Liverpool 2017-18: Salah Days are Here

SoxFanInCali

has the rich, deep voice of a god
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jun 3, 2005
15,602
California. Duh.
Salah with a sweet volley from a Mane cross makes it 2-0. Great work by Mane to keep the play alive and get the cross in.
 

PedroSpecialK

Comes at you like a tornado of hair and the NHL sa
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2004
27,168
Cambridge, MA
Salah seals it. He is approaching Suarez levels of effectiveness (though he is obviously more pace-driven than a pure genius)

This may be the first time I'm happy to have captained a player who didn't start.
 

SoxFanInCali

has the rich, deep voice of a god
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jun 3, 2005
15,602
California. Duh.
Almost blew the clean sheet but somehow Diouf blew two point blank chances within 3 seconds. One off the post and another over the bar.
 

wonderland

New Member
Jul 20, 2005
532
I’m biased against Liverpool but I have no idea how that wasn’t a red card. Any reasonable explanations?
 

PedroSpecialK

Comes at you like a tornado of hair and the NHL sa
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2004
27,168
Cambridge, MA
Agreed that it should have been a red. He was last man, clear goal scoring opportunity, got 0% of the ball.
 

SoxFanInCali

has the rich, deep voice of a god
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jun 3, 2005
15,602
California. Duh.
Apparently Matip has a thigh injury and will be out until the new year.

Good thing there aren't a lot of games coming up or anything...
 

67YAZ

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2000
8,807
Line up for CL match day 6:
Karius in goal, Gomez-Klavan-Lovren-Moreno across the back, Can & Wijnaldum in the midfield, Coutinho (captain)-Mane-Firmino-Salah in attack.

'Pool need a draw to go through, and a win will lock up the group. This strikes me as a particularly attack-minded line up. But an early Spartak goal would make me feel awfully nauseous.
 

PedroSpecialK

Comes at you like a tornado of hair and the NHL sa
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2004
27,168
Cambridge, MA
7-0 final, onto the knockout stages in pot 1.

I would have started to feel badly for Spartak towards the end of that drubbing... but given that Rhian Brewster was racially abused by a Spartak player in a youth game today, and that Spartak supporters made racist chants and gestures towards Bobby Adekanye in the last youth match, I'm good with this outcome.
 

SoxFanInCali

has the rich, deep voice of a god
Lifetime Member
SoSH Member
Jun 3, 2005
15,602
California. Duh.
Possible draws:

Hope for: Basel, Shakhtar, or Porto
Will probably get: Real, Juve, or Bayern

Can't draw Sevilla because they were in our group, or Chelsea because of country protection.
 

67YAZ

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2000
8,807
Some stray thoughts...

Taking 10 of 12 points through the insane English holiday season is fantastic, even if the draw with Arsenal was a major let down. I'm not putting a lot of emphasis on tomorrow's FA Cup Derby because...well, I'm not English and I think the league and Champions League are much more important this season (a top 4 finish and quarter final appearance, respectively, would be success; anything more would be a bonus). I'll be keen to see VVD in action, though. And then Man City on Sunday, which should be fun.

Gomez has had a bunch of troubling mental lapses of late, some leading to really bad goals. The physical talent is there, but he's got to lock into the games much better. Fortunately, Clyne should be back soon (last report I saw said early-February), which I think would make Gomez emergency cover for RB & CB.

On the other side, I'm very much enjoying Robertson's turn in relief of Moreno. His crosses are almost always really threatening, and he has great awareness/instincts. But he doses't have great speed, which sometimes forces Henderson or Can to slide over and cover for him...and those two aren't particularly pacey, either. Speaking of Man City, their right-side wingers could be a big problem.

Whatever the cost, VVD was an upgrade this team needs. I also hope they make a run at signing Stefan de Vrij on a free (lock him up this month, comes over in July). For all the Coutinho concern, I'm more worried about replacing Firmino should that guy get injured or wooed by a big money offer. There's currently no replacement for his skillset and work rate. I'm not sure there is a realistic replacement out there for him, but it needs to be explored.
 

SocrManiac

Tommy Seebach’s mustache
SoSH Member
Apr 15, 2006
8,680
Somers, CT
I'll add a few...

Agreed with the point haul. It's frustrating to have that "what if" of the Arsenal drop.

As part of that... I'd like to dispute the Mignolet "howler" a bit. It can't be overstated how difficult it is to judge a rocket knuckling at you. I'm nowhere near the professional level and probably have never even faced a shot hit with that pace. I've had a few similar shots that have made me look absolutely foolish. It happens to professionals, too:

1. Hart against Pirlo's free kick:
Hart has become something of a punchline of late, but what would the narrative have been if that went in? The artistry of the shot or Hart's ineptitude?

