Dismiss Notice
Guest, I have a big favor to ask you. We've been working very hard to establish ourselves on social media. If you like/follow our pages it would be a HUGE help to us. SoSH on Facebook and Inside the Pylon Thanks! Nip

Manchester United 2018/2019: Third Season Voodoo

Discussion in 'Breakfast with Gazza (with Sachmoneious Bullcrap)' started by Zomp, Aug 10, 2018.

  1. OilCanShotTupac

    OilCanShotTupac Sunny von Bulow Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    16,071
    Your new manager:

    [​IMG]
     
  2. Zososoxfan

    Zososoxfan Well-Known Member Silver Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    4,653
    As a fan of the game, I want United to return to playing attractive attacking football. As a supporter of other clubs, I worry about United righting the ship, although from what I understand many of the problems are more systemic. I love Pogba, Rashford, Lukaku, and a few other United players and I want them to at least enjoy the game again.

    Billy Haisley wrote about United over at Deadspin, and he points out that Poch is a pipedream for United because Spurs are currently in a better situation and Real and Barca (I know Poch said he'd never go) would roll out a red carpet for him to come back to Spain. Zizou might actually be a good fit for this United, although I think he's stated that he wants to be back at Juve or managing France. Jardim is out of a job from what I can tell at the moment. Normally I'd float a name like Simeone, but I think he might be staying at Atleti for a long time. I think Di Francesco has done a solid job at Roma and is worth considering.

    As for Mou, he could certainly still find work in the club world, likely in Italy or Portugal if he chooses. But, I think it would be ideal for him to manage a national team. His strict and conservative approach suits the international game and he could still run circles around managers in that circuit. That being said, I wouldn't want him managing Argentina, but I think the US would be silly not to at least knock on his door. His cult of personality would likely be a hit for our media-driven culture here.
     
  3. OilCanShotTupac

    OilCanShotTupac Sunny von Bulow Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    16,071
    Hadn't thought of this, but you're right, it's awesome to think about. How insane would this be?
     
  4. 67YAZ

    67YAZ Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    1,266
    If only US Soccer had been more patient and didn't rush to snap up Berhalter...
     
  5. Zomp

    Zomp Turkey Virgin Dope

    Messages:
    10,974
    This is the quote from Haisley:

    Tottenham has a better squad right now, but to say it is a better situation and has a better outlook than United is ridiculous. I am not saying the board doesn't make a lot of mistakes. They do. But if they do it right, they could absolutely make a package that would entice Pochettino. Obviously, money is the first consideration. United could easily double his salary at Spurs. Secondly, if a Director of Football is hired that Pochettino likes (rumors are already flying that they want to get Paul Mitchel who Poch has worked closely with at Southampton and Spurs) then that could entice him as well. Thirdly, there have been stories at Poch being annoyed at the lack of net spend that Spurs have. Here that wouldn't be a problem. You could argue that Poch has done as well as he could with the Tottenham team, but at United he'd have a chance at building a perennial title challenging squad. The Real and Barca point is a decent one, but again he said he'd never manage Barca and rumors are point to Real going after Conte or Mourinho.


    Pochettino should be the number 1 candidate. If they can't get him, Zidane would be most interesting because I honestly have no idea how good of a tactician he is. I could have managed Ronaldo, Kroos, and Modric to a few trophies.

    No matter what, the club has to get a player's manager. Poch and Zidane fit that. Conte I don't think would.
     
  6. Cellar-Door

    Cellar-Door Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    13,448
    Doesn't meet 1 of the only 2 requirements for the job.
     
  7. DrewDawg

    DrewDawg Dorito Dink SoSH Member

    Messages:
    30,979
    You're correct about that, but the other point I've seen made is that Tottenham is essentially Pochettino FC right now. Why would he risk that?



    Of course, there's also this:

     
  8. fletcherpost

    fletcherpost sosh's feckin' poet laureate Lifetime Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    8,661
    This is an interesting one. What is Poch worth to Spurs? Not just in terms of how much to pay him, but how much to give him to reinforce the squad moving forwards? He'll do well to get top four this season and he didn't make any signings. That won't fly at the end of this season, and maybe Poch has some winter transfer targets. Seems he has a lot of leverage right now.

    Could Poch leave for Old Trafford at the end of the season and take two or three players with him. Harry Kane in a Man U shirt? Stranger things have happened.

