So just a few small ruminations on my understanding of the runner’s lane interference play last night. If nothing else the Red Sox in the playoffs over the last several years have involved some pretty funky rules and rules interpretations.
For RLI you need two elements. Runner out of the lane except for his final approach into first base to touch it, and interference. I don’t think runner out of the lane is controversial here.
So that leaves interference. The runner must interfere with the throw or act of fielding. This is sort of like the word “prevented” in the spectator interference rule we all just learned about. It requires the umpire to judge that the play would probably have been successfully completed but for the interference.
But here’s the crucial part. In making that determination the umpire is not allowed to consider that the throw might have been affected by the runner being in the wrong place. This is counterintuitive and different from the rules in high school. We saw an example of this in a Yankees game last year where the catcher had no lane and tried to throw the ball above the runner and the first baseman had no chance to catch it. No RLI.
So, the ump must take the throw as it comes. And then determine whether there was a realistic chance of getting the out on the throw that was made taking into account fielder placement, runner proximity to the bag, and location of the throw. Traditionally, in MLB they seem to give the benefit of the doubt to the team that is batting, which seems a little backward to me.
So, there was definitely hinderance of Pearce’s ability to make the play but is it realistic to assume the out would have been made? I don’t think so. I think the interference here affected the throw not the act of fielding by the the first baseman but it’s fucking close and reasonable minds totally can differ.
If the runner is not where he is supposed to be and he’s blocking your throw you have to drill him to get the call. So long as the first baseman is in position and the batter wasn’t about to touch first base, that’s the best way to show interence because that play always looks like the first baseman would make the play. But the runner causing the fielder to make a bad throw that then would have required a spectacular play by the first baseman is perhaps unfairly not RLI in MLB.