I guess with the competitive balance pick included this is better return than they got for Peavy, but not by as much as I was expecting. Given the SABR orientation of the A's front office, it's probably the case that the difference between league average (Peavy) and great (Lester) over 12 starts just isn't all that big, so maybe that isn't a surprise.
Here's one of those Player A, Player B, Player C things:
Career vs. right handed pitchers (you know, the ones who pitch 70 percent of the games)
Player A: 222 / 307 / 415
Player B: 257 / 306 / 459
Player C: 291 / 387 / 428
Player B's BABip may rise about 20 points, Player C's BABip may or may not fall about 20 points.
Who do you want playing the 70 percent of the games against righthanders in 2015?