2. Weidenfeller against Calhanoglu's free kick:
This illustrates what the modern ball is capable of. It does simply insane shit, and with the pace of a professional's shot if it happens late, there's nothing the keeper can do. Look how far the ball has traveled before it breaks. Watch the spin. How could you possibly predict that as a keeper? Weidenfeller isn't young here, but certainly experienced in reading the ball. What is there to read?

Enough on that...

Solanke is utterly awful. I see absolutely nothing positive. Poor workrate, dumb as a stump, hides behind defenders... Just get him off the field.

I've had a hard time believing that internal competition truly brings out the best in players at the professional level. It might be dependent on the individual whether it's seen as motivation or an insecurity. Regardless, I can't deny the change in Lovren. I'm maintaining my faith in Klopp that he won't revert to a back 3 made up of central defenders to experiment with getting more attacking talent on the pitch. I can't relive those Brendan Rodgers days...

If Lallana could stay healthy, he might be the Firmino insurance, or at least part of the policy. He's not made of Sturridge-level tissue paper, thankfully, but you certainly can't build plans around him. It'd be nice to get Bobby off the field a bit more.

The Nike website gaffe was the first indicator outside of the utterly insane media that something might happen with Coutinho this window. I can't imagine selling him now, but stranger things have happened.

My first true footy love is Juventus, and their pursuit of Emre Can shouldn't be dismissed. They've had an insane eye for plucking blossoming or overlooked players and turning them into world beaters. Some outlets will have you believe the deal is done, but should Liverpool do what they can to lock him up? Even with Keita coming in, you can't count on Henderson to stay on the pitch. Hell, even Can has had his issues. The central, roving midfielder is too important to be a question mark. Right now it's a massive one.
 

67YAZ

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2000
8,807
The Nike “mistake” was telling. I can’t see Barca buying now, though, since Coutinho is tied up for the Champuons League and they own a massive lead in La Liga. But I suppose a desperate mega-club is liable to do anything to appease the fans.

I think Can is gone, and that’s ok. He’s been clear that he wants to play a deeper role that requires fewer forward runs, and Klopp keeps putting him in that box-to-box role that Kieta will fill next year. At Juve, he’s probably been promised Khediera’s job...and will excel at it. Happy for him, don’t think it was going to work out as well under Klopp.

I agree that another excellent midfielder is necessary given Lallana & Henderson’s struggles to stay healthy. Goretzka would be a dream, but you have to figure there is no way Bayern lets a domestic talent that huge head abroad. If there is a way to poach Kovacic from Madrid, I’d love to find it. More realistically, Ruben Neves could be a nice young option. Or if Fenway Sports is dyeing for an American, there’s Weston McKinnie...
 
Last edited:

Mighty Joe Young

The North remembers
SoSH Member
Sep 14, 2002
8,458
Halifax, Nova Scotia , Canada
I agree Goretzka would be an intriguing - if unlikely - signing. His skillset is more or less duplicated by Keita though.

I suppose when Coutinho inevitably leaves, Keita can fill that role wih Goretzka filling Can's. I'd prefer a Henderson upgrade.

Regarding Solanke - he has looked decent when brought on late in games IMO but has been rubbish when starting - maybe nerves? Most of what I've read suggests his work rate is fine - but has lacked composure. He was awful against Burnley.

.
 

Mighty Joe Young

The North remembers
SoSH Member
Sep 14, 2002
8,458
Halifax, Nova Scotia , Canada
So ..

Coutinho is gone for 143 million pounds , so what's next.

Immediate reports of Mahrez as a replacement have been quickly shot down .. I thought that unlikely (and unwise due to a lack of fit) anyways.

So what's next ?

One would think Lemar is the obvious replacement as they wanted him in the summer .. but he's going to be expensive, his form has reportedly slipped this year and Monaco will either not sell or demand a premium for a January transfer. 100m £ well spent?

Given Klopp's past willingness (stubbornness?) to wait on guys he has targeted (VVD, Keita), I'm guessing no obvious replacement comes in this window if they can't get Lemar.

IMO this is the correct way to proceed. It's a gamble as it threatens a top 4 finish. But knee jerk responses such as Mahrez or Lanzini would be marginal upgrades at best and limit options going forward.

Edit: Andy Hunter at the Guardian with a good summary

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2018/jan/07/philippe-coutinho-transfer-barcelona-liverpool-jurgen-klopp-legacy
 
Last edited:

67YAZ

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2000
8,807
I'd prefer a Henderson upgrade.
I've been turning over this thought, and it has come to make the most sense for this coming summer: use Keita to replace Coutinho, bring in a true DM, and push Henderson into Can's box-to-box role. Henderson has worked hard to make himself into a solid DM/holding mid, but he's doesn't quite read the game well enough to be the shield that the CBs need. Plus, playing so deep mitigates a couple of his strengths - mid-range passing and late runs into the box.