    I'd like to see him stay at Spurs and keep building, but football is a cruel sport with little sentiment and loyalty. Levi knows this and doubtless has his abacus out as we speak.
     
  9. OilCanShotTupac

    OilCanShotTupac Sunny von Bulow Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    16,071
    As an Everton fan, I'm scared that Poch to ManU then means Silva to Spurs.

    If I've got my Everton glasses on I think that Everton may be a better job in the near future (3-5 years out). The owners have signaled that they want to spend money AND build a new stadium, whereas Spurs seem reluctant to pay in the transfer market. With their core group being younger, Everton can be said to be on the way up whereas the current iteration of Spurs may have peaked.

    You can all tell me to sit down and stop drinking now.
     
  10. koufax32

    koufax32 He'll cry if he wants to... SoSH Member

    Messages:
    6,534

    Well, you’re an Everton supporter so...
     
  11. PedroSpecialK

    PedroSpecialK Comes at you like a tornado of hair and the NHL sa Silver Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    23,368
    Interim appears to be Solskjær

    If memory serves, Moyes was announced in similar unintended fashion

    Apparently the Norwegian PM congratulated him on Twitter as well but has since deleted it
     
    #61 PedroSpecialK, Dec 18, 2018
    Last edited: Dec 18, 2018
  12. teddykgb

    teddykgb Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    6,724
    Maybe drink more because man are you gonna be disappointed.

    Poch would be crazy to go to United. He can get paid if he wants in Spain and inherit far more talented rosters. I don’t think Zidane is coaching that collection either (nor do I rate him I hope they convince him somehow). I think the interim approach makes sense as you never know who will shake loose and right now United needs to figure out which players can be resurrected. Every player is playing for a job again and whichever manager takes over is going to need more non Mourinho tainted info to make decisions
     
  13. coremiller

    coremiller Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    3,561
    I actually think Poch would not be a good fit at all at Man Utd unless they were totally willing to remake the club in his image, which I don't think they will. Poch is very much a my-way-or-the-high-way guy who hasn't really had to deal as much with strong egos and independent power centers in the dressing room. Partly that's because Spurs' best players were for the most part developed internally or bought cheaply (Kane, Eriksen, Alli), so they weren't big stars before Poch got there, and Levy mostly avoids the Mendes/Raiola clients. The players who have gotten too big for their britches (e.g. Walker, Rose, Alderweireld) have all gotten frozen out and lost power struggles, but Poch can get away with that at Spurs in a way he probably can't at United. It also helps a lot that Spurs' best player and tone-setter is an internal youth product with a strong work ethic. If Harry Kane isn't complaining about being underpaid (Kane's new deal is 150k/week, which he could probably double in a heartbeat at a richer club) or double fitness sessions or being played outside his preferred tactical role, it's hard for anyone else to complain.

    Also, Pochetino's pressing system is an awful fit for Man Utd's current personnel. It would take him 18 months and a huge spend to sort out the deadwood, and they might go backwards at first. And United's crew of overpaid coddled millionaires may not take to Poch's notoriously tough fitness training very well. Poch spent his first year at Spurs weeding out all the players he didn't want, he'd have to do the same at Man Utd.

    Of course, there are many millions of reasons why Poch might think that challenge is worth it.

    Hahahaahaha. You Toffees are cute. Spurs have Champions League football, a brand-new stadium in London (assuming it ever actually opens), close to double Everton's revenue, and at least 5-6 players who are all better than any single player in Everton's current squad or anyone Everton is likely to sign in the near future. Everton's most expensive signing and best creative player is a Spurs cast-off that Spurs dumped because he couldn't get in the team (and he still wouldn't). Silva leaves for Spurs in a heartbeat if the option is there.
     
  14. Zomp

    Zomp Turkey Virgin Dope

    Messages:
    10,974
    I don't understand the thought that says Spurs is Poch FC. He has repeatedly said he cannot buy the players he wants and that because of the new stadium he is operating on a restricted budget. That does not sound like someone who is in total control of his squad.

    Of course he'd need a few seasons to get the deadwood out and tailor his team to his system. I'm not sure anyone would expect anything different. It's not like Mourinho wasn't given enough time, his team just went backwards over the course of a few seasons. "United's crew of overpaid coddled millionaires". Come on. Is there anyone who thinks that Mourinho coddled anyone? Are a few overpaid? Definitely.

