Who is the best Bruins Coach of all time?

Who is the best?

  • Art Ross

  • Lynn Patrick

  • Milt Schmidt

  • Harry Sinden

  • Don Cherry

  • Gerry Cheevers

  • Pat Burns

  • Claude Julien

  • Terry O'Reilly

  • Brian Sutter


Results are only viewable after voting.

Lose Remerswaal

Experiencing Furry Panic
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
The B's have had 27 head coaches. Many of them are from before any of us were born. None of us *really* know how good Art Ross was, but I'm listing the coaches who have coached the Bs in at least 250 games to see who rises to the top along with 2 other recent coaches with over 200 games
 

Red Right Ankle

Formerly the Story of Your Red Right Ankle
SoSH Member
Jul 2, 2006
11,978
Multivac
No coach has ever won more than 1 Cup with the Bruins. Had there been one, it probably would have made this easier. I picked Julien - 3rd in games coached, 1st in wins, 7th best points percentage with most of the coaches ahead of him having only coached 1-3 seasons, 3rd best playoff win percentage and 1 Stanley Cup. That's a hard resume to beat.

Anyways, fire CLODE
 
Mar 1, 2009
557
I'm going to get killed for this one but I think Mike Millbury deserves to be on the list. I don't think he should get any votes but deserves to be mentioned. That 90-91 team was the best in the post Orr/pre Clode era, and he was a big part of that.
 

mwonow

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 4, 2005
7,124
I voted for Grapes. He coached against a GOAT-level Montreal team - one that could put an all-HOF starting six on the ice - and got the Bs into OT of game 7.

After which Sinden fired him.

Can we have a different poll for "Bruins exec who has earned a one-way pass to eternal damnation?"
 

Dummy Hoy

Angry Pissbum
SoSH Member
Jul 22, 2006
8,241
Falmouth
You mean the guy who in his prime built multiple cup contending teams after coaching the team to a title after a 30 year drought? What a shithead.
 

timlinin8th

Member
SoSH Member
Jun 6, 2009
1,521
No coach has ever won more than 1 Cup with the Bruins. Had there been one, it probably would have made this easier. I picked Julien - 3rd in games coached, 1st in wins, 7th best points percentage with most of the coaches ahead of him having only coached 1-3 seasons, 3rd best playoff win percentage and 1 Stanley Cup. That's a hard resume to beat.

Anyways, fire CLODE
Adding to this, there's way more teams in Claude's NHL (and additional playoff rounds to reach a Cup), the salary cap and free agency means he's had to do it with a lot of roster turnover as well as front office changes... Credit where credit is due.
 

mwonow

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 4, 2005
7,124
You mean the guy who in his prime built multiple cup contending teams after coaching the team to a title after a 30 year drought? What a shithead.
His prime was fine.

His later years - including (/especially) Shawn McEachern for Trent McCleary (who, IIRC, was blind in one eye, but made up for it by being the lowest-paid guy in the league) were not.

More on that trade, listed as the second worst in B's history from 1972-on by Stanley Cup of Chowder:

"This draft day trade contributed mightily to Boston's dreadful 1996 draft, one that set a new low for incompetence and helped set the stage for the franchise's fall on hard times a few years later...Mitigating factor: That aforementioned fall upon hard times was what helped Harry Sinden decide to move to the sidelines. Sinden did a tremendous amount for the franchise; you'll notice that there aren't a lot of trades from the 70s and 80s up there. That's not because I'm lazy, it's because Harry Sinden had the magic touch back then. But he was losing that touch by this time, and it showed. Unfortunately, it took another 6 years after Sinden stepped aside before they got a GM who knew what he was doing, but hey, better late than never.

So yeah, Sinden didn't start out as a shithead, but he ended up there anyway.
 

lexrageorge

Member
SoSH Member
Jul 31, 2007
18,186
A discussion on Harry Sinden is probably thread-worthy in and of itself.

As coach, he was well respected by the players and fans. As GM, he was usually booed by the Garden faithful, but that started when he traded Phil Esposito, a trade that played a key role in Boston's rise in the late 1970's. I remember the era well; we all hated him as fans. But when we look back, we do see that he made a lot more good trades during his prime than bad ones.

Cherry vs Sinden was one of those polarizing moments. Cherry was a great coach, but he was starting to go off the deep end during the end of his time in Boston. He openly clashed with Sinden on just about everything, and took those clashes to both the media and the locker room. And any coach that bridged the gap between Bep Guidolin and Fred Creighton would appear to be first ballot HoF material.

Part of the problem with Sinden's legacy is that he hired and groomed Mike O'Connell, who turned out to be truly awful as GM. Ignore the revisionists among the Globe beat writers: that Thornton trade is one of the worst in league history, never mind Bruins history. Interestingly, the Secord-for-O'Connell trade, while not as bad as the 12 mentioned in the Stanley Cup for Chowder, turned into one that many Boston fans wanted to have back when the Bruins were going through a goal drought in the early-to-mid 1980's while Secord was putting up 213 goals for the Hawks.
 

mwonow

Member
SoSH Member
Sep 4, 2005
7,124
Secord was definitely one who got away. In 81-83 (two full seasons), he put up 98 goals and 483 PIMs. Yep, Bruins fans were really, really sorry to see him in another jersey!