games would require 61 wins (.549):
10-0 - .549
9-1 - .558
8-2 - .567

7-3 - .576
6-4 - .585
5-5 - .594
4-6 - .603
3-7 - .612
2-8 - .621
1-9 - .630
0-10 - .639


This is the set for the more modest 87 win target (which is maybe? a 50% chance of making the post season):
10-0 - .522
9-1 - .531
8-2 - .540

7-3 - .549
6-4 - .558
5-5 - .567
4-6 - .576
3-7 - .585
2-8 - .594
1-9 - .603
0-10 - .612