    I think players like Pogba, Rashford, Lindelof, and Martial would benefit greatly from him coming in. It's difficult to say the pressing system is an awful fit for the current personnel when Mourinho's philosophy was the exact opposite. How can we know if its a bad fit?



    Look, it probably won't happen because I don't think Woodward has the intelligence to deal with Levy. But Poch should, and would, be interested in the job. At the end of the day I've gotten used to the board not doing anything right so I'm assuming during the summer we'll be hiring someone like....I dunno, Conte or Blanc. But the job is still desirable for the right type of manager.
     
  15. Dernells Casket n Flagon

    Dernells Casket n Flagon Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    3,126
    Maybe this is a separate topic, but assuming every club had no manager what would be the most desirable football clubs to manage?

    Similar to college football, there are perennial top programs that even on a dip are desirable due to their location, history resources (Alabama, Michigan, ND, Texas, etc), where there's probably a list of 5-10. Then there's a list of second tier where the current specifics can make programs better fits and more desirable.

    What's that top Tier for football? Barca, Real Madrid, Bayern, Juventus are obvious non-English clubs, but I think ManU might be the only permanent English fixture right in that same tier. I agree that it'd be crazy for Poch not to strongly consider a move from Spurs to Manchester.
     
  16. Vinho Tinto

    Vinho Tinto Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    5,369
    I don’t follow the EPL as fiercely as many here, but I haven’t been this confused since City’s initial spending spree led posters to proclaim those player we’re making a mistake - City may have been offerering more money, but it was a club without prestige.

    Managers and players aren’t hot properties forever. Few clubs in the world can match United’s revenues. The issue has been their management. They are throwing spaghetti on the wall and wondering why it isn’t sticking. If control over the roster matters to Pochettino, he will get more of that at United than Madrid. Madrid holds a similar opinion to their managers as Billy Beane holds his. He would manage the players they want there and have no input.

    United clearly has a higher ceiling than Spurs. I don’t even comprehend how anyone could think otherwise. Spurs at their best competes for the FA Cup and the top 4, while United would be on the shortlist of EPL and CL favorites.
     
  17. Kliq

    Kliq Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    8,366
    Historically, Manchester United would be a much better coaching situation than Spurs. However, since Fergie left , United has finished 7th, 4th, 5th, 6th, 2nd, and where ever they end up this season, which I assume is probably going to be 6th. Now maybe they have only finished that low because of poor management and Poch would be able to turn it around with all of Man U’s money, but the fact is that since Fergie retired, Man U has pretty much consistently been outside of the Top 4.

    I’d agree the United job is attractive due to the financial support; but it’s been a while since United was a top tier team on the same level as Barca, Real, City, Bayern and Juventus.
     
  18. Zomp

    Zomp Turkey Virgin Dope

    Messages:
    10,974
    Right but nobody is arguing that. The argument is between Spurs and United. Since Fergie left, United as a club has underperformed. Spurs have arguably overperformed.

    And the clubs you listed, only Barca, Bayern, and City are clearly above them. It wasn’t too long ago that Serie A was where coaches and players went to enjoy the last few seasons of their career. As far as Real goes, it’s certainly tempting but I could see some coaches staying away because of the demands of the job.
     
  19. Kliq

    Kliq Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    8,366
    I’m arguing that as things currently stand, for Poch, it’s not that obvious that United is a job with a higher potential than Spurs right now. Yes there is more money; but United has had more money since Fergie left and they haven’t been an elite team under multiple managers, which to me that suggests that there is a problem at United beyond just the manager being a poor fit.
     
  20. Morgan's Magic Snowplow

    Morgan's Magic Snowplow Well-Known Member Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    15,870
    Fully agreed.

    The current Spurs side is better but its really hard to see them challenging City or Liverpool in the next couple years, especially given their financial constraints, a number of aging players in the spine of the team, and the very real possibility of losing Eriksen.

    United is dysfunctional and the current roster isn't ideal for Poch's system but their spending power and name brand attraction give them a much higher ceiling. Its not that hard to imagine United spending another $300-400M over the next couple years, actually getting it right this time in terms of what players are bought and how they're integrated into existing talent, and putting together a team capable of winning the league or making a run in the CL.
     