So forget Lemar, focus on Fabinho.
 

Mighty Joe Young

The North remembers
SoSH Member
Sep 14, 2002
8,458
Halifax, Nova Scotia , Canada
Don't you just love the January Transfer Window

This is promising .. the Echo (via Bild) is reporting Liverpool can bring in Naby Keita in January .. for a mere £13m (or thereabouts)

http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/transfer-news/rb-leipzig-midfielder-naby-keita-14138844

That would certainly solve the immediate need to replace Coutinho .. and remove the possibility of any panic buys this window.

There were also reports that Thomas Lemar's reported price has dropped significantly - although a tussle with Arsenal would be inevitable.

I'm starting to get the feeling Pulisic is the ultimate summer target. Signing Lemar right now would seem to preclude Pulisic.

I tend to agree with 67Yaz .. a world class DM would seem to improve the squad more than another attacking mid.
 

SocrManiac

Tommy Seebach’s mustache
SoSH Member
Apr 15, 2006
8,680
Somers, CT
Adding another yay to the chorus for a CDM. With Henderson made of Sturridge and Emre Can off to Juventus in the summer, now isn't an awful time to strike for a major position of need.

When you watch the team play as currently constructed, it's amazing how compact the opponents can be on defense. The threat of an accurate cross field pass connecting is so low they it's practically invited. Adding that Hollywood long ball possibility will create the space needed for the front four to operate and really help unlock some of the weaker sides.
 

PedroSpecialK

Comes at you like a tornado of hair and the NHL sa
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2004
27,168
Cambridge, MA
Lots of smoke now to Leipzig relenting and letting Keïta leave for an additional fee- £17m is the rumored amount.

If Keïta leaves and Leipzig qualify for CL without him, the payment for the summer transfer would remain £53m. If he stayed and they qualified it would have risen to £66m - in essence, getting him now for £17m is an effective £4m hedge assuming RBL would qualify regardless.

If they get Keïta in this window, Coutinho stings a lot less. If they can also nab Lemar, I’d feel better about their chances than I did a week ago.

Links:

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2018/jan/11/liverpool-naby-keita-extra-17m-bring-forward-signing
 

Clears Cleaver

Lil' Bill
SoSH Member
Aug 1, 2001
11,370
Does anyone believe the pulisic rumors? I can see FSG doing something like this. I’m just not sure it’s what the team needs. But I’d be pumped if it worked out.

Basically would be replacement for firmino I guess
 

PedroSpecialK

Comes at you like a tornado of hair and the NHL sa
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2004
27,168
Cambridge, MA
I don't think Firmino needs replacing - Joyce is saying he's in line for a new long-term deal (with Bascome hyperbolically saying Klopp wants to keep Firmino at Anfield for the rest of his career)
 

Dummy Hoy

Angry Pissbum
SoSH Member
Jul 22, 2006
8,246
Falmouth
All I know is that all he's ever said is that he wants to get regular playing time. I don't see the rush for him to bolt Dortmund when he's pretty happy there by all accounts. He and his dad have made smart moves every step of the way, I doubt they do anything too rash now just because there's some dollars being thrown around.
 

67YAZ

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2000
8,807
Does anyone believe the pulisic rumors? I can see FSG doing something like this. I’m just not sure it’s what the team needs. But I’d be pumped if it worked out.

Basically would be replacement for firmino I guess
Pulisic's skillset is very comparable to Mane & Salah. He's a clear system fit and a ready placement if Salah does get snapped up by a mega club. Plus, I think the biggest clubs see Pulisic as a great way to grow their brand in the US. I'd buy a Pulisic Liverpool jersey in a heartbeat.

Pulisic has shown himself to be pretty savvy so far, and his next move will be a key one. He's not a finished product, but he is in a position to earn a bigger salary and garner more exposure. A move away from Dortmund is inevitable in the next few years, but it has to be to a place where he will get good support, great training, and plenty of game time. Madrid's history is littered with uber-talented kids wasting away on the bench when the could be key players in other top sides: Ceballos, Kovacic, James, Illaramendi...
 

67YAZ

Member
SoSH Member
Dec 1, 2000
8,807
Helluva match. Taped it and somehow managed to avoid all news about it. Wow.

Gomez, man...the mental lapses are just killing him and the team. I'm eagerly waiting on any Clyne news.

I was wrong about Robertson. He showed off the wheels and the will to hang with City's wingers. (It helped that Sterling was pissing his pants out there.)

I don't get the Karius-Mingolet thing, either. But Klopp has some plan he's working here, I have to hope. To me, Mingolet at least has one world class skill - shot stopping - otherwise he and Karius are each a jumble of good to excellent skills, which sometimes get exposed.

@Swansea, West Brom, and @Huddersfield see out the month with Spurs coming to Anfield on Feb 4. This is a key stretch to rack up some points before the CL starts up again.
 

PedroSpecialK

Comes at you like a tornado of hair and the NHL sa
SoSH Member
Dec 12, 2004
27,168
Cambridge, MA
There’s a post on Lovren’s IG that some are taking as indication that Can has signed a new contract
 
Last edited:

SocrManiac

Tommy Seebach’s mustache
SoSH Member
Apr 15, 2006
8,680
Somers, CT
I need to eat some crow...

Ox blew me away yesterday. I’m happy he scored (on a fairly poorly placed effort, no less), but that wasn’t his biggest contribution. His work rate in the press was vital, and his disruption of Fernandinho in particular was a major key to the victory. In fact, I’m going to go pretty far with this... Liverpool don’t win that one with Coutinho in his place.

If Karius is better with the ball at his feet, it’s not by a margin that excuses his inferior shot stopping. He has no confidence at all and that’s reflected by his defense. He’s the first non-Ozil German I’ve seen that consistently has a deer in the headlights look. I said it elsewhere- we don’t see what happens in training. In this case, we don’t need to. Even if he’s vastly superior during the week, it’s absolutely not translating.

Firmino’s goal was beautiful. He needs to stop taking his shirt off. I’m sick and tired of this utterly selfish celebration. There were 30 minutes left against a superior opponent and he’s taken the tactical foul out of his pocket. He’s also going to earn a suspension at some point. Klopp needs to address this.

That was a super important win and a wonderful statement. It’ll be a fun second half, especially once VVD acclimated and Clyne finds his way back.
 

Mighty Joe Young

The North remembers
SoSH Member
Sep 14, 2002
8,458
Halifax, Nova Scotia , Canada
Helluva match. Taped it and somehow managed to avoid all news about it. Wow.

Gomez, man...the mental lapses are just killing him and the team. I'm eagerly waiting on any Clyne news.

I was wrong about Robertson. He showed off the wheels and the will to hang with City's wingers. (It helped that Sterling was pissing his pants out there.)

I don't get the Karius-Mingolet thing, either. But Klopp has some plan he's working here, I have to hope. To me, Mingolet at least has one world class skill - shot stopping - otherwise he and Karius are each a jumble of good to excellent skills, which sometimes get exposed.

@Swansea, West Brom, and @Huddersfield see out the month with Spurs coming to Anfield on Feb 4. This is a key stretch to rack up some points before the CL starts up again.
The only way the Karius-as#1 move makes any sense is that Klopp simply wants to prove that Karius can't be what they'd hoped when they signed him. He simply hasn't had enough playing time to get a real handle on his abilities. If he's sucking because of a lack of confidence then the only remedy is lots of games and a run of success. I think the move was made before the City game because they were more likely to test him. Remember, Karius started against Arsenal early in the year too - another puzzling decision. You probably aren't going to find out much against the league's Lesser lights.

The other thing is the 'Pool defence simply doesn't give up a lot of shots. City had 4 shots on Sunday and 3 went in. That's been pretty much true for most of their games. Hopefully VVD's influence will cut down on the quality shots.
 

SocrManiac

Tommy Seebach’s mustache
SoSH Member
Apr 15, 2006
8,680
Somers, CT
Klopp reiterated the GK situation today in his presser.

I've been trying to build a rationale for this that makes sense, at least for myself. Otherwise, every time Karius flaps at a shot I'm going to go white-hot with anger.

The tryout does make some sense, but only if the team is in its final position. Are they in a position where they can leak goals just to see if Karius is the guy? Frankly, I think it's clear he's not. It's buy now or play your best option until the summer. The CL place is too tenuous and too valuable.

The only thing I've come up with is that Klopp doesn't want to waste VVD's gelling period with Mignolet. Does he see something synergistic between Karius and VVD? Maybe a confidence boost for a keeper that's otherwise struggled?
 

SocrManiac

Tommy Seebach’s mustache
SoSH Member
Apr 15, 2006
8,680
Somers, CT
So, once again, we’re staring at the expected three points out of six from two games. Once again, it’s grabbing the unexpected three from the powerhouse opponent and inexcusably dropping three to a Championship side. It’s absolutely infuriating.