Well yes he was bad tonight. But as for the other two--when you were listing the question marks, you'd already mentioned injury history and "character." I don't think anyone is arguing the gamble on his health. The character issue is debatable at best. So was there anything pertaining to his performance you were referring to or was that just you trying to slip one by?
well he was consistently bad tonight, consistently injured over his career and consistently afraid to play in the spotlight...so I guess you're right he is consistent.
Here's my point: he's not inconsistent. Its actually one of the things he has in his favor. Words actually mean things that people can you know, call you on.