  21. OilCanShotTupac

    OilCanShotTupac Sunny von Bulow Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    16,071
    Listening to a podcast and just lol’d on a train- they called Jose “the Portuguese Pulis.”
     
  22. DrewDawg

    DrewDawg Dorito Dink SoSH Member

    Messages:
    30,979
    Does there come a point where we can stop saying Spurs "overperformed" and ManU "underperformed" when Spurs have more points than them over the past 6 seasons and finished ahead of them 3 of the past 4?

    That's *not* to say ManU doesn't have the resources to climb back over them, but maybe Spurs success shouldn't be treated as a fluke.
     
  23. Jimy Hendrix

    Jimy Hendrix Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    3,150
    I think we’ll know Manchester United is serious again when Woodward is gently ushered away from the football side of their management structure back into the loving arms of only doing commercial deals.

    United have vastly more resources than Spurs, but unless Poch or someone who knows about football and is simpatico with Poch is in control of those resources, the amount of good they can do is limited.

    If Paul Mitchell or someone similar actually takes that role and if Woodward isn't still above him with the final say based on how the player fits into the Asian tire endorsement market, then I'd be worried as a fan of other clubs.
     
  24. OilCanShotTupac

    OilCanShotTupac Sunny von Bulow Gold Supporter SoSH Member

    Messages:
    16,071
    Philosophically: is there a diminishing return on money, as far as buying big-name players and trying to knit a team out of them?

    The fantasy-team approach at United has been a failure. Not only are there guys like Pogba and Lukaku underachieving because the lack of a system fit (or lack of a system period), but you have guys like Alexis and Fred not even starting, who cost huge sums of money.

    PSG is another team that spends gobs of money on superstars but can't seem to crest past a certain point. They're shoo-ins for the CL because they're so much stronger than the rest of their domestic league, but I've never felt like they were the best team in the world or the favorite to win the CL. I would call them underachievers relative to their spend.

    City obviously can break the bank for whoever they want, but that team has "roleplayers" mixed in with the superstars who aren't within the top-ten names in the world at their positions, or whatever. You can say the same for RM, Barca, Bayern, etc.

    This isn't stunning insight, I know.
     
  25. Zomp

    Zomp Turkey Virgin Dope

    Messages:
    10,974
    Well city’s role players still cost ridiculous sums of money.

    The biggest difference between city and teams like PSG and United are City cane up with a vision and plan years ago that they’ve stuck to and executed. Woodward has not stuck to any plan because he denied Mourinhos requests for transfers.

    As much as Mourinho wasn’t a fit, Woodward is equally to blame. If you have a manager that has a certain way of playing and identifies certain players, you have to buy them. Looking back the season was doomed from preseason once they started battling on targets.

    Hopefully Woodward, who to be fair is very good at the business side of things, hires a DoF and stays out of their way. The argument has always been with the money United has generated they should be competing every year. That hasn’t happened in a while but it certainly should with the right staff in place.
     
  26. scott bankheadcase

    scott bankheadcase Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    589
    Te weird part to Paul Mitchell, for anyone who doesn't closely follow Spurs, he doesn't work well with Poch. Poch basically got him fired from Tottenham and took over control. ManU hiring him is a boon for Poch staying at Spurs.
     
  27. scott bankheadcase

    scott bankheadcase Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    589
    Maybe he'd have more input at ManU than Madrid. But the comparison right now is ManU and Tottenham. He has full control and deals directly with Levy on all players. No board, no other player talent voices, just Poch and Levy. He's also one of the higher paid managers in the EPL. I'm sure ManU would raise the salary, but Spurs are paying him (they just don't pay for players).

    I think it more likely he goes to Madrid in 2 years, he's talked frequently about eventually wanting to go back to Spain before taking the argentina national team job.
     
  28. DrewDawg

    DrewDawg Dorito Dink SoSH Member

    Messages:
    30,979
    Southgate added to ManU’s shortlist per everyone on twitter.
     
  29. Zomp

    Zomp Turkey Virgin Dope

    Messages:
    10,974
    Anyone reliable?
     
  30. 67YAZ

    67YAZ Member SoSH Member

    Messages:
    1,266
    Makes good sense to interview Southgate just to improve the scouting reports on the English player pool.
     

Share